2 ms·
To compare China to the Soviet Union seems to me very erroneous. The communist party has survived communism itself, which the Soviet Union did not manage, it ha
by Barrin92 7y ago
To compare China to the Soviet Union seems to me very erroneous. The communist party has survived communism itself, which the Soviet Union did not manage, it has survived Deng's reforms towards a more market based economy, and now it apparently evolves into something else again, whatever that is.
So to characterise a system as rigid that has shown the ability to absorb more shocks than just about any other political system on earth and still come out intact and relatively, if not highly functional is probably a huge mistake.
And it's true that all this thought control stuff and the Xi smartphone apps aren't serious long term politics, but they're also not really evidence for the opposite. Politically China has still a lot of old cadre who thinks they can brainwash the population with Soviet era propaganda, but in contrast to the USSR I'm not sure how seriously the leadership itself takes this or merely runs with it because it's the motions you go through in these authoritarian systems.
And concerning the last part about stagnation, how often have we heard this now? China is always five years away from being five years away of succumbing to its politics. It's almost an unfalsifiable belief at this point. You say that it'll take many years to find out, but is there a point in time at which you're open to change your outlook? The issue I have with this view is that it almost feels like the roles have reversed. People in liberal democracies want to exercise foreign pressure and maintain the system solely on belief in the system itself, rather than admit that we're in a phase of competition between political systems (which ironically was supposed to be the arena where liberalism wins on merits)