5 ms·
Legislation is not meant for you (at least for now). It's meant for those who cannot/do not know how to protect themselves.
by oblio 7y ago
Legislation is not meant for you (at least for now).
It's meant for those who cannot/do not know how to protect themselves.
- friedman23 7y ago>It's meant for those who cannot/do not know how to protect themselves. Like EU media giants?
- sprayk 7y agoAnd now those who cannot/do not know how to protect themselves will be unable to start a business on the internet in the EU. Do you think these two groups have to be mutually exclusive?
- toomuchtodo 7y agoProtecting the masses is more important than edge cases. Most people will never start an internet business.
- btilly 7y agoWithout the people who start business type X, we won't have competition in business type X. Therefore a law that makes it hard to start businesses of type X will affect you whether or not you ever intend to start such businesses. This applies for any X that you care to name, including "internet". If you believe that you can both pass regulations that make businesses of type X harder to form, and enjoy the benefits of having new businesses of type X around, then there is probably a big flaw in your thinking.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIn case of GDPR, X is "businesses abusing people's data", which essentially boils down to "adtech". We don't need more competition in adtech. We need adtech to die.
- btilly 7y agoNo, X is "businesses that handle people's data". For whatever reason. The goal is to regulate adtech. But the effect is to impose regulatory costs on every company that wants to have a discussion forum on their website. (And the upcoming copyright bill is even worse.)
- jdietrich 7y agoHandling other people's personal data is a serious responsibility. GDPR imposes regulatory costs, in the same way that health and safety or environmental protection legislation imposes regulatory costs. It's not creating any new costs, it's just properly pricing an externality. https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2016/03/data_is_a_toxic.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2016/03/data_is_a_tox...
- kelnos 7y agoIn the case where X is what you describe, then fine. If they can't start their company and simultaneously treat my private data with respect and care, then I don't care for them to exist. The cost of business going up isn't necessarily a bad thing, if we're getting something valuable in return (IMO we are). The question is whether or not the increased cost is prohibitive, and you have not provided any evidence to suggest that's the case.
- UncleEntity 7y ago> The question is whether or not the increased cost is prohibitive, and you have not provided any evidence to suggest that's the case. The thousands of companies that just block EU citizens rather than comply seems to suggest that they feel the cost is prohibitive. As for more direct hard evidence I believe this would fall into the "unseen" category in Bastiat's That Which is Seen, and That Which is Not Seen and is, in effect, calling on someone to prove a negative.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> The thousands of companies that just block EU citizens rather than comply seems to suggest that they feel the cost is prohibitive. They block EU because they deem compliance not worth the effort (now), usually because they get more than enough from their US markets. This doesn't mean the costs are prohibitive. Thousands more companies didn't block EU citizens. Some companies (notably news sites) even started to offer a superior product to EU citizens (e.g. plaintext news). Also, even with those blocking EU or shutting down, nothing of importance is lost. These companies have competitors that are less abusive, who do fine.
- MaxBarraclough 7y agoI don't see how this answers the point. I'm of the opinion that privacy regulation is a good idea, but it's trivially true that it's an additional burden for start-ups. The Is it worth it? question is a legitimate one.
- fromMars 7y agoHonestly, the biggest problem with GDPR is it's current implementation, i.e. the on demand wipeouts.