4 ms·
I thought the reason it made economics sense for the Air Force to use this gaming console (as opposed to any other computer) was that Sony sells PS3s at a loss
by jessriedel 16y ago
I thought the reason it made economics sense for the Air Force to use this gaming console (as opposed to any other computer) was that Sony sells PS3s at a loss in order to spur sales of PS3 games. But Sony can't be subsidizing this by more than $100/unit, which would only save the Air Force of order $1 million. How is it saving them more than 10 times that? Are PS3s really sold at such scales that they are 10 times cheaper than a non-gaming option for equivalent computing?
- binarymax 16y agoYes, and the place they mention is 34th slot in Top500 ~ 190TFlops So, suppose a bespoke 190TFlop beast would normally cost $20M - at a bargain $0.10 for one flops!(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FLOPS http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FLOPS -Costs of computing) Looks like with their setup they are getting $0.01 each flops.
- jessriedel 16y agoSo you're saying that the fact that the PS3 is sold at a loss has very little to do with the cheapness of this supercomputer? I still have trouble believing economically that Sony gets it's processors ten times cheaper than normal. Why couldn't the Air Force just buy the processors from whoever makes them for Sony? Yes, Sony probably has a discount from the processor manufacturer for buying in bulk, but a factor of 10 doesn't seem possible.
- binarymax 16y agoSony makes the processors :) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cell_(microprocessor) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cell_(microprocessor)
- moxiemk1 16y agoI'm quite sure that IBM actually makes the processors, at the plant in East Fishkill, NY. In the history section of that Wikipedia Article, IBM manufacturing the chips is referenced several times, but never Sony.
- metageek 16y agoYeah, but they codeveloped them with Sony, so Sony presumably gets a really low price.
- jessriedel 16y agoThis doesn't answer my question. Even if Sony did make the chips all by themselves (which seems dubious from comments below), then they own some sort of magic capital or intellectual property which lets them produce such processors way cheaper than every other company on the planet. What is this magic thing?
- alecco 16y agoTFlops are a very bad metric for computers. A rocket car isn't better than a Ferrari. A monster truck isn't better than a 4x4. Computers and cars have very complex specs.
- scott_s 16y agoIt can be true if you take it as a given that they want to use the Cell processor. Cell blade servers cost about $20,000. There are no options for getting the Cell between a PS3 and a Cell blade. But, those tend to have two Cell processors, they're a more recent version, and it's an actual high performance computer, with lots of memory and fast interconnects. So they are in no way "equivalent."
- metageek 16y agoAnd the Cells in the blade probably have all 8 SPUs enabled.
- jessriedel 16y agoThis doesn't answer my question. There are alternative processors out there. Unless the manufacturer of the Cell processors has some sort of magic which lets them make them 10 times cheaper than all other companies, there should be plenty of competitors which would be happy to supply a medium sized order.