4 ms·
Naomi Wolf’s Book Premise Corrected by Host in BBC Interview
- TheMagicHorsey 7y agoThat was an unnecessary amount of cringe to bear for a Friday afternoon. I could have done without that. This is the real life version of the kind of dream where you catch yourself giving a lecture naked. Having said that, I think the author did the right thing. She accepted that the premise of her book was wrong, and she promised to correct it. That's more than most people do when caught out live like that.
- chrisdhoover 7y agoWhat choice does she have? She fancies herself a public intellectual. Turns out she’s a ninny
- theoh 7y agoShe didn't accept that the premise was wrong, just that this particular detail was inaccurate: "Wolf said she appreciated Sweet’s “important correction”, but rejected the idea that it challenged the main thrust of her book. “Outrages doesn’t purport to be a comprehensive database of eventual sentences served for sodomy,” she explained. “Its focus is on the reception of news about laws and sentences by a group of friends, as well as eventual arrests of friends of Symonds.” https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/books/2019/may/24/naomi-wolf-admits-blunder-over-victorians-and-sodomy-executions https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/books/2019/...
- TheMagicHorsey 7y agoI guess I will have to gracefully admit I was wrong in saying that she gracefully admitted that she was wrong.
- DanBC 7y agoShe hasn't though. She's been going through Twitter correcting people.
- chrisdhoover 7y agoSomewhere Nelson is letting out a hardy ha ha
- jMyles 7y agoWolf is a solid author and researcher; her reaction to this absolute nightmare (being called out love on NPR for misunderstanding a British legal term from the 1820s on which her research into 15 cases is based) shows incredible poise. Sucks that she got it wrong, but I've been similar gaffes before and certainly bnot reacted as professionally.
- cbnotfromthere 7y agoSolid author and researcher? I assume you meant imbecile leftard with compulsive-obsessive need to be wrong again, and again, and again about basically each and every topic she ever touched on. Basically a less smart, more noisy female version of Chomsky.
- gnusty_gnurc 7y agoShe's not a solid author though, it seems. https://www.vox.com/2014/10/5/6909837/naomi-wolf-isis-ebola-scotland-conspiracy-theories https://www.vox.com/2014/10/5/6909837/naomi-wolf-isis-ebola-...
- jMyles 7y agoReading that article, do you think that her quotes are used fairly in each case? The article repeatedly tries to read between the lines, accusing Wolf of "implying" a number of outrageous fact patterns, but I'm not sure that her posts actually imply any such things. She states that SITE received a US government grant (true), that similar US government grants have been used to fund disinformation (almost certainly true), that the New York Times relied on a single primary source instead of sending an investigative journalist to do on-the-ground investigation (true as far as I know, but feel free to correct me if I've got it wrong here), that the US has history of militarizing Africa and empowering African dictatorships (true). She also points out that, given the quality of the videos, if they were fake (which she doesn't not assert or even imply to my eyes), then the work can have been done by just 4 people. And thus, the responsible act for a serious news gathering outfit is to confirm the authenticity of the video instead of assuming it is real on the US government's say-so alone. I hope we all agree on this. It's not like these videos are cryptographically signed by a known keypair belonging to ISIS. Real journalism means doing the hard work of confirming the provenance of pieces of media - even if doing so might require hypothesizing that a piece of media is fake and working to disprove that hypothesis. Finally, she points out that calling any organization "evil" in passing, in an otherwise dispassionate news article, is not in keeping with the traditional editorial style of the New York Times. This is also true as far as I know, unless there is a standard for "evil" defined in unpublished style guide. So for Vox (or anyone else) to jump all over the road about what she implied by pointing out these truths is not particularly relevant. I also can't help but notice that these kinds of smear pieces against her started just as she began to embrace some of the more effective and sane libertarian movements in the US (eg, her high-profile appearance at New Hampshire Liberty Forum). I assert that much of corporate media (and the ecosystem that relies on it) is unable to properly contextualize figures who cross political lines and form alliances that don't fit neatly into a right-left narrative, and that this often takes the form of painting these figures as extreme or unhinged.
- hanoz 7y agoOuch. Having just listened to the audio, and not knowing anything about either party, or the subject matter, I have to say the author took it quite graciously, but I think she was very lucky to have it broken to her by so gentle an interviewer.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThe book is titled Outrages: Sex, Censorship, and the Criminalization of Love. Apparently, part of what it covers is cases where the author thought people were put to death when they were actually pardoned: during the interview, broadcaster Matthew Sweet read to Wolf the definition of “death recorded,” a 19th-century English legal term. “Death recorded” means that a convict was pardoned for his crimes rather than given the death sentence. Wolf thought the term meant execution. I am, sadly, unsurprised. The title plus gender of the author paints a picture for me of one (or both) of the following scenarios: 1. Angry feminist type not adequately fact checking because it fit some outrage fuel narrative she had in mind. "Heads will roll. Don't confuse me with the facts." 2. I honestly think women tend to not get adequate constructive feedback at early critical junctures. I think the second issue was a factor in the Theranos debacle. It's an issue that makes me quite crazy at times as someone who happens to be female and has had trouble getting traction.