> Your entire comment feels awfully dismissive What's dismissive is this word "dismissive". Sometimes, a comment really is just a random low-effort personal s

> Your entire comment feels awfully dismissive What's dismissive is this word "dismissive". Sometimes, a comment really is just a random low-effort personal swipe that don't engage with the substance of the subject. The GP did not write one of those comments. Instead, wrote a valid and substantive critique of the article, and you don't get to score rhetorical points by smearing that work with vague labels like "dismissive".