5 ms·
> First, it takes money. Healthier diets... generally cost more... They note that the unprocessed diet they fed participants cost 40% more than the ultra-proces
by vorpalhex 7y ago
> First, it takes money. Healthier diets... generally cost more... They note that the unprocessed diet they fed participants cost 40% more than the ultra-processed diet.
And yet, a paragraph later:
> Lots of families in our study cooked almost every night, in part because it was the cheapest option
So wait, hold on, is cooking more expensive or not? What are they eating that's supposedly healthier but significantly more expensive?
> the labor of shopping (often at multiple stores)
What major grocery chain doesn't carry everything needed to make dinner?
> This means making healthy food more affordable, but it also means addressing the other challenges families face: for example, by guaranteeing workers a living wage and fair working conditions and by investing in families through universal free school lunch and subsidized child care, so that parents don't feel like they're doing it all on their own.
Wait, hold on, what? I thought we were talking about food cooking barriers? I can understand the connection to free school lunch (make sure kids get one solid meal in them a day, if you can call government supplied cafeteria materials food), but, what?
- NotPaidToPost 7y agoThere is a whole 'lobby' that tries to convince public opinion and government that bad diets, including too much processed food, are not people's fault because they are just victims of corporations and capitalist exploitation. This is of course total BS and eating healthily is not more expensive, and in any case in Western countries food has never been so cheap relative to income [0] [1]. [0] In US : https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2015/03/02/389578089/your-grandparents-spent-more-of-their-money-on-food-than-you-do https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2015/03/02/389578089/yo... [1] In UK : https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-45559594 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-45559594
- umvi 7y agoI mean, it's partially true. In cities there is such a thing as "food deserts" where it is hard to find fresh affordable groceries. But I admit, part of it is also just poor education/culture. In the area I live, there are no affordable American grocery stores. There is, however, McDonald's and a Wendy's with cheap fast food. If you are in the know, however, there is an affordable Latin American grocer that sells bulk rice, lentils, beans, tortillas, even some produce, etc. I almost never see Americans in there, but I see tons of El Salvadorian immigrants. Their culture involves cooking from raw ingredients more than ours though so I suspect they save a lot of money that way. Lentils, rice, and beans are way better for you than McChickens/fries.
- bluedino 7y agoIt's funny that the poor immigrants cook/eat just fine while the poor Americans who were born here just do the $ for 4 at Wendy's
- NotPaidToPost 7y agoQED. As I said in my now flagged previous comment (why?) cost of food is not an issue at all.
- Loughla 7y ago>So wait, hold on, is cooking more expensive or not? Just to answer this one part - the cooking itself is generally cheaper than eating out constantly. But that's after you jump over the barrier to entry of pots, pans, utensils, stove, cleaning supplies, and materials in bulk. And once you've learned how to cook. The only thing worse than wasting money on a poorly prepared meal is knowing that you can't afford to not eat the garbage.
- kwhitefoot 7y agoAny half way decent pots and pans will last you decades. I have a set of stainless steel pans that I bought nearly forty years ago that are in near perfect condition and in use several times a week now but every day when my children were growing up. And really there isn't much to learn about cooking healthy food. Most of the fancy techniques don't apply. And you can get perfectly good utensils like spatulas and ladles, etc., for a dollar each or visit a charity shop (thrift store in the US).
- wongarsu 7y agoI guess part of the problem is comparing "unhealthy" processed foods with cooking "healthy" food? I can cook food for a whole day for about €1. It will mostly be potatoes and lack any nutrients, but it will be a lot cheaper than any processed food I could buy. Or I can cook something with fresh ingredients and lots of fiber and nutrients, but those ingredients are expensive to buy in part because handling time sensitive squishy stuff makes every step of the supply chain more expensive.
