2 ms·
>> How would it work exactly, I wouldn't know which is sort of the point. But sooner or later representations of abstractions within the code would appear withi
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
>> How would it work exactly, I wouldn't know which is sort of the point. But sooner or later representations of abstractions within the code would appear within the graphs.
Sorry to be mean but all this sounds awfully confused and terribly hand-wavy. It sounds like you think that stuff would just magically work like you want it, if only you mix up enough ingredients (data, computation, neural networks, evolution, abstractions, representations, graphs...).
Well, stuff doesn't just magickally work. Lots of people (like, literally thousands) are training machine learning models and not a single model has ever come close to "understanding" anything. I'd start from trying to figure out why that is the case, and then see if something can be done about it.
Otherwise -and, sorry again, but- all these are mere time-wasting fantasies.
- tracer4201 7y agoWhen op used the word “understanding”, I interpreted it as some program that can provide code snippets, skeletons, or whatever abstraction in some contextual way so it’s not just a dumb table lookup. You’re post is unnecessarily pessimistic and generally bad faith. And maybe ops vision can’t be realized today, but if someone is thinking beyond the current state of the art, it’s short sighted and incredibly ignorant to dismiss them as time wasting fantasies.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoAssuming the OP expects to gain something from this conversation, the most benefit that can be gained is from telling them why their idea makes no sense. That is what "good faith" means and that is what I did. Your comment, on the other hand, seems to be confusing good faith with indulgence. Just saying "yes" to people and being nice to them does them no favours.
- tracer4201 7y agoA discussion that makes us think about the boundaries of what is or isn’t possible today is indulgence? You failed spectacularly by your own definition of a good faith discussion by dismissing ops post as “fantasy”. You give no explanation of why it is unachievable today or why it would continue to be impossible in the future. My previous team had a member who outright dismissed ideas and criticized things for the sake of sounding intelligent without proposing solutions to further the discussion or solve the problem. We let him go. Good luck.
- TBF-RnD 7y agoThank you :D Couldn't have written it better myself. Maybe there is an minimal test case that could demonstrate deeper understanding. Sort of a fizz-buzz for AI, to separate the parrots from the thinkers so to speak. Food for thought. Meanwhile I am to busy on other grandiose plans to give it to much attention ATM.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]