6 ms·
Duplicate it at no cost to anyone except yourself, I think you mean. It often does cost time and money to pirate things. And now that RepRap and similar 3D ob
by wccrawford 16y ago
Duplicate it at no cost to anyone except yourself, I think you mean.
It often does cost time and money to pirate things.
And now that RepRap and similar 3D object printers are becoming more popular, they will continue to come down in price. It won't be long before printing physical items is a possibility, and then wholesale pirating of things that used to be protected by patents will start.
And if you're having trouble imagining that happening, don't worry. It was just as hard to imagine music piracy before MP3s. It happened on a VERY small scale before that due to difficulty and media cost.
- arethuza 16y agoCan you actually think of any examples where "printing" 3D objects that are protected by patents is likely to be a problem in the foreseeable future?
- tptacek 16y agoI don't know, but the underlying problem is very real: counterfeit goods.
- jules 16y agoI don't see traditional counterfeit goods like watches and perfumes being printed any time soon.
- tptacek 16y agoThe economic harm caused by both actions is analogous; "printing" goods is basically a more sophisticated way of counterfeiting them.
- nitrogen 16y agoCounterfeiting implies the intent to deceive the customer. I'm not counterfeiting when I burn a copy of legal music to put in my car's CD changer. If I made many copies and sold them at a flea market, that would be counterfeiting.
- cma 16y agoIf the Consumer Is Not Deceived, It's Not "Counterfeit" http://www.cepr.net/index.php/blogs/beat-the-press/if-the-consumer-is-not-deceived-its-not-qcounterfeitq http://www.cepr.net/index.php/blogs/beat-the-press/if-the-co...
- skorgu 16y agoI agree in general, however there are circumstances where it's rather a different story: http://news.thomasnet.com/IMT/archives/2009/04/closing-the-door-on-counterfeit-parts-components-in-aerospace-applications.html http://news.thomasnet.com/IMT/archives/2009/04/closing-the-d...
- showerst 16y agoI think that it depends on your definition of 'foreseeable'. One of the first markets I can see this disrupting are things like war-gaming miniatures, and board gaming pieces, which have a HUGE markup, but could be reproduced in plastic relatively easily after a more few generations of this tech. I'm not sure about patents per-se, but it's certainly an intellectual property issue. Once these printers gain the ability to draw circuits and build or insert basic electronic components, things will really take off, but even before then there are some big markets for what are basically hunks of plastic and metal that are only expensive because they're well designed/marketed. Will you be printing off an iPhone in 5 years? Of course not. But that fancy $60 paperweight on your boss's desk? There's a big market for those too.
- arethuza 16y agoThis made me think of what is potentially a very large market - kids toys. As any parent will tell you, an awful lot of toys (especially for young kids) are cheap bits of plastic where the only "value" is the associated licensing of a brand/character from someone like Disney.
- sethg 16y agoThe relevant patents on Lego® bricks expired decades ago, and you would think clone bricks would have flooded the market by now. And yet Legos still sell—even the sets that aren’t licensed brands. My experience with Mega Blocks, cheaper bricks that are supposed to interlock with Legos, is that they don’t interlock very well—the tolerances are just far off enough to cause frustration. There must be something in Lego’s manufacturing process that keeps their quality high even though, on paper, nothing could be easier than replicating their technology.
- smackay 16y agoThere was also an attempt by Lego to trademark the blocks. That would have prevented competitors from creating compatible designs. However this was recently struck down by the European Court, http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/eu-judges-rule-out-lego-trademark-2079150.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/eu-judges-rul...
- wgj 16y agoIt depends on how you define 'problem', but here's one small example ( http://fabathome.org/?q=node/110 http://fabathome.org/?q=node/110 ) and I've been reading recently about others. e.g. all kinds of small kitchen, bathroom, and utility items that are currently sold at relatively high margins in stores. I remember when mp3s were too big to store or move easily, and couldn't be played portably. Piracy was purely a geek thing then. That situation changed incredibly fast.
- michaelbuckbee 16y agoHow about the Glif? http://www.theglif.com/ http://www.theglif.com/ - They were a Kickstarter project and the actual prototype was made on a 3d printer. The costs to pirate one don't quite make sense yet (I'm pretty certain that even with markup it will be cheaper to buy one from them than print your own currently), but the threat is clearly there. I also wonder about things like: if you downloaded a file to print your own Glif, but tweaked it for your android phone and made it a different color you're starting to get a transformative work out of the thing. Maybe the future is mixed atoms and bits (like when you buy a BluRay and it also has a "digital copy" on it for use on your PMP). Maybe when you buy a Glif they'll email you the plan to print your own that you can tweak up.