3 ms·
No, first I have made well under $20k annually. Using $20k as my income is, at best, a misreading of my comment. Second, that income supports three adults. Whi
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
No, first I have made well under $20k annually. Using $20k as my income is, at best, a misreading of my comment.
Second, that income supports three adults. While homeless, I knew other homeless people who had a higher per capita income than us.
Currently, I have reason to believe that I'm one of the poorest people in the building I live in.
I'm pretty damn poor for an American.
You are also ignoring my previous statement that I've seen comments here from people from third world countries.
My essential point is that, no, not all people reading HN are rich. I have no problem agreeing that most (more than 50% of) people here are well off. That seems like a reasonable assertion.
But it doesn't take much to indicate that your addition of "if not all" is almost certainly not true.
- fuzz4lyfe 7y agoDo you use any of the governmental or private social services? Medicare? Housing assistance? Food stamps? You don't have to answer but those programs don't exist in that manner for the majority of the world's population. The fact that you live in something that could be called a building is evidence of your wealth comparative to most of the people on this planet. Let me put it this way, if all global income were distributed equally it would be roughly ten thousand dollars a year per person. That's all in. Roads, police, social programs, private spending. Ten thousand dollars is the average household income in China. That's a the most fair distribution possible. Do you know what the per median per capita income is in India? A growing nation with a tech sector and nuclear weapons? Less than $700 a year. Here's the worst bit, people in India are also disabled and deal with the same personal struggles that you do. I'm not saying this to trivialize your life but the facts have to be put into perspective. People living in western nations, speaking English and with internet access really don't have the right to call themselves poor. Comparatively poor yes, nominally poor? Check your privilege.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoWow, what a way to completely and totally miss my point and turn it into a completely unwarranted personal attack. There are lots of people here who are not living in Western nations. I'm done arguing this. Your remarks are not remotely in good faith.