3 ms·
A bit disappointing that the article doesn't go more into the technical details of the hardware and how the two designs differed, and how the Atari design influ
by flohofwoe 7y ago
A bit disappointing that the article doesn't go more into the technical details of the hardware and how the two designs differed, and how the Atari design influenced the 16-bit Commodore machines (the Amiga).
IMHO the 8-bit Ataris were a lot more innovative than the Commodore 8-bitters (including the C64), despite being a couple years earlier to market.
For instance the Atari display chip ANTIC was an actual co-processor, running a sequence of simple instruction via DMA to produce the display (very similar to the Amiga's copper).
The C64 (and other 8-bit machines) could only reprogram the display chip mid-frame by directly writing hardware registers with the CPU at the right time (often controlled by a raster interrupt).
The 8-bit Ataris were the actual predecessor to the Commodore Amiga (not surprising, because the same people who designed the Atari later designed the Amiga).
- rbanffy 7y agoIndeed. ANTIC did beam racing based on display lists and could switch modes and palettes mid-screen (tricks the Amigas inherited). The sound was modest, but nothing in the 8-bit space (and on the PC clone side until EGA) comes close in the visual side. And the SIO could daisy chain intelligent devices running their own tiny little OSs just like we do with USB-C today, which is really cool for 1979. The 64 had the just-right choices for its 16 colors, which provided some amazing visuals when combined, and had the most beloved sound chip of its time. From retrogeek to retrogeek, if you are in doubt, get both. And an Apple //e to finish out the 6502 family. All three are extremely interesting on their own.
- ido 7y agoDisappointed as well - reads a like a quick summery written by someone who read about the subject matter on wikipedia a bit.
- 0815test 7y ago> IMHO the 8-bit Ataris were a lot more innovative than the Commodore 8-bitters (including the C64), despite being a couple years earlier to market. ... The 8-bit Ataris were the actual predecessor to the Commodore Amiga (not surprising, because the same people who designed the Atari later designed the Amiga). Indeed. While the closest thing to a true successor to the Commodore 64 and 128 (ignoring the unreleased "Commodore 65") in the "16-bit" era was the Atari ST, which like the C64 was optimized for low cost.
- bluGill 7y agoAlan Tramiel, CEO of Commodore in the C64 days was CEO of Atari at the time of the ST.
- danmaz74 7y agoI think it was Jack Tramiel? But the reference about him being the CEO in those two situations is interesting.
- bluGill 7y agoYou are probably right. My memory of the 1980s is not perfect.
- timbit42 7y agoSome of the C64 engineers designed the Atari ST, for example, Shiraz Shivji ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shiraz_Shivji https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shiraz_Shivji )
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]