12 ms·
YC's request for startups: Government 2.0
- unseenbastiat 7y agoPsychologists use the term “socialization” to designate the process by which children are trained to think and act as society demands. A person is said to be well socialized if he believes in and obeys the moral code of his society and fits in well as a functioning part of that society. It may seem senseless to say that many leftists are oversocialized, since the leftist is perceived as a rebel. Nevertheless, the position can be defended. Many leftists are not such rebels as they seem.
- zxcvvcxz 7y ago>We believe this mindset is the result of increased family debt, stagnant wages, and a lack of government commitment to provide equal access to the basic services families need to thrive. These services include access to quality education, affordable housing/healthcare/food, physical safety, accurate news and information, a social safety net, and a livable environment. Absolute nonsense. We are wasting more money than ever on publicly funded and shared services, and are taxed more than ever. We are moving individual and family money into large bureaucratic holes of un-productivity. We need LESS government and more incentives to have stable nuclear families, the original drivers of wealth and stability and growth for human civilizations.
- byoung2 7y agorefreshed the Request for Startups I didn't see the link in the article, but here is the list mentioned: https://www.ycombinator.com/rfs/ https://www.ycombinator.com/rfs/
- hluska 7y agoI find this very exciting - it strikes me that this field could create some tremendously valuable companies, whose impact upon society will be even more valuable than they are. Great work and best of luck to everyone involved in this general space!
- gioele 7y agoIf anybody is planning anything that combines laws, versioning/revision control and public access to legal resources, please get in touch with me. I have quite a bit of experience in that field that I'll be happy to share thoughts and talk shop.
- ibeckermayer 7y agoCan you send me an email at my user name at gmail dot com?
- bytematic 7y agoI have been dreaming about a government system of laws that uses open source version control with a github-like ui, maybe even a constitution. If I had my own country, that's how I would do it.
- dymk 7y agoI think as long as we base the kernel of the Government on Rust (for a fearlessly concurrent Government), we'll be in the clear. Also protects against terrorist memory tampering. Congress could submit new laws to Blockchain to combat tampering and ensure proof-of-work. My startup is working on Artificial Intelligence to predict laws that model cities like San Francisco or New York would want to implement in the face of acute social woes, so if Government 2.0 could provide a RESTful Lobbying API, that'd let the People move fast.
- scarejunba 7y agoBit of an old joke, no? I think the "descent to the absurd" style here doesn't make sense because there is a concrete reason for what he's saying: lowering the barrier to suggesting changes in laws in a more structured form. You could point to the diff and talk about it. Worthwhile, I think.
- dymk 7y agoAbsurd? I'm just as serious about what I'm proposing, as I am about a "Github-like UI" for the foundations of our country.
- Alex3917 7y agoIn Andrew Yang's recent panel at Monetery Tech Summit, he was making the case that most of these are problems that the free market doesn't reward solving: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nhNpbPhFwRc&t=957 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nhNpbPhFwRc&t=957 These are all important problems, but there have been people working on them for decades already without much progress. What we really need is for either government to tackle these problems itself, or else to put in place market mechanisms that are able to better reward entrepreneurs for solving them.
- mwseibel 7y agoI agree - it would be great for the government to tackle these problems. But looking at the current US government that doesn't look likely. I agree it feels almost impossible for a startup to actually fix some of these problems. But we fund startups who try to do the almost impossible all the time. And sometimes they succeed :)
- kaushikktiwari 7y agoI guess a lot of blowback is coming from the fact that you decided to call it Government 2.0. It seems a bit presumptuous, guilty of the same hyperbole tech is always accused of...changing the world etc...but at the same time it's a title I would click on. It's outrageous, but serves a purpose
- jakelazaroff 7y agoAre the startups listed actually fixing these problems, though? You say that Promise, for example, is attacking mass incarceration — but it's basically just a dashboard for lawyers. Maybe lawyers could be more efficient, but that's a way easier problem to solve than radically changing our justice system so that fewer people get pulled into it in the first place. What's worse, given that Promise appears to be a for-profit company and you're investing in it to make money, you now have a financially incentive against fixing the systemic issue. It's better for you if the justice system is bigger and less efficient, because you'll make more money selling us a band-aid. So count me in with the GP and Andrew Yang: it's not that the problems seem too hard for startups to tackle, but because they are fundamentally not problems that the free market rewards solving. YC mostly funds profit-seeking companies. That's okay! But I am skeptical that there is profit to be made in e.g. dismantling the justice system.
- YjSe2GMQ 7y agoI'm genuinely doubtful that people would want a tech-associated fund to try and mess around running the government. I mean tech doesn't get much of good press lately. Not that I agree with that sentiment, but "something needs to be done with Facebook!" is one of the few things that both US parties seem to agree on.
- chuckgreenman 7y agoThere are people who want to improve government with technology, just because it's an uphill battle doesn't mean it isn't worth doing. Also, governments are big spenders. Plenty of incentive there.
- Noos 7y agoThe real motive is your latter point, to capture evergreen money through government spending. Trying to find opportunities to be the vendor of choice in new ways.
- graenxa 7y agoThat "something" is varies widely by party.
- mwseibel 7y agoHmm - I'd reread the RFS. YC is not interested in running the government.
- tootie 7y agoI don't think this implies replacing government with private business. This could be services sold to government or tightening connections between government and the public. And don't just think of federal government. Local government frequently uses antiquated technology because better stuff is out of reach. How about helping small libraries organize their collections? Or fire departments manage procurement?
- pl0x 7y agoCome on YC, the silicon valley elites have destroyed so much of our society. Do we really expect you to fix it? You all need to read Anand Giridharadas "Winners take all".
- graenxa 7y agoWho needs public services when you can have private for-profit start-ups? I'm sure the new startups will always prioritize serving the citizens over making money. After all, that's what private for-profit organizations have a long track record of doing. In seriousness: I'm sure the listed start ups do good work. There are ways tech can help government and people. Government 2.0 is awful branding. The idea that you can "upgrade" our government with a handful of private companies is downright anti-democratic. How about instead of trying to replace the existing government with private organizations answerable to a few very rich individuals, you work with existing democratic structures and try to improve them.
