3 ms·
... but where he was charged with rape. So he gave up protection from extradition to the US in exchange for protection against the rape charge. A cynic might
by AnimalMuppet 8y ago
... but where he was charged with rape. So he gave up protection from extradition to the US in exchange for protection against the rape charge. A cynic might think it tells you which one he thought he had more reason to fear.
- duxup 8y agoIMO I think Asssange has had trouble with the truth in favor of cultivating his image for a long while now. Granted, that's a very human thing to do. He's not alone... politicians all the time. Back in the day when there was a wikileaks facebook page, if you followed up asking about "hey you said you'd release X" after they talked something up and did nothing ... they'd just delete your comment.
- monocasa 8y agoSweden has allowed the US government to just black bag people in the past. The UK doesn't from their soil. There's good reason to think they don't have a issue with extraordinary rendition in the global sense; I think they just don't like the idea of a former colony subverting their legal system. But all of that means that it's more likely for Assange to stay in the legal system in the UK rather than being black bagged.
- duxup 8y agoHow many people go to the UK to escape the US? This is a very strange argument.
- monocasa 8y agoHe found himself stuck in the UK, and didn't want to go to Sweden, which has a habit of allowing the CIA to kidnap people. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repatriation_of_Ahmed_Agiza_and_Muhammad_al-Zery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repatriation_of_Ahmed_Agiza_an... I'm sure he'd prefer to leave the UK too if he could, but between Sweden and the UK, when facing this amount of scrutiny from the US, the UK is his obvious choice since they don't allow extraordinary rendition starting from their soil.
- duxup 8y agoI think it is a bit absurd to think Sweeden would allow it in this case either considering that legally they wouldn't allow him to be extradited.
- monocasa 8y agoThe whole point of extraordinary rendition is that it's outside the legal process. The individuals in the wiki link I gave you successfully sued and won on the fact that Sweden had allowed their kidnapping when Sweden wouldn't have allowed an extradition.
- notahacker 8y agoAh yes, the completely logical argument that in order to be able to complete a rendition outside the legal process, those dastardly Swedes decided to commence a very public legal process against him requiring him to be on trial in Sweden... (The UK makes dubious decisions to repatriate asylum seekers to countries like Egypt all the time FWIW)
- monocasa 8y ago... yes, Sweden's public historical willingness to cooperate extralegally with the US in ways that the UK is not is in fact pretty good evidence of... exactly that situation being capable of occurring.
- notahacker 8y agoYou miss the point. If Sweden's true motivation lay in doing something outside the legal system, what on earth was the protracted legal process for unrelated allegations of offences committed in Sweden all about? And if Assange's true motivation was fear that the Swedes were unusually willing to act outside rather the legal process rather than within it, why was he so ambivalent about this threat that he chose to live there and stayed there until his lawyer received notification legal proceedings against him had reached the stage where he was due to be charged? It's certainly amusing to see Assange fans rewrite history to make the UK the good guy when it comes to not cooperating with the US over extraordinary renditions (or indeed ordinary ones). Even the UK government wouldn't make that claim.
- sneak 8y ago> ... but where he was charged with rape. This statement is not accurate. There were not, and are not, any charges in Sweden against Assange. There is only an investigation.
- AnimalMuppet 8y ago... for which they wanted him to return to Sweden to face questioning, right? To avoid that return to Sweden, he sought asylum in the Ecuadorean embassy, right? If not, why did he seek asylum?