3 ms·
The Copenhagen Catalog: Principles for a new direction in tech
- Jun8 7y agoThis one of the few that resonated with me: #readpoetry It is difficult to get the news from poems yet men die miserably every day for lack of what is found there.
- skybrian 7y agoWell, it's good marketing, maybe, but this is an assertion made without evidence, and the author may have been biased.
- njepa 7y agoI don't disapprove, though it does seem a bit out of touch. Maybe developers aren't the most thoughtful people, but the state of things isn't without reason. If you moved to another city, you are paying a lot of rent, you work as a contractor (or other "flexible" employment), you have student loans, potentially a mortgage, you don't know how long you have this career and there isn't any employee organization to back you up then "values" doesn't come first. You should change the way investors, schools, companies and societies work.
- adjkant 7y agoI mean investors, schools, companies, and societies are all made up of people. It isn't only aimed at developers. That said, even with those factors, many employees in tech today 100% have ways they can influence the way companies interact with these values, even in small ways. More nuanced yes but I don't think its fair to say it's out of touch. Especially if this hits its goal and is displayed in many places, social pressures can help at both the developer and company level.
- charles_f 7y agoWith compilers come responsibilities. And sometimes a usable debugger.
- ghufran_syed 7y ago"Principle: a fundamental truth or proposition that serves as the foundation for a system of belief or behavior or for a chain of reasoning." These aren't 150 "principles" - more like "150 feel-good marketing statements". Or perhaps I should say, "virtue-signalling statements" Taking just one example : "Make business human to human instead of b2b or b2c - let's build companies that have humans at the core" Consumers are human, and businesses are made up of humans, so what exactly is this saying? It seems like "humanity" and "humans" are bing used as a synonym for "good", which makes the whole thing trivial. If we were serious about something like this, we would try and find 1, 3 or 5 "principles" out of the 150, then we would actually be doing some real thinking in terms of what things mean, relative importance etc
- Guthur 7y agoThat was my feeling as well. There may be some gems in there but so much of it comes with such political overtones that it's hard to read without becoming increasingly cynical.
- mola 7y agoHumans are also consumers. Modern businesses think about people as consumers first and human second. This paves the way to many perversions, such as, huge industries bases on exploiting human weaknesses (e.g. addiction based online gaming) . This is enabled morally by marginalizing the concept of a human to consumer first. In this moral outlook, as long as you get costumers to buy your product, everything is AOK morally. Being human oriented means you don't create a product that which manipulate humans into self or social harm even if it'll turn a profit.
- icebraining 7y agoThe problem with generic principles like that is that they'll be used against you by anyone who doesn't share your opinions on what "manipulate" or "social harm" mean. You'll be harangued for being an hypocrite and going against your own principles, despite never having intended the principle to be applied that way.
- sonnyblarney 7y ago
- hliyan 7y agoMany of these resonate with me, but I feel 150 is too many. I try to live by the following: 1. A corporation must equally serve the three groups that come together to make it possible: investors, customers and employees. Losing the long term goodwill of customers and employees for quarterly (or even annual) targets is ultimately unprofitable. 2. Technology is not an end in itself. Focus on solving problems. Don't use machine learning where a spreadsheet would suffice. Don't use Redux, GraphQL etc., unless you have the particular problem they try to solve. Don't cram blockchain into everything. 3. Don't use technology to solve human problems. Use it to make the solution easier. If your team is unhappy, talk to them. Don't create apps to manage their sentiment. But do create an app that helps them express themselves to you easier. 4. Question the prevailing view, especially if it's super-popular: "Fail fast", "Move fast, break things", "Fake it till you make it", "Premature optimization is the root of all evil", "Man days estimates are anti-agile", "Relational DBs constrain your ability to develop quickly" etc.
- sonnyblarney 7y agoNeat point: "the three groups that come together to make it possible: investors, customers and employees." But - there are two more entities in direct relationship: suppliers, debtor; and more importantly many externalities, like non-participants, non-customers, the environment etc.. I don't think it's practical to promote this 'arbitrary equality' ideology on everything because it has a 'good sensibility'. A 'corporation' is just a group of people doing stuff. They can do whatever they want: make profits, not, have fun, make stuff, provide some service, or not. It's entirely up to them how to determine the 'balance' between the various actors. As for many of the remaining points in the article, I suggest people can do whatever they want as well, so long as they trying to be good people. "Move fast and break things" is a perfectly suitable approach in some situations, though obviously not always.
- hliyan 7y agoI think you're missing my point. The reason for (1) is the idea that "maximizing shareholder value" is the only goal of a corporation. There are two other stakeholders in a corporation who get shortchanged because of this principle. Of course, suppliers are there, but consider that we are their customers (we being the corporation under consideration). Also note that this is what I follow personally and it's based on fifteen years of experience working for many companies. I would hardly call that arbitrary, and certainly not arbitrary in quotation marks. Whether that's right for an entire industry, is an open question.
- tlb 7y ago“Principles” should be worded to be clear and unambiguous. The items listed here can be interpreted to mean something, but different people will interpret them to mean different things. They are more like koans. Useful to ponder, but not for people to agree to and think they’ve agreed to the same thing.
- neokantian 7y agoWhat we have here is yet another long list of vapid platitudes that attempt to create out of the blue some kind of fake morality. Morality is meant to be system of rules; not a collection of haphazardly-concocted, virtue-signalling feel-good statements. Atheists, who often viciously criticize religion, are themselves the absolutely most imbecile source of bullshit. As far as I am concerned, they can stuff their godless crap where the sun does not shine.