- bradenb 7y agoI totally agree. My first thought was of the world of Snow Crash where there are districts owned by businesses and individuals that set their own systems of law and order. It was not a pleasant future.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- matt4077 7y agoThere are plenty of private companies that are positive or, in many cases, even necessary for governments and democracy to function. The media is one example, and so are internet providers. As this request is written, really any contractor that does something better than the SQ would qualify. And, of course, YC even funds non-profit startups. Recognised tax-exempt organisations almost by definition work on goals which are also in the government's purview. As it is, it appears your comment simply takes umbrage with the title? There is even a footnote explaining that the goal here is not to replace government but to improve it. That footnote may have actually been added as a response to your comment, because your's would seem to be a rather odd reading of this request.
- supergauntlet 7y ago> The media is one example Read (at least an outline of) manufacturing consent. Edward Herman and Noam Chomsky pointed out 40 years ago that the media is complicit in propaganda dissemination for the government without any active coercion taking place. > so are internet providers This is directly at odds with reality, when internet providers are allowed to run rampant we get anti-consumer behavior that requires things like net neutrality to fix. The fact that state mandated monopolies make problems like this worse is not an argument against the state, but against unregulated/poorly regulated monopolies. Telecom at some level does require actual lines to be run; it's a natural monopoly so we don't have a comcast line, an at&t line, a spectrum line, etc all right next to each other. The alternative is forcing them to work together, which we also could do much better on. Neither of these companies are necessarily fundamentally evil, but without oversight and accountability can, will, and have done bad things. That's the crux of it all, you can't rely on private companies to self-regulate, they're ultimately only beholden to their shareholders.
- mwseibel 7y agoHey folks - happy to answer questions about our new RFS.
- saeedjabbar 7y agoWhy the focus on only profit making for-profit companies when the bulk of what you mentioned is currently being serviced by non-profits?
- thedogeye 7y agoWhen non-profits succeed they have to ask for more money. When for-profits succeed, they fund themselves. So it's far better for a for-profit to solve a given problem than a non-profit, as they are inherently more scalable.
- XzAeRosho 7y ago>When non-profits succeed they have to ask for more money. That's not true at all. I worked for 3 years on a non-profit that funded itself and it received external donations and investments. This is not "either self-funding or external-funding". The whole idea of a nonprofit is that instead of sharing the surplus of revenues between shareholders, leaders or members, it will invest the surplus further into the company development and projects. It has nothing to do with scalability.
- danenania 7y agoI think it's more about aligning incentives with investors. Money put into a non-profit is a full write-off and so can really only have altruistic motivations. For-profit allows for investments that are motivated by a mixture of altruism and self-interest, which (for better or worse) allows for a much larger supply of capital.
- batty_alex 7y ago> When non-profits succeed they have to ask for more money. When for-profits succeed, they fund themselves. Having managed a non-profit and having worked at a very successful one before, this just makes you sound so out-of-touch it's not even funny. Yes, some non-profits are driven by donations, but many are not. > So it's far better for a for-profit to solve a given problem than a non-profit, as they are inherently more scalable. If by, "more scalable," you mean, "less accountable," then you're correct.
- tptacek 7y agoThere were better ways to word this and a better name to give it.
- idlewords 7y agoAnd better people to run it.
- visionaryturtle 7y agoWhy is this not run by PG or SAMA?
- JohnFen 7y agoI have to confess, this effort makes me very, very nervous. I already think that business has replaced too much of what government should be doing, and has too much influence over what it hasn't replaced. Also, given the activities coming from the tech industry over the last decade or more, I'm even more nervous that this is aimed in that direction. Increasing the amount of that doesn't seem wise to me.
- Uhhrrr 7y agoBleah - government shouldn't be the default actor in a space unless it's absolutely necessary. It's actually a good thing if community problems can be solved by smaller organizations which don't need tax money or coercive measures to get things done.
- JohnFen 7y ago> It's actually a good thing if community problems can be solved by smaller organizations As long as those organizations are not for-profit companies.
- p_roz 7y agoThat’s not true. If an organization benefits its customers/users in some way, it’s still doing a good thing if it captures some of that benefit in the form of profit.
- JohnFen 7y agoMaybe. My observation, though, is that whatever good thing it may be doing ends up costing people more, and being less good, when done by a for-profit company as opposed to a non-profit organization. Plus it is becoming increasingly risky to engage with for-profit companies for certain things because of their insatiable desire for data on their customers.
- pjc50 7y ago> need tax money or coercive measures to get things done. But those are pretty much all the remaining hard problems! If it was self-funding and didn't have any opposition, someone would be able to solve it.
- parthdesai 7y agoThe irony when they talk about affordable housing but don't say a word about AirBnb which is fucking over long term renters in popular tourist destinations.
- mwseibel 7y agoWhat about the hosts who use Airbnb to help them pay their rent?
- lasfter 7y agoAh yes, think of the poor high-rise owners who won't take on long-term tenants because they make more from tourists. How else would they afford their vacation home
- parthdesai 7y agoDo you actually believe that? What about the cities where Airbnb skirts the regulation and zoning and makes it a hell for people living there? What about Airbnb filing a lawsuit against cities when city wants an occupancy tax? If Airbnb was so serious about helping hosts pay their rent, it would only allow one unit per person/owner to be listed on the platform and honour the day limit imposed by some cities. You and I both know it very well that Airbnb is nothing but a glorified hotel now. There are studies out there that nicer neighbourhoods of the city where Airbnbs tend to concentrate have seen more increase in rent compared to other neighbourhoods. I really liked, in fact love the idea of Airbnb if it functioned the way it was supposed to be. But all it has done in desirable cities (speaking of Toronto in my case) is take units off the market for long term renters who actually live and work in the city, thus contributing to increase in rental prices and make it tougher for people to buy their first unit since people are investing money into buying x+1st property to Airbnb in it. I'll appreciate it if you actually reply to this post, and i'm willing to discuss it further.
