4