4 ms·
There are plenty of fruitful conversations to be had WRT the concept of responsible disclosure, but a fundamental pillar is that vendors are held to some deadli
by kibwen 7y ago
There are plenty of fruitful conversations to be had WRT the concept of responsible disclosure, but a fundamental pillar is that vendors are held to some deadline so that they cannot hem and haw indefinitely while leaving their users vulnerable. It's certainly a valid argument to posit that 90 days may be too short of a deadline, but a valid counterargument is that if a company like Apple cannot ship a security patch within 90 days, then their process itself is broken.
- bitexploder 7y agoNit to pick. Prefer the term coordinated disclosure. Responsible disclosure puts things on an unnecessary moral dimension. It’s not irresponsible to disclose bugs ever, IMO. I have seen this debate a million times now, but I know it is new for someone.
- tptacek 7y agoNotice that Intel used the term "coordinated disclosure" for last week's new raft of microarchitecture bugs; "responsible disclosure" is on the way out for exactly the reason you stated.
- bitexploder 7y agoThat is neat, I actually didn’t even notice and I read the thing. Seems like progress on this topic to me.
- kibwen 7y agoThanks for the tip, I didn't know there existed a better term for this. Indeed, I always felt that "responsible" was a loaded adjective in that context.