- nabnob 7y agoThe solution to income inequality is not going to come from venture capitalists and private companies. I have an idea for a non-profit that tackles a systemic problem, but I can't help but look at some of the other yc grads and think that their companies seem hopelessly out of touch with the problems they're trying to tackle. Promise is mentioned as "tackling mass incarceration", but their company seems geared more towards improving efficiency in criminal justice agencies. Do they really think that an app that sends reminders is going to help failure to appear rates? Crime, recidivism, failure to appear etc are deeply rooted in poverty and hopelessness. How does a reminders app fight any of those problems? People fail to show up to court because they don't see the point, because they think the system is stacked against them, because they can't afford to take the time off of work, because they can't find child care, or because they don't have transportation. It's ridiculous to suggest that an app that sends reminders of court dates will make an impact on any of these problems.
- mythrwy 7y agoThe solution to income inequality probably isn't going to come from governments either sadly.
- maxxxxx 7y agoIt has to come from politics. Capitalism unregulated will pretty much always lead to a few accumulating more and more and increasing their power.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoIndeed. Want to fix government? Run for office or work in government. Anything else is polishing brass on the Titanic. Hat tip to the USDS and 18F [1]. Hard working people making an impact. YC: Why not consider hiring lobbyists to enable existing, impactful teams more velocity? [1] https://thehill.com/opinion/technology/444159-congress-should-grow-the-digital-services-budget-which-more-than-pays-for https://thehill.com/opinion/technology/444159-congress-shoul... (Congress should grow the Digital Services budget, which more than pays for itself)
- blang 7y agoI honestly don't know what Gusto does that is different from companies like ADP (established 1949), especially in being framed as Government 2.0.
- MWilcut 7y agoIf anyone wants to help Veterans, I am an attorney, 5+ years in assisting Vets get VA benefits. I have A LOT of fully formed concepts, but amateur/hobby technical ability. Most immediate goal is to compliment but go well beyond the very minimal efforts that USDS has been doing for Vets directly the last 2-3 years. VA has coopted USDS into assisting the VA first, Vets only incidentally. matt@deutermanlaw.com
- chc4 7y agoI'm surprised to hear about this. USDS is paraded around as one of the poster childs of how to pair tech with the public sector and effective government work. Are there any posts about how they failed with VA benefits?
- MWilcut 7y agoI was actually considering writing one but I have no established presence or blog. I'm a full-time attorney but I've been following USDS work with VA for years now. I am subscribed to every update in certain respositories. In very very short terms, the tools have been designed from scratch without primary stakeholders (veterans, their advocates) for 2-3 years and they are just now considering opening up to stakeholder issues on their github. Instead, they focus on VA employees say they need to accomplish their jobs or even VA contractors. Certain VA employees have publicly stated ownership of the USDS's work on their behalf, it's "their" software and not the public's or Veterans', and it is clearly designed as such. I could give very specific examples all throughout the USDS VA Digital Service github account but I'll just leave this nugget[0] (which I wrote) from October 2017. They just stated their intention to begin to incorporate stakeholder ideas only a few months ago[1]. What would actually improve Veteran's claims processing starts with what Veterans and their advocates can do - to SAVE government resources doing the same thing or codifying it into complicated software on their end. [0]https://github.com/department-of-veterans-affairs/caseflow-efolder/issues/624 https://github.com/department-of-veterans-affairs/caseflow-e... [1]see very bottom of [0]
- jkeuhlen 7y agoWhat kinds of issues are you thinking about tackling in that space?
- WilliamEdward 7y agoCompanies already run the government. We need less of this, not more.
- jpmattia 7y agoHaving been part of the startup community in both Silicon Valley and greater DC, I think this is a much-needed and brilliant effort on the part of YC. I hope it pays off in spades, both for the public and YC. That said: My hat is off to anyone who manages to cross the divide between silicon valley culture and govt bureaucracy culture. Navigating the differences in those world views is not for the faint of heart.
- mwseibel 7y agoThank you :)
- thomasjudge 7y agoAs someone who works in technology in the public sector at the state level, let me just say that there is tremendous greenfield opportunity for software startups within existing government programs. Probably every program that government runs requires one or more systems to administer it; these are often painfully legacy systems. We are starting to see startups in some of these niche line-of-business areas (Medical Marijuana licensing, Senior & Long Term Care services, ...) but there are many other areas yet untouched.
- mwseibel 7y agoWe agree :)
- corry 7y agoThis 10000%. I founded a YC company that's focused on Public Sector, and we see the greenfield opportunity in this space every day. Only 5% of a given public sector IT's budget is cloud software (most of their software is legacy/on-prem) vs. 50%+ for similar large commercial enterprise. As governments digitize more and more, they will prefer native "gov first" products. So while it's still early days in these parts of the market, the early winners will be a great position as we move along the tech adoption curve. It's worth noting too that the tech adoption curve still exists in government, even if it's backwards skewed. And when the early majority hits, given the scale and size, it's going to create some very large and successful companies.
- tyre 7y ago100% agree. The problem is not that there aren't opportunities to improve but that getting those into the hands of users is often nearly impossible. Public officials are not incentivized to improve software or even services. People vote based on emotions and the downside of fucking up a software upgrade is far more politically damaging than the upside of fixing it. Until the procurement and purchasing process is improved—changes that, in my mind, have to come from within—building better products just doesn't matter all that much. (I say this as someone who co-founded a YC-back company building software for local governments and burned out after 2.5 years trying to sell into them.)
- astuary 7y agoDisregarding the misaligned incentives of for-profit enterprises delivering the kinds of services that are traditionally handled by governments, what evidence is there that technology can materially improve many of these services? Many of the needs listed in the post (housing, education, food security, etc) are largely challenges of resource allocation. I'm skeptical that a web app can somehow make landowners willing to encourage increasing the housing stock in a city.
