Hi, thanks for taking the time to explain in detail why you think the proof is wrong. I think this kind of discussion will go a long way in trying to find the s

Hi, thanks for taking the time to explain in detail why you think the proof is wrong. I think this kind of discussion will go a long way in trying to find the solution. Will pass on the comment to the prof. He will like that someone took the time to critique. So far most of the time all he gets is,"the proof is not valid because no one has done it so far" :).