4 ms·
No, observers claimed he was delusional to think he would be charged with a capital crime (meaning he could be executed if convicted), because that would violat
by gamblor956 7y ago
No, observers claimed he was delusional to think he would be charged with a capital crime (meaning he could be executed if convicted), because that would violate the terms of any extradition.
Everyone thought he would be charged with a number of crimes if he ever left the embassy.
- darkpuma 7y ago>>>> Is it your belief that he would not end up in US custody? And do you think he also believes that? >>> Yes, that is my belief. I don't know what he believes. >> Well, you seem to be implying that he is being dishonest about his fear of being extradited. As if he is doing this so he doesn't have to answer to the charges in Sweden. Based on your statement, you clearly do believe that he isn't actually worried about ending up in US custody. > I do think he's being dishonest, yes. He has access to skilled lawyers, and his concern about extradition to the US is irrational: it's easier to extradite him where he is.
- krustyburger 7y agoI’m not sure whether you’re really making a blanket statement about what all observers had to say. But if you are, your recollection is incorrect. The issue of capital punishment aside, many voices chimed in to say (especially in the early going) that the United States would not hold these cards close to its chest for such a long time and that he should just go face justice in Sweden.
- rootusrootus 7y agoThe terms "many observers" and "many voices" are weasel words, and also blanket statements. Your argument would be much better if you could be more specific about who you are referring to.
- gamblor956 7y agoBack then, I and a number of the other legal dudes on HN were saying that the US would definitely try to extradite Assange no matter how long he tried to stay in the embassy.[1] We all generally agreed he should face justice in Sweden (if he was innocent, as he claimed) because Sweden does not extradite for the crimes he is now charged with...but the UK does. While it's possible Sweden might have deported him to Australia after whatever happened in Sweden, that scenario was never brought up. [1] We're still trying to extradite Polanski, even though he's been a fugitive for decades. The US legal system has patience, largely because everything takes so long anyways.
- rmtech 7y agoSo why didn't he go to Sweden? Even if guilty and they can prove it, a Swedish jail is probably nicer than a US one and I doubt he would go down for longer for the alleged crimes in Sweden than for those in the US. What was it - sex without a condom? Versus the espionage in the US?
- sjwright 7y agoBecause there is a history of Sweden quietly allowing the US to perform extraordinary rendition there.
- myrryr 7y agoBecause he thought they would hand him to the us.
- rmtech 7y agoit's certainly possible. I guess we'll never know.
- belorn 7y agoWhen people are out to get you and you see irregular behavior from people in the government, what is a rational behavior? The case had gone through not one but two prosecutor, both which dropped the case. Rumors of US influence and a third prosecutor picks up the case. Could be nothing of course and just part of normal operation by the legal system. Just because people were out to get him doesn't mean he should had reacted paranoid about it.
- stale2002 7y agoThis is such a rewritting of history. Everyone was claiming that there were no secret charges, and we were a conspiracy theorist if we thought so. This went on for years.
- saalweachter 7y agoI mean, our current information is that there were no "secret charges" ... until 2018. So for 6 of the 7 years he was in there, the "you all are crazy conspiracy people" people were correct, and only for the last year have the crazy conspiracy people been correct.
- cheez 7y agoThere was even an administration change in between, which means that it is likely whoever followed up on these charges within the US government had their eye on the prize for more than half a decade.
- yakshaving_jgt 7y agoNo, I think the "crazy conspiracy people" were right all along. Whether or not they were provably right at the time is not the issue. They were right. They could read between the lines, and they were right.
- monocasa 7y ago... the charges leaked in 2018. They had probably been filed in 2010.
- stale2002 7y agoHe only just now got out of the embassy. The claim, all along, was that as soon as he is out of the embassy that the US will bring out their espionage charges. And he just got out of the embassy,and guess what happened? He recieved espionage charges. Exactly as predicted.
- saalweachter 7y ago
- inflatableDodo 7y ago>observers claimed he was delusional to think he would be charged with a capital crime (meaning he could be executed if convicted), because that would violate the terms of any extradition. While the Foreign Office may insist that we will never extradite if there is a possibility of the death penalty, the Home Office on the other hand can take it upon themselves to waive that requirement and have apparently done so recently in another case, so it is possible and the UK is quite prepared to say that it isn't, while doing it - https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-44929067 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-44929067
- ddingus 7y agoDon't count me in the set of "everyone"