3 ms·
No one denies that the climate changed before and that it's a natural thing. The problem is that in 100 years we went from slow changes to 10 times the amplitud
by lm28469 7y ago
No one denies that the climate changed before and that it's a natural thing. The problem is that in 100 years we went from slow changes to 10 times the amplitudes ever recorded.
The questions isn't "Do these cycles exist ?" it's "Are we sure we want to trigger one early ?"
Greenhouse effect is a very well studied effect. CO2 / other gases level are a very well studied field. CO2/other gases dramatically increased since the industrial revolution. Are you also denying that ?
When you study something you have to look at the settings in which it happens and look at the time frame. Sure changes happened 10k+ years ago, that's not invalidating anything related to our role in the current change.
> Thinking humans are responsible for global warming is like thinking humans are responsible for the rise and decline of tides because we drink water.
You won't win anyone over with such nonsensical arguments.
https://www.climatecentral.org/news/the-last-time-co2-was-this-high-humans-didnt-exist-15938 https://www.climatecentral.org/news/the-last-time-co2-was-th...
https://theconversation.com/the-three-minute-story-of-800-000-years-of-climate-change-with-a-sting-in-the-tail-73368 https://theconversation.com/the-three-minute-story-of-800-00...
https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/global-warming/last-2000-years https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/global-warming/last-2000-years
https://xkcd.com/1732/ https://xkcd.com/1732/
- anthuman 7y ago10 times the amplitudes ever recorded? Or are you just conveniently only looking at the past 150 years? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Last_Glacial_Maximum#/media/File:Evolution_of_temperature_in_the_Post-Glacial_period_according_to_Greenland_ice_cores.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Last_Glacial_Maximum#/media/Fi... And my argument of taking water from the seas causing the rise and fall of tides is just as laughable as the "climatecentral.org" nonsense that is pushed everywhere. And linking to agenda driven "climatecentral.org" propagandists won't win anyone over either. Neither will linking to a 2000 year climate range when I purposely talked about 20000 year climate range. The truth of the matter is that climate has change far more drastically in the past and will do so in the future. And the truth of the matter is that we don't know why climate changes drastically. Those who claim they know are simply liars and propagandists. Just like for much of human history, we had no idea that the moon was responsible for the rise and fall of tides. Maybe one day we will know - perhaps there are planetary reasons. Perhaps it is something internal to earth. Yes, the greenhouse effect is very well studied and it's pretty much been proven that it doesn't apply to climate change. Ever wonder why the propagandists don't talk about it much any longer? We can actually calculate the temperature of a greenhouse ( there are actual formulas for this ). When we modeled that to the earth, it predicted much higher temperatures than we have. How embarrassing. So the model doesn't work, otherwise, the problem would be solved. It's almost like the earth isn't a greenhouse. Whatever the forces causing climate change, I think we can safely say that natural forces are far more important than humans. Though that idea may bruise our egos a bit. The industry of climate fearmongering has more to do with politics/geopolitics than climate or science. We don't definitely know why we had a "little ice age" in the last millenia. We don't know why much of the ice in the northern hemisphere melted 10000+ years ago. We don't know why much of the northern hemisphere was covered in ice ( parts of which was covered in ice 2 miles high ). We don't know the definitive cause of any of the climate shifts just in the last 20000 years. But you and your "consensus" makers are sure about climate change today. Right? Even though every climate model today fails. We don't have a definitive climate model. We don't know why any of the climate change happened in the past. Yet, you are absolutely sure of man-made climate change.
- lm28469 7y ago> 10 times the amplitudes ever recorded? Or are you just conveniently only looking at the past 150 years? Look at the units. 15c in 1000 years is less than what we're expecting if we continue on our trend (+2 to +5c by 2100, probably more after that once the reinforcement loop kicks in properly). > The industry of climate fearmongering has more to do with politics/geopolitics than climate or science. Yet the vast majority of deniers are politicians or people with no scientific credentials, and the extremely vast majority of scientists recognise that humans play a role in the current climate change. > We don't know ... we don't know ... we don't know ... Yeah sure, there are many things we don't know. But the things we know all point toward the same conclusion: the current change is at least partially man made and it'll suck balls if we continue on the trend. > Yet, you are absolutely sure of man-made climate change. Alright, let's say, for the sake of argument, that I'm wrong; what then ? We can start mining coal again and stop investing in green energies I guess. Everything we do to curb down climate change, consuming less, polluting less, &c. is a net positive even if climate change isn't man made. > We don't definitely know why we had a "little ice age" in the last millenia. Yeah but what we definitely know is that it was not even -1c globally, over 200 years. For comparison we gained 1c between ~1910 and 2010, we expect 2 to 5 more by 2100. > Though that idea may bruise our egos a bit. The irony is lost on you I guess ...
- josho 7y ago> When we modeled that to the earth, it predicted much higher temperatures than we have. Source? I did find one a year or so ago (from a site like 'skeptical science' or similar name), but when I dug into it the author cherry picked data to make his conclusion accurate and left off recent data. But, when I went to the author's own publications with current temperatures the model was accurate over the full time period. Merely the skeptic simply choose a time period ending that showed a short term divergence.