3 ms·
It simply isn't true that we're completely ignorant on these questions. We know an awful lot about the chemistry of all the known elements and it's pretty clear
by simonh 7y ago
It simply isn't true that we're completely ignorant on these questions. We know an awful lot about the chemistry of all the known elements and it's pretty clear water and Carbon are by far the best candidates for supporting complex, rich chemistries across a wide range of environmental conditions.
It's not that alternative life chemistries are necessarily impossible, but equally it's plausible that they might well be non-viable above a very primitive level at best. They would have many orders of magnitude fewer options available to them for biochemical resources, pathways and molecular geometries to take advantage of. Chemically speaking, not all elements are created equal.
Take Sulphur for example. It's far more reactive than carbon, so chemically unstable in many more environmental conditions. It generally only forms linear chains, rather than the complex branching structures of carbon. It also bonds with far fewer other elements in ways that are likely to be chemically useful. If you have carbon available, Sulphur is a very poor substitute. It's high reactivity might make it a passable alternative to Oxygen though.
- dumbfoundded 7y agoIt sounds like you're paraphrasing the wiki page I attached in a different comment: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypothetical_types_of_biochemistry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypothetical_types_of_biochemi... To address your point, I would say we are extremely ignorant about what the solution space of life looks like. Hydrothermal vents are a very recent discovery. Before this discovery, it was unexpected that such complex and large organisms could exist without light from the sun. As a planet, Earth is teeming with life. Everywhere you look on Earth, you can find it. Even though we have a good understanding of chemistry, we have little clue as to what's important to form complex and self-propagating systems.