3 ms·
Manning hasn't really been jailed forever. She had her sentence commuted, and the recent legal trouble she finds herself in is entirely of her own creation, no
by rootusrootus 7y ago
Manning hasn't really been jailed forever. She had her sentence commuted, and the recent legal trouble she finds herself in is entirely of her own creation, no?
IMO both Manning and Snowden have the weakest legal arguments, and Assange the strongest. I would personally have advised him to avoid taking sides in US politics, but he wasn't asking my opinion :). Playing in the big pond as a small fish is a dangerous game.
- scotty79 7y ago> recent legal trouble she finds herself in is entirely of her own creation, no? Only in a sense of "Stop hitting yourself!".
- rootusrootus 7y agoAdmittedly I'm not keeping close tabs on the case, but isn't the issue contempt of court? Could she stop the legal trouble by agreeing to testify?
- alexis_read 7y agoI believe it's to testify against Assange, which she has decided not to do as Assange's case is a legal grey area to say the least. I wouldn't say it's Manning's choice so much as a 'testify if you want to get out' Hobson's choice.
- scotty79 7y ago"We don't say you commited any crime but either you speak or we'll hold you jailed indefinitely." That doesn't sound like a first world democratic country. Yet it is.
- lmm 7y agoOn the contrary, it's perfectly normal in much of the first world. You are required to testify and jailed in contempt if you don't. The 5th is a US peculiarity.
- scotty79 7y agoJailed indefinitely? In my country it's 30 days tops. Not sure if you can be sentenced more than once for the same thing. Also you can refuse to answer any question that might incriminate you, your family or your loved one without any punishment.
- lmm 7y agoYes, that's how contempt of court tends to work: you are jailed until you do the thing the court demands.