5 ms·
Sorry, do you have an example of a "large media group" "selectively editing" a video to make someone look drunk for the purposes of propaganda? Anything equiva
by ajross 7y ago
Sorry, do you have an example of a "large media group" "selectively editing" a video to make someone look drunk for the purposes of propaganda? Anything equivalent?
This sounds like a clever attempt to "both sides do it" a way out of actually admitting that this video and its pushing by a bunch of partisans (right up to and including the office of the President of the United States) was awful.
You agree this is awful, right?
- ekianjo 7y ago> "selectively editing" a video to make someone look drunk No, I don't have anything that specific in mind, but there's enough examples even in recent history of "selective editing" clearly aimed at taking people down, out of context. And yes, let me say it again, "on both sides". This is probably driven by the fact that outrage brings views, and views bring money + influence to such media groups, and then it's just an extra step to manufacture outrage for your own benefits. That's why all sides do it: same incentives at play.
- ajross 7y agoSo, all sides do it except only one side actually did it but you're pretty sure the other side did too because you personally believe they'd want to so therefore it must have happened ... ?
- ekianjo 7y ago> all sides do it except only one side actually did it Selective editing? There's abundance of videos on youtube compiling Trump being unable to pronounce things and Obama missing a few words - all compiled to make them both of them look stupid. How is that not both sides? Not sure what your point exactly is.
- ajross 7y agoYou think compiling a video of real-world malapropisms is somehow the same thing as ... fabricating evidence like this? Seriously? I mean, Obama and Trump actually said that stuff. Yes, it's misleading, but it's "true" in some kind of abstract sense. This video of Pelosi was a straight up lie. She didn't say that stuff that way. You get that there's a moral difference here, right? The fact that people can be fooled with cleverly structure and possibly misleading factual argument is not a license to lie like a sumbitch whenever you want. And that you seem to think so is horrifying.
- ekianjo 7y ago> fabricating evidence like this? Are we talking about the same thing? Slowing down a video 25% is not fabricating anything, it's just "slowing down the actual video", and people found it very quickly so it was rather obvious. Fabrication involves changing what the person actually says in my book.
- insickness 7y ago> Sorry, do you have an example of a "large media group" "selectively editing" a video You don't have to look too far to see large media groups selectively editing videos, or at least choosing to not display portions of video that exonerate someone. Nicholas Sandmann, the MAGA-hat wearing teen, was said to be part of a group confronting a Native American protester. When you look at the full video, it was the Native American who was confrontational. He walked over into the middle of the group rather than the group confronting him.
- kadendogthing 7y ago>When you look at the full video, it was the Native American who was confrontational. Absolutely false. This was a group of students who were using their free time to protest the reproductive rights of others, and in the midst of doing this did incredibly racist stuff to a Native American protester who was merely trying to keep balance of peace in these stressful engagements. There is direct video evidence of students * Shouting "go back to Africa" * Doing the tomahawk chop * Harassing other (even white) groups of women (https://twitter.com/roflinds/status/1087486166939680768 https://twitter.com/roflinds/status/1087486166939680768) All in a situation where they greatly outnumbered these people in the first place, and all of them wearing MAGA hats. Basically your post is either extremely dishonest or ignorant about the actual facts. Not only does all available video evidence most definitely not exonerate the group, it puts them squarely right where people initially pegged them, and on top of all that no point is the Native American being the confrontational one.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- insickness 7y agoHe walked up to them. They did not walk up to him. Therefore he was being the aggressive one, end of story. > This was a group of students who were using their free time to protest Because you disagree with what they were protesting, they had no right to be there? Absolutely wrong.