4 ms·
Thanks for the rephrasing. I should rephrase as well. The language I am proposing offers much stronger control over ambiguity. Take the 8th amendment: "Excess
by breck 7y ago
Thanks for the rephrasing.
I should rephrase as well. The language I am proposing offers much stronger control over ambiguity.
Take the 8th amendment: "Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted."
What is an "excessive fine" mean? In the language I am proposing it could be defined as is, or in something like:
...
cellType dollarAmount number
cellType fine dollarAmount
cellType adjustedGrossIncome dollarAmount
cellType universalExcessiveFineThreshold
description As a percentage of adjustedGrossIncome
constant .1
nodeType isExcessiveFine
cells adjustedGrossIncome fine
trueIf fine / adjustedGrossIncome > universalExcessiveFineThreshold
...
So you have more control over ambiguity.
- umanwizard 7y agoBut that’s not ambiguity at all — “giving judges leeway according to parameters defined in advance by legislators” is not the same thing as “statutes being ambiguous”.