- lysium 7y agoI agree. I want to add the rumor that you can live on potatoes alone. At least one guy reported he did it for six weeks and the medical checks did not find any malnutrition. Don’t know how scientific that anecdote is, though.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Merrill 7y agoPotatoes and milk was the diet that enabled the Irish population explosion prior to the famine. https://www.dochara.com/the-irish/food-history/food-in-ireland-1600-1835/ https://www.dochara.com/the-irish/food-history/food-in-irela... "The burgeoning population lived on a diet comprised mainly of potatoes and milk, which if eaten in sufficient quantity is a surprisingly nutritious, if monotonous, diet. It is also relatively tasty and easy to prepare."
- vibrato 7y agoPotatoes are a complete, if poor, protein source. You'll live. For a long while at least.
- colomon 7y agoI think your basic point is dead on, but I'm pretty sure ramen is significantly cheaper than potato for the same amount of calories.
- 7y ago
- iamnothere 7y ago> Wait, hold on, what? I thought we were talking about food cooking barriers? I can understand the connection to free school lunch (make sure kids get one solid meal in them a day, if you can call government supplied cafeteria materials food), but, what? I agree, I am in support of reducing income inequality etc but I feel like it is a bit dishonest to link these two issues so directly. The low-income people I know cook at home more, not less. It's cheaper than processed junk if done correctly.
- mc32 7y agoThe article is poorly written. Nothing is defined. What is highly processed? How much of it? Is this diet typical of a significant number of people? Plus, benefiting a majority of people is worthwhile even if those at the periphery are not helped.
- liveoneggs 7y agothey mean cooking is cheaper than eating from a restaurant -- preparing a healthy lunch every day for your kid is difficult and time consuming and uses up family food budget -- You can get an entire frozen pizza for about $1, a box of mac & cheese for about $1, etc
- scott_s 7y agoOne can cook processed meals at home. The supplementary material has the diets: https://www.cell.com/cms/10.1016/j.cmet.2019.05.008/attachment/3e50c90d-ca83-48c3-80e4-82e925189f1b/mmc1 https://www.cell.com/cms/10.1016/j.cmet.2019.05.008/attachme...
- AdmiralAsshat 7y ago> So wait, hold on, is cooking more expensive or not? What are they eating that's supposedly healthier but significantly more expensive? They might be "cooking" every night, but they're not necessarily cooking from scratch. A pack of ramen boiled on the stove with a flavor packet added is technically cooked by their definition of "cooking", but it's still ultra-processed: the amount of sodium added by the flavor packet is nearly an order of magnitude greater than if they had simply boiled some rice noodles from scratch and added their own seasonings of salt, soy sauce, etc. Not to mention any of the vegetables the package provided are freeze dried, and likely coated with stabilizers and preservatives. A "from scratch" version of ramen that paired the noodles with freshly chopped peas, carrots, or spring onions would be significantly healthier. This is really the heart of NPR's argument, I think: there is a substantial hump that people must get over to think about leaving the can of marinara sauce on the shelf and buying canned tomatoes, an onion, and garlic instead. There's a time and labor investment, not to mention an initial loss of satisfaction when the recipe fails to come out properly the first few times.
- bluedino 7y ago'Cooking' doesn't necessarily mean making your own tomato sauce. It's making something instead of eating a frozen lasagna or pizza. A big part of the issue is the food stamp or SNAP culture. When you get your allotment for the monht it's easy to just go fill your cart with bad choices. Caseworkers should be assigned to help show people how to cook, give out kits with cutting boards and pans and such. Recipe cards, that kind of thing. Maybe even subsidize meal delivery options (like HelloFresh) for a few weeks to get people started.
- vorpalhex 7y ago> Maybe even subsidize meal delivery options (like HelloFresh) for a few weeks to get people started. That was actually the direction I thought the article was going to go. Some kind of subsidized program to bootstrap the ability to cook decent meals from raw ingredients quickly.