- mwseibel 7y agoIt is hard to predict how a small startup can grow to address a huge problem until after they do it. What we want to do is back the founders who are at least trying to solve these problem.
- neilv 7y agoWill there be better outcomes for society if such efforts are pursued as non-profits?
- mwseibel 7y agoThere are forprofits and nonprofits on our list.
- jakelazaroff 7y agoYou're investing in these companies, right? You expect them to make themselves — and you — money? The problem is what happens when we get to ways to solve the problems these companies are tackling, without the companies. If we enact universal healthcare, will Gusto pivot? If we structure our economy to remove the need for food stamps, will mRelief shut down? Or will there be attempts to entrench these problems so these companies still have something to solve?
- halfjoking 7y agoIt reminds me of an op-ed about Imperfect Produce destroying local food coops. Their whole pitch to investors is they're environmentally friendly but in practice they are actually entrenching the agribusiness industry by competing with better alternatives: https://newfoodeconomy.org/imperfect-produce-ugly-food-waste-commodification-community-supported-agriculture/ https://newfoodeconomy.org/imperfect-produce-ugly-food-waste... Startups need to make money, and it will always be way more profitable to sell software to those with power/money than those who are disadvantaged.
- 0xDEFC0DE 7y agoNote that none of those startups are currently tackling stagnant wages directly, which is really what would fix a lot of the other problems listed here. I've worked for a company that paid millions for a contract and software that ultimately wasn't used. There was tons of corporate waste that could be solved by simple internal CRUD apps and a little user training, purchases that weren't used much (if at all), projects that were bad from the start, and apathetic leadership with a comfy golden parachute. But why would I make a startup that encourages companies to pay their employees more? Or fire bad leadership and bad employees? Or stop making dumbass purchases? Or stop giving out golden parachutes and force leadership to actually have skin in the game? No business would hire that startup.
- Kalium 7y agoMore to the point, how do you address an issue with hundreds of contributory causes? It's so large as to be effectively intractable. It's akin to trying to cure the common cold. Of the issues you listed, dumbass purchases is by far the most tractable. It aligns with existing incentives. It's something companies are broadly already on board with. It might even be possible to contractually hook it in with departmental compensation to boost wages with part of the funds when waste is found. Now that sounds a lot more workable than "tackling stagnant wages". Might just be me, though.
- adpirz 7y agoI'm on board with this. This sounds like creating products / software that basically make public ops much better. As someone with a background in education, this is what I wish more edtech startups focused on. Yes, instruction is core, but so much of what's failing in today's schools is bad ops -- hiring, sourcing, maintenance, managing student data, etc. It's also all based on many legacy public systems.
- ghobs91 7y agoA startup working on a secure digital voting system should be one of the top priorities here. As it currently stands, this is what the voting experience is like: - Always on a weekday, so if you have a job and then a family to take care of after work, good luck finding time. - Long lines, so that even those who find time are discouraged by standing around in November weather. - The countless cases of voting locations in minority areas conveniently having broken machines or other barriers that prevent them from voting. This environment has essentially optimized the experience for one group: retirees who have the time and energy to prioritize their day around voting. It's no surprise that legislation often favors this specific group as a result. My high-level vision of how digital voting would look: - A secure open source app that verifies your identity before letting you vote. - Every candidate on the ballot would have a bio detailing their policies and views, to be filled out by them. - A digital approach would make it easier to eventually adapt the system to involve things like ranked voting. This would allow everyone to vote whenever and wherever they want, no relying on external factors like those mentioned above. It also provides one consistent place for every voter to see the same information about the candidates, rather than placing that task in the hands of media and their inherent bias/interests. That's my 2 cents, I'm excited to see how startups tackle this.
- davidascher 7y agoSee https://voting.works https://voting.works
- iknowstuff 7y agoIdeally, yes, but there are so. many. things. that could go wrong: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3_0x6oaDmI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3_0x6oaDmI From silent malware changing votes on voter's machines, to an authoritarians manipulating the servers, to inability to verify what is actually run on the servers, to hacking of air-gapped servers like Stuxnet did, etc. etc. Perhaps a smart contract on a publicly verifiable blockchain could alleviate the black box concerns. Privacy issues remain. Most democracies see it as absolutely vital for the population not to disclose who they voted for, so whatever smart contract we come up with, it has to be blockchain analysis-proof.
- 7y ago
- JabavuAdams 7y agoI don't see tech being a solution here. As a Canadian, this is one of the areas where Americans and Canadians differ very noticeably. The US seems to have a dogmatic / religious belief that government is bad, and that business / private enterprise is the answer to almost everything. Even among HN Silicon-Valley progressive types who are so similar to me, there's a difference in mind-set. It's like it's in your milk, air, and water growing up.
- greenstork 7y agoI think the key to improving the US government is to bring the system closer to a one person, one vote situation. I believe the best way to achieve this would be to do the following: 1) Abolish the electoral college and go with the popular vote for the presidency. 2) Weight a senator's vote by the population of their state. So a senator from California would have more voting power than a senator from Alaska. 3) Draw congressional districts via an "I cut, you choose" type system [1] Our current system has a number of problems. Swing states in presidential elections become the focus of presidential candidates and their platforms, even though those states are not home to the majority of the US population. Also, our current system creates weak links in the chain that are easier to exploit. For example, if you are a corporation looking to block legislation the most efficient means of doing so would be to contribute to the campaigns of the senators from smaller states. The average amount raised in 2012 by senate winners in California was $29.3M vs just $1.7M in Utah. It is much less expensive to influence smaller senate races, but the voting power a corporation would influence is the same. [2] If senate voting power was weighted by population, corporations or other groups would have to influence costlier senate races. [1] https://www.cmu.edu/news/stories/archives/2017/november/i-cut-you-choose-cake-cutting-protocol-inspires-solution-to-gerrymandering.html https://www.cmu.edu/news/stories/archives/2017/november/i-cu... [2] https://dposorio.com/822/the-cost-of-winning-a-senate-race/ https://dposorio.com/822/the-cost-of-winning-a-senate-race/
- britch 7y agoWhy do you need a start up to do this? How would a start up even do this?
