2 ms·
Let’s say they make a binding promise and then try and execute him anyway. What then? He’s dead, and US-UK relations are basically unaffected. Where is the rec
by sneak 8y ago
Let’s say they make a binding promise and then try and execute him anyway.
What then? He’s dead, and US-UK relations are basically unaffected. Where is the recourse? Who would seek it? No one would be punished, just as for the other violent crimes being discussed in this thread.
Or, what’s worse: they don’t kill him quickly, but instead torture him to death like they tried (and almost succeeded in doing) to Manning. They could even do it in the context of a multi-year protracted non-capital trial, making it seem like they were intending to comply with their promise.
Their goal is suffering and intimidation, make no mistake. Death or not, they are within sight of their endgame. Once he is in their custody, his life will become very, very painful, regardless of what the law says or whether or not he is given a trial or whether or not he is convicted or whether or not is is fair or just. He will suffer, and probably die.
Remember, he is the adversary of the organization who hacked their own Senate to avoid oversight. (No legal repercussions for that, either. The CIA is allowed to hack the legislature.) They give zero fucks about the law, because they know it doesn’t apply to them.
(To add insult to injury: that oversight they were avoiding? It was because they torture people.)
Even Mengele didn’t have that kind of carte blanche.
Literally no law in any country practically applies to the US military intelligence machine at this point.
- maxlybbert 8y agoIt’s my understanding that the US used to claim that it was inappropriate for the State Department to make binding promises that someone would not be sentenced to death because the State Department is part of the executive branch and should not interfere with the judicial branch. The US got away with this argument for a long time. Eventually, countries made it clear that the US would have to solve its own separation of powers issues if it hoped to ever get extradition requests approved. This is the diplomatic equivalent of saying “that sounds like a personal problem to me.” The US did eventually find a way to provide those promises without interfering with the courts. Reneging on a promise like that is the kind of thing the US can only do once: sure they would get to execute Assange, but the natural result would be that the UK and other countries would stop extraditing people.