- peterwwillis 7y ago
- fitchjo 7y ago> So wait, hold on, is cooking more expensive or not? What are they eating that's supposedly healthier but significantly more expensive? Cooking unprocessed meals is more expensive than cooking ultra-processed meals. Cooking at home, however, is less expensive than eating out, which appears to be the reference they are making in the second quote. > What major grocery chain doesn't carry everything needed to make dinner? For those shopping on a budget, going to multiple stores may be necessary based on pricing differences between stores (including consideration of sales or coupons for different products).
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoDepends if you're comparing like with like, surely? At least here it is impossible to get say a prepared ready meal curry or shepherd's pie that works out anywhere near as cheap as cooking it yourself. Especially once you've allowed for portion sizes and the 5kg of potatoes, the carrots and onions covering other meals as well. Ready meals appear to only offer time. I can probably find something that works out cheaper - noodles, unpleasant budget range 50p pizzas maybe. Tinned macaroni cheese will indeed be cheaper, as it's incomparable with home made. Tinned curries etc work out much more than making your own.
- fitchjo 7y agoYou can definitely find certain items/dishes where it is cheaper to buy already made instead of making yourself - rotisserie chickens in the US are a perfect example of that. On the whole, though, cooking at home is less expensive than eating out.
- peterwwillis 7y ago> So wait, hold on, is cooking more expensive or not? You spend more if you buy and cook fresh produce. You spend less if you only cook rice and beans. The latter is less healthy than the former. > What major grocery chain doesn't carry everything needed to make dinner? Not every store with food is a grocery store. Dollar stores and corner stores do not stock an abundance of fresh produce, beans, flour, etc. People may have to go to multiple stores to find the items they need. > I thought we were talking about food cooking barriers? Yes. Not having child care is a food cooking barrier. Not having money or the time to prepare school lunch is a food cooking barrier. Not having access to grocery stores or a car is a food cooking barrier. As is access to food assistance programs, not being paid enough, not having access to good public transit, insecure or unaffordable housing, etc. In 2009, over 2% of the US population lived in a food desert, and in 2017, 11.8% of US households were food-insecure. Of that 11.8%, 4.5% had very low food security.
- maldusiecle 7y ago> > First, it takes money. Healthier diets... generally cost more... They note that the unprocessed diet they fed participants cost 40% more than the ultra-processed diet. > And yet, a paragraph later: > > Lots of families in our study cooked almost every night, in part because it was the cheapest option > So wait, hold on, is cooking more expensive or not? What are they eating that's supposedly healthier but significantly more expensive? The next sentence is: "But when their cupboards ran bare, they ate ramen and hot dogs, not a pan of roast chicken and vegetables, as food gurus recommend." > > This means making healthy food more affordable, but it also means addressing the other challenges families face: for example, by guaranteeing workers a living wage and fair working conditions and by investing in families through universal free school lunch and subsidized child care, so that parents don't feel like they're doing it all on their own. > Wait, hold on, what? I thought we were talking about food cooking barriers? I can understand the connection to free school lunch (make sure kids get one solid meal in them a day, if you can call government supplied cafeteria materials food), but, what? All of these have fairly obvious connections to food preparation time. If you do backbreaking labor all day, or work two or three jobs because none of them individually pay enough to support you, you won't have much time or energy to spend on food preparation. And there are the sentences just a few paragraphs earlier: "At a minimum, it requires a working stove and enough money to pay the electric bill to run the stove. One family in our book experienced homelessness during the time we spent with the family. Patricia Washington, her daughter and her two grandchildren moved into a hotel room after being evicted when they couldn't keep up with both the rent and the heating bill." Point being, economic barriers are food preparation barriers.
- AstralStorm 7y agoNote that cooking often is not the same as cooking long. Some of the low processed foods are just offloading the processing onto you taking more time. Salads don't make themselves. Veggies don't remove skin and wooden parts on their own. You could eat many of the vegetables whole. The best light processing that allows some of this to be offloaded and batched is freezing...