- quantgenius 7y agoIncome equality is not a problem as such. It's a natural consequence of technology seeping more and more into society. In Shakespearean times all musicians made money by performing. The best ones performed for the king and made more money but all made money. With digital distribution, the best ones can reach everyone, and everyone wants to listen to only the best ones, so the best ones make a killing and other musicians turn into starving artists. There is going to have to be a transition of people into professions that aren't easily distributable or automatable. You don't need a startup to fix this. This is precisely what capitalism is good at doing, though it does take time, creates winners and losers and causes some segments of society a lot of short term pain. The big problem is that if you take into account all capital invested in the financial industry, so investments in VCs, hedge funds, mutual funds but also deposits in banks, financial firms have been a) generating lower rates of return and b) passing a smaller percentage of those returns to investors. Banks in the US keep/spend 60-70% of returns generated on all capital invested with them. In Europe it's actually worse, about 90%. Couple this with the fact that the middle class doesn't have access to and doesn't know how to do due diligence on investments that generate higher returns (the better hedge funds and VCs) and that policy makers have held rates extremely low for a very long time, and you have we are now. Even though people are not making a lot less from employment, their total income (including returns on saved and invested capital) and net worth is MUCH lower on a relative basis and it's clear that their children are likely going to be worse off than them and they may not have a retirement. This in my opinion is likely the cause of the appeal of Trump. Both problems a) and b) mentioned above are not because the financial industry is evil. It's because large parts of the industry, particularly the parts that serve retail investors and depositors are obsolete in how they are structured, for example the very idea of a mutual fund (including ETF) or indeed any vehicle that pools capital, except in situations where material capacity constraints exist, is obsolete because unlike in the 1950s where pooling capital reduced transactions costs, it now dramatically increases transactions costs and hence lowers returns. The industry won't fix it itself because the best and most innovative people working in areas serving retail get pulled into areas that can charge 2 and 20 and because doing so means they compete with their own most profitable businesses. Most extant fintechs won't fix this because putting an API or web-page in front of extant products doesn't solve the underlying problems. I don't think the typical VC funded startup will fix this because there is an extreme focus on going to market immediately and then iterating. If that's your approach you are going to end up building a web front end to Vanguard or an API to ACH and focus on marketing. Decent returns to VCs but you don't actually fix anything or approach anywhere near the returns possible with a higher risk approach. Extreme immediate focus on iterating is great if you are a 20 year old who hasn't built anything yet. I don't think it works all that well if you have a couple decades of industry experience, know what to build because you are likely your own most finicky customer. Full disclosure, I am working on fixing this. We (at different firms) built systems that essentially took the US equity market electronic and early HFT systems. That in some ways was a much simpler problem but it still took us 2 years of building and testing with our then employer's capital, essentially serving as our own clients, before we went to our first external customer. We are following the same process now, essentially coming up with a different way of structuring our client's relationship to us, dealing with the regulatory headaches that come from that, and developing novel algorithms to handle investing for retail clients. If you are interested in this sort of thing, can program well, love data science but understand that even when doing something exciting you will spend 70-80% of your time munging data, get in touch.
- ackbar03 7y agoI don't feel like any of these ideas are going to be viable businesses...
- hitekker 7y agoIf you felt the need to write this footnote, >1. To be clear, we do not seek to replace the government and its policymakers but seek to fund startups that create solutions that provide Americans the foundations for economic growth Why did you give this project such a provocative name? It's borderline trolling.
- tyre 7y agoI agree with the spirit of these but (venture) capitalism generally feels unsuited to tackle the deepest underlying structural issue in the United States and the world: poverty. Growing up in poverty has strong correlation with traditional measures of success (high school/college graduation) as well as being shown to affect a child's IQ[1], working memory[2], language development[3], etc. At that point, we can increase access to college and healthcare and whatever else, but the damage has been done. Education can do some good, but if the problems are environmental, if the challenges are that children can no longer go to school because they need to care for siblings/children of their own[4] or work to supplement their family's income or grow up with PTSD from gun violence[5] or end up in jail because they're taking advantage of the limited means available to them, then…I mean I don't know. It feels like capitalist enterprises focused on adults might not be the real solution here. And please don't take this as criticism of YC. Their Basic Income project is the most forward-thinking approach to solving this exact problem, but precisely because it doesn't try to solve poverty through capitalist means. The risks associated with doing business with people with low income means the interest rates for lending (payday loans) are unconscionably high. Businesses just aren't incentivized to help the poor. I think it's going to require political action. Not only helping people vote—YC's funded a number of initiatives here—but specifically supporting candidates who will tackle poverty[6], who focus on the root of so much suffering in our country and our world that is not directly solvable by capitalism. And in fact, Silicon Valley's greatest success stories are directly fueling wealth inequality. Not only destroying jobs but centralizing wealth into a small corner of the world. Airbnb, Uber, Lyft, etc. take wealth from all over the world and centralize it into the Bay Area. When these companies IPO, the vast, vast majority of that wealth created comes back to Silicon Valley. Capitalism is not the answer to every problem, nor was it meant to be. Adam Smith wrote The Wealth of Nations about markets, but he also wrote The Theory of Mental Sentiments about reducing suffering. Markets to him were a tool in the pursuit of happiness, and sometimes that tool did not fit. So I agree with the sentiment here, but believe there is more to be done, perhaps more important or impactful work to be done, beyond the bounds of capitalist enterprises. [1]: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3052975/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3052975/ [2]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2662958/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2662958/ [3]: https://www.sas.upenn.edu/~mfarah/Development-povertyassociation.pdf https://www.sas.upenn.edu/~mfarah/Development-povertyassocia... [4]: Biggie Smalls: > Yeah, this album is dedicated > To all the teachers that told me I'd never amount to nothin' > To all the people that lived above the buildings that I was hustlin' in front of > Called the police on me when I was just tryin' to make some money to feed my daughter (it's all good) [5] Chance the Rapper: > It just got warm out, this the shit I've been warned 'bout > I hope that it storm in the mornin', I hope that it's pourin' out > I hate crowded beaches, I hate the sound of fireworks > And I ponder what's worse between knowing it's over and dyin' first > > 'Cause everybody dies in the summer > Wanna say your goodbyes, tell them while it's spring > I heard everybody's dying in the summer > So pray to God for a little more spring [6]: For this reason I believe that one of the greatest political tragedies of modern American politics was the assassination of Robert F. Kennedy.
