3 ms·
>”corpora of peoples faces have been insufficiently stocked with a particular racial group, in such cases people's faces might not register as faces..” I’m not
by mc32 7y ago
>”corpora of peoples faces have been insufficiently stocked with a particular racial group, in such cases people's faces might not register as faces..”
I’m not sure this is s good argument against the technology because there is a solution to this objection: they’ll improve it and ensure every face type is comparably recognized. It should be rejected on more basic principles.
- rmrfrmrf 7y agoIt's not as simple as "just make sure it works on everyone". Even if it were physically possible to capture the face of all 7 billion people on Earth, you'd start running into issues of false positives/negatives, overfitting, etc., and furthermore it would basically require every person to be periodically scanned from birth until death to ensure that the algorithm can recognize new faces.
- mc32 7y agoThis is a different objection than the original objection. (effective accuracy vs specific bias). With a pervasive system, unless people are hermits, they’ll get scanned periodically, and with other bits of information the changed face can be correlated with the same person (I go into a salon looking one way, come out different, go into a boxing match, come out different, but I’m following my routine and go to the same subway stop and convenience store and use the same payment method, etc.)
- xboxnolifes 7y agoAnd then you just have a different implementation of China's social credit surveillance system...
- bryanrasmussen 7y agothere are of course examples of technologies that do not work for their stated purpose, but I think in general technologies do work pretty much for their stated purposes if people can use the technology correctly. Generally the arguments against a technology is not that the technology does not work for its purpose, but that the way humans will use it is problematic.