4 ms·
I thought the big deal with EternalBlue is that the Shadow Brokers released the NSA's hacking trove as open-source, thus opening it up to all sorts of people wi
by nostrademons 7y ago
I thought the big deal with EternalBlue is that the Shadow Brokers released the NSA's hacking trove as open-source, thus opening it up to all sorts of people with minimal technical skills. There's a big difference between having a zero-day but requiring the technical chops to turn it into a working exploit, and downloading a file off the Internet and running it.
There's this huge pandora's box about opening up state-level weaponry to the general public. Ultimately, it undermines the nation state as an organizing principle. And that's the world we live in now.
(For that matter, all these attacks are credited to Russia or North Korea or Iran - but do we actually have any evidence that that's who's behind them? Couldn't it just as easily be a teenager in his bed in upstate NY who has compromised a server in Russia? $100K in Bitcoin ransom is peanuts for a nation-state and would even be peanuts for a number of Silicon Valley techies on this site, but it's a lot of money to a high school kid.)
- sterlind 7y agoThis BlackHat keynote[0] makes the good point that cyberattacks by other countries, especially Russia (the 'bears') work fundamentally differently from the US. In the US, private companies aren't allowed to do any hacking whatsoever, and organized crime is swiftly prosecuted by the FBI. The NSA would often have a dozen meetings before changing course on an operation... the bureaucracy is slow and autonomy is non-existent. In Russia, there is no extradition for hackers, and it's rare for someone to be prosecuted for ransomware. Malware writers and organized crime rings form a loose network with Kremlin officials. Attacks are done as favors, or even launched because the hackers think Putin would like it. Guccifer 2.0 is a prime example of this.. their espionage op against the DNC got blown, and 12 hours later they relaunched the op as a hacktivist campaign. It's altogether more casual and efficient. As a bonus, you don't have to pay your hackers if you let them make their own profits... hence all the ransomware. $100k is a good haul for an enterprising Russian criminal. 0. https://youtu.be/gvS4efEakpY https://youtu.be/gvS4efEakpY
- chupasaurus 7y agoCorrections: > it's rare for someone to be prosecuted for ransomware. Because of the choice between prison time with blackmail and other dirty deeds or working on the 3-letter organization. Russian law enforcement agencies are large criminal organizations themselves. > Malware writers and organized crime rings form a loose network with Kremlin officials. Those form a very tight network, former also with Lubyanka officials (location of FSB HQ).
- paulie_a 7y agoThere has been pretty strong attribution for NK in the past doing ransomware. 100k isn't a lot but you are talking about NK, a country that has it's diplomats selling meth and heroin
- blotter_paper 7y ago> There's this huge pandora's box about opening up state-level weaponry to the general public. Ultimately, it undermines the nation state as an organizing principle. And that's the world we live in now. I feel like this point is hardly ever appreciated. I don't think we quite live in that world (where's my open source nuke?), but we're always oscillating on the continuum if we take a long enough view of the situation. The extent to which power is distributed relies on the extent to which technology is distributed, but also the extent to which the distributed technology can be utilised by a relatively small group. A small group with equally good spear designs still loses to the larger group. A small group with equally good drones, nukes, viruses, and firewalls might be able to put up something closer to an even fight. A radical open sourcing of technology might lead to a breakup of the modern nation state into smaller entities. Until it does, or some sort of parallel structures form alongside the nation states which they are unable to actually police, I wouldn't call them undermined. The parallel structure scenario might be somewhat arguable today, but always has been; the line between organized crime and government is blurry. I don't think we've moved significantly far in that direction as a result of open source tools yet. If there ever comes a day when private defense contractors can accept Bitcoin without KYC and taxes, just rolling through the streets in a small division of tanks selling AK-47s to passing school children, I'll completely agree that the nation state has been undermined.
- ethbro 7y agoImho, what keeps the nation-state from being undermined by the techno-anarchist crowd is the requirement to hold territory. Any halfway competent person in a number of fields (cyber security, virology, chemistry) could probably "take over" a small town with a few buddies. And then the US government surrounds it. Blockades it. Allows nothing in or out. And waits. As the Palestinians, South Sudanese, Tibetans, Taiwanese, Hongkongers have found (with varying degrees of success), independence is only viable as a going concern if you have international allies and trade.
- blotter_paper 7y agoAgree completely. I think this is one of the reasons for so much interest in seasteading despite the high barrier of entry and maintenance compared to living on land (not that a group of ships can't be surrounded and sanctioned). Ultimately, I fear that joining the WMD club is a prerequisite to true self determination.