- JabavuAdams 7y agoI don't see how one US for all USians can solve its own problems. You have irreconcilable internal differences and gridlock is probably the best outcome. Better than civil war or genocide? Maybe exodus? Things I believe you'd have to believe to solve the US's problems: 1) The US is not the greatest country in the world (to live in). It is certainly the most powerful empire in history. Its economic success owes as much to aggressive militarism as to some innate dynamism or goodness in the American people. 2) Being wealthy does not necessarily mean that you are good at anything other than building and/or maintaining wealth. Maybe not even that, if it's inherited. There are a lot of wealthy people with ridiculously bad models of how the world works. We shouldn't listen to them for anything except perhaps financial-planning or time-management advice. It's circular logic. 3) Unfettered capitalism is evil. The US brand of fuck all y'all ima do what I please individualism is both personally desireable and also makes it pretty much impossible to fix tragedies of the commons both nationally, and internationally. 4) The US and especially the South has never adequately addressed the legacy of slavery. There is a deep sickness in the US around fear of and disgust of African Americans. The US should look to and learn from Germany as a country that has deeply (though imperfectly) sought to make amends for its shameful history. 5) Ditto Indigenous Peoples, although I have no skin in that game, and frankly Canada is no better. 6) The US is overly religious for a modern nation. Many reforms won't really be possible with such a strongly religious population, without coercion of lots of people. Religious decay and de-programming won't come fast enough to avert irreconcilable differences over all kinds of socially-relevant science and technology in the next few decades. EDIT> fixed numbering EDIT 2> I don't see how a bunch of HN / entrepreneur / business types and investors are going to believe 1,2,3.
- dang 7y agoThis is way too generic and inflammatory to count as anything but off-topic flamebait. If you post like this, we're guaranteed a flamewar. However good your intentions and however sure you are that you're right, that's a destructive thing to do, which is why the site guidelines ask you not to, so please don't. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. Please especially don't post nationalistic slurs to HN. Your comment unfortunately dips at least a toe into that toxic waste.
- zackmorris 7y agoI'm in my 40s and old enough to remember when the government ran just fine (before the national debt grew to $3 trillion in the 80s). We grew up wanting to go to Space Camp, and build human-powered airplanes, and hack into our school to change our grades. There was none of this dour doom and gloom about government overeach we have today. Fast Times at Ridgemont High and The Breakfast Club demonstrated that our biggest problems were finding dates and getting into college, not worrying which constitutional freedom the government was going to take away next. IMHO the problem happened when the propaganda machine began telling us that the government is the enemy and can't do anything right: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xhYJS80MgYA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xhYJS80MgYA I know that many people still believe that today, but they are wrong. My personal evidence for this is the fact that our education, infrastructure, and social safety net were all much stronger in the 80s than today. The catch is, that they weren't strong for everyone. Women and minorities were largely left out. The 80s were mostly about the growing pains of transitioning from a 1950's style nuclear family economy to a 21st century one where every human being has equal dignity. That scared a lot of people, and resulted in AIDS and the war on drugs, among a great many other social ills that never.should.have.happened. The scientific evidence for the lack of justice and progress in 40 years is the vast wealth inequality today. We're what, 2, 4, 10 times more productive per capita than in 1980? But make less money adjusted for inflation? Someone stole that money. And they did it politically. The catch there is that politicans are the symptom of dysfunction, not the cause. With all that out of the way, I think we can still have a vision forward. I think that to get the USA back towards the top, we need to address every ranking where we currently suffer: education, healthcare, infant mortality, college/personal/national debt, environmental sustainability, being overworked/underpaid, lack of transparency in government, on and on. We know the problems, but our two major political parties have us deadlocked and distracted so they can skim from us to line their own pockets and those of their donors in order to maintain artificial scarcity and rent seeking to bolster hierarchy. Politics aside, there is a huge, untapped, public sector market that has been starving for capital since 1967. There was a long term agenda to convert that to a private sector market by means such as HMOs, the privatization of education, and buildup of the military industrial complex without an industrial superpower threatening us. Personally I'd like to see money be shifted from those things back to the public sector (We the People), but that's unlikely to happen because our economy is made up of the middlemen it feeds now. Luckily with our increased productivity, we can find a way to feed everyone. Government is traditionally good at long term investment. So it's going to be a shift for any private sector startup to go from short term thinking to long term planning. But for example, there is nearly infinite opportunity in things like the Green New Deal, distrupting the ISP duopolies, bringing the arts and humanities back into education, big data/machine learning in medicine, new forms of transportation, organizing labor/guilds, peace corps and legal financial instruments to provide people the means to work off and/or settle their debts, and so on. These are comparable to the federal budget, perhaps $1-4 trillion annually in untapped opportunities.
- Slam7min 7y agoMunicipal Government Employee here (from a top 15 US city). Municipal & State IT systems (particularly around cyber-security) are atrocious (See Atlanta, Baltimore Ransomware). Many of our (and our peers') systems are a hodgepodge of paper, excel sheets, legacy systems, and new off the shelf systems. At the end of the day, government maintains a strong role in the operations of cities, counties, and states. For example, our city manages the issuance of more than 250,000 permits annually, a road network of more than 10,000 lane miles, and an annual capital infrastructure budget of nearly $1 billion. There is a very real need for better IT systems that can be customized to meet the needs of differing legacy systems and data structures by municipalities. If our city is any indication of the industry, there is an insane amount of waste and mismanagement that can be attributed to poor/legacy systems or data.
- toomuchtodo 7y agohttps://www.senecagov.com/ https://www.senecagov.com/ (no association, just a fan)
- yeahitslikethat 7y agoI've tried so many times to work with government entities. It's a complete mess. It seems the only people who want to fix the problems don't work there or are fine with the problems.
- Slam7min 7y agoYup, we're a hot mess to work with. Challenges: - Procurement rules that require RFP/RFQ to obtain software and limit departments' abilities to get low cost, easy-win solutions. - Older, non-tech savvy workforce - Administrations that focus on high visibility IT projects (to public) without thinking about the not sexy foundational issues that are needed. Also politics. - Siloes between departments that result in many types of systems that don't talk to each other. - There's so much to do within government and so much that can be improved that the people who get things done are often overburdened. We're both understaffed and overstaffed at the same time. (not enough project managers!) - Startups try to sell us solutions on problems that are only a small part of a bigger issue
- atlasunshrugged 7y agoI can't help but feel that with better representation (or at least representation that felt they had to actually do right by voters) then we would be in a much better place and many of these problems would be solved through legislation. I know this is glossing over many things like lobbying, gerrymandered areas, favoritism for incumbent candidates, etc. but I really think there's something to getting more people elected who represent the people and have a serious interest in passing legislation that actually helps people and solves major societal issues. Maybe political training for "everyday" people who pledge to vote the way the majority of constituents want them to (I think there was a YC startup back in the day that had a software platform for something like this)? Maybe a political donation platform like Crowdpac that only unlocks donations to a politician if they've voted a way they promised to on an issue? Maybe a way to help bring more people to the polling station during elections to make them more representative of the population (many poorer voters can't make it as in the U.S. these are often during weekdays, have lines, etc. and they can't afford to take off work or the Uber ride to get to the location) I've been researching the area and am looking to jump on something full time (currently working for the Estonian govt but will move back into the private sector soon) but haven't landed on a final killer idea so more than open to kicking around ideas with anyone who is interested!
- dnautics 7y ago'at least representation that felt they had to actually do right by voters' What is the mechanism by which you propose to enforce this? Who gets to define "do right by voters"?
- atlasunshrugged 7y agoNot sure the exact definition, I meant it more as the politician would have to do what they said they would do when they were campaigning (as in fulfill their promises). The enforcement mechanism is what I think is most lacking today - even when politicians break promises they often still get reelected (hence the Congressional reelection rate compared to voter approval). The pessimist in me says it has to be purely based on money because money is what really talks, but maybe there's another mechanism too
- westurner 7y agoThere's money to be earned in solving for the #GlobalGoals Goals, Targets, and Indicators: The Global Goals 1. No Poverty 2. Zero Hunger 3. Good Health & Well-Being 4. Quality Education 5. Gender Equality 6. Clean Water & Sanitation 7. Affordable & Clean Energy 8. Decent Work & Economic Growth 9. Industry, Innovation & Infrastructure 10. Reduced Inequalities 11. Sustainable Cities and Communities 12. Responsible Consumption & Production 13. Climate Action 14. Life Below Water 15. Life on Land 16. Peace and Justice & Strong Institutions 17. Partnerships for the Goals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sustainable_Development_Goals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sustainable_Development_Goals
- jamesjyu 7y agoIn a recent newsletter from Robin Sloan (sci-fi writer), he shares what he's heard from a few engineers that work in China: "The Chinese government is building an OS and, in the not-too-distant future, the world will be split: those nations that adopt it, and those that don’t. This OS isn’t just software – it’s also access to Chinese capital, investments in infrastructure, and more – but it is ALSO software, a very capable suite, and it includes the world’s best facial recognition software. The sales force is out there now, signing up clients. This is happening." Anyone else heard more details on this?
- kaushikktiwari 7y agomost of the amazing facial recognition tech is actually israeli--and turns out the biggest buyers of military foreign tech tend to be competitors of china, so not sure how much legs this OS idea has, unless you mean small eastern european republics signing up
- kaushikktiwari 7y agostill love the OS idea--it found its home on a HN thread. The US has been selling the word its OS for the most of the last century, some would say about time another one showed up
- motohagiography 7y agoThe real disruptive techs for govt will be advances in things like fully homomorphic encryption (FHE), data tokenization, identity (happening today), privacy enhancing AI and other privacy enhancing technologies that facilitate data sharing that is impossible today due to jurisdictional and legal issues. One of the biggest things that is going to hit government that people haven't articulated is the effect of Agile development on service economics. Short version is, iterative development was designed for things that grow revenue, so the cost of maintaining them using devops is minor when you are a growth SaaS business. Waterfall methods were designed to be built by expensive developers and passed on to cheaper operations groups for long term maintenance lifetimes of a decade or more. Keeping developers on staff to patch libraries, iterate on features and maintain solutions that have fixed revenue/funding allotments is much more expensive than most agencies understand they are signing up for. Going to a cloud subscription model creates massive procurement problems with vendor lock-in and competitiveness issues, and it also takes PII and sensitive data out of their custody and control. I think to understand government, you need to understand public sector economics, which are centrally planned and do not reflect the reality of the outside economic world.
- pron 7y agoHere's a better idea: encourage talented young people to join civil service or run for office. Companies can help government in many ways but have a relatively low positive impact.
- lifeisstillgood 7y agoI have been banging on about this sort of thing for ages http://oss4gov.org/manifesto http://oss4gov.org/manifesto I have come to the conclusion that commercial offerings in the government space are just fucking over the taxpayer and should be replaced by open source services maintained in specific ways - OSS for gov should be seen as a pro bono "year out" for professionals on their journeyman year - OSS needs to be funded at government level for development and for ops separately. Something like a kickstarter / auction for features and for support - this oss suite gets to become well known and cross supported - because so many small companies work on it they can become a matrix like support network - no worries that there is not a single huge supplier "supporting" their crap source, here comes a "Guardians of the Galaxy" web of small ships all able to pick up the load from another because they all know this big code base - This is partly "let's bring our government into the digital age, but more importantly its "let's bring all governments" - including those not so democratic. Look at how the GDPR just made itself the default. Now think of every small interaction with government being designed with individual agency in mind. this is potentially the biggest act of cultural "laying down of rails" since the Napoleonic code. Shall Western democracy do it? - remember "developer hegemony" - this is where such firms would do well Any way - bed time so not well put but it all popped into my head so wanted to share
- laurenWWH 7y agoI have been working a project to create a place where youth can exhibit their writing talents outside of the standard educational system. Exceptional students exist in all schools, but in districts like Oakland, their work never gets visibility. We Write Here (http://wewritehere.com http://wewritehere.com) aims to fix that. Student created content has way more relevance than what the government can mandate. Eventually, we will expand beyond writing. I was a K-12 teacher for the past 10 years, and know this to be a critical need. I have been building this for the past 6 months, and we have gotten 200+ submission, and published and awarded 25+ amazing students. Does this fit under Government 2.0? Even otherwise, would love to hear what the community feels about it.
- dominotw 7y ago> 57% of Americans believe that children in America today will be worse off financially than their parents. I cannot seem to find this in the linked survey( seems to link to some methodology about us-german relations). Can someone help me find it. only google hit for this is this YC article. > We believe this mindset is the result of increased family debt, stagnant wages, and a lack of government commitment to provide equal access to the basic services families need to thrive. What is the basis of this guess?
- kaushikktiwari 7y agoLove the debate on this thread whether startups can't meaningfully tackle deep societal problems. We are the working on building a free universal basic safety net for all: https://betterbank.app/ https://betterbank.app/ Essentially it's a checking account+insurance policy, bank with us and if you ever got hurt we will pay upto $5k in cash…use it for out-of-pocket expenses+ lost wages. It's free because we make money from debit interchange, targeted at either uninsured young folks who find obamacare to be too expensive or families with high deductibles. Do we qualify as a profit minded start also doing good? If not, are there any other models out there
- rkagerer 7y agoI've been thinking about creating a platform for discussion of present-day issues, built on a reputation-based contribution system akin to how StackOverflow surfaces quality content. The goal is to give average citizens a place to go to: - become informed about all sides of an issue in a quick and easy way - share a new opinion, or up-vote a remark that resonates - monitor and engage in affairs you care about while ignoring those you don't I feel democracy in North America needs to foster more constituent participation, and I think the internet can turn governance into a two-way street. Anyone could open an issue, no matter how controversial. Anyone can provide their opinion, and one of the challenges is figuring out how to engineer the site such that high-quality submissions float to the top while trolling and inappropriate remarks sieve down to obscurity. Conflicting positions would be grouped into major camps with the top-voted contributions of each equally showcased (picture the Amazon review page with the most helpful positive and negative review on top). Each issue would have a section organizing fact-checked, unbiased research presented from well-reputed sources (possibly distinguished through community moderation) and make that work easy to cite. It would also track related, real-world events as they occur (e.g. bills being voted on, court cases, protests, breaking news, etc). We'd link to existing sites where it makes sense (e.g. Wikipedia, Factcheck/Politifact, stuff like TheyWorkForYou, etc.) The site would offer (but not require) to collect your demographics and share anonymized stats with levels or branches of government you choose (e.g. local counselor, municipal utilities, state, etc) or social researchers. You could opt in to lightweight surveys from your representatives (targeted by geography, demographics, or issues of interest) to help them gain more granular understanding of the needs of their constituents. This isn't fully fleshed out and I know it covers a lot of ground - too much for one startup to do all at once. Some of it has already been attempted by others. Would love to hear your thoughts on it. One thing I became convinced of pretty quickly is in order for this to succeed it needs to be built and hosted by a non-profit able to maintain a strong public reputation for being unbiased.
- newmac 7y ago"[..] the goal of making America a better place" This sucks to see from YC. So many of us around the world look to YC as an accessible version of American prosperity. America is an exclusive and very rich club however. A bigger impact than improving American government would be: Improving American Democracy. Improving global government. I know things have changed a lot in America in the last few years, but I didn't realize how pervasive the nationalistic mental model had become. YC: Do good in the world, please.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThis is specifically asking for "Government 2.0" startups. I imagine if they framed that as for the world that would be quite the can of worms and potentially interpreted as calling for global governmental overthrow. It's reasonably safe to say "oh, god, the US Has Issues and please help us with it." It's pretty widely accepted that America is shite for a wealthy, developed country by quite a few metrics.
- AlexanderNull 7y agoAmerica is in the world. Next question please. Seriously though, there's millions of people here who have been left out of the exclusive and rich club. The UN repeatedly dings the USA for the standard of living of many of our citizens and our terrible legal/justice system. So much of our government meant to help those people is either deliberately underfunded or mismanaged and can use all the help it can get. How the heck can we figure out how to help government abroad when we can't even get our own right?
- CPLX 7y agoI have a request too. I’d like to see a reduction in the power and influence of unaccountable billionaires over our public policy. I wonder if the people who write things like this have processed the fact that they are no longer insurgents, but the entrenched establishment with a very bad history of exploiting the masses for private gain. Any sane person should instinctively distrust the idea of giving valley tech startups and private equity firms more power over the mechanics of government.
- tootie 7y agoI think this is not the real root of any particular problem. I think entrenched power is good at exploiting weakness in the system. The fact is that the major pro-wealthy policies aren't snuck in as obscure riders to normal policy. Candidates run on a pro-wealthy platform and people cheer for it. The question is why are voters so easily convinced to vote against their interests.
- sjg007 7y agoSome food for thought: https://www.vox.com/recode/2019/5/22/18634612/anand-giridharadas-billionaires-philanthropy-zuckerberg-bezos-kara-swisher-decode-podcast-interview https://www.vox.com/recode/2019/5/22/18634612/anand-giridhar...
- edoceo 7y agoMy team and I are working on software tools (GPL3) for government technology. I'm excited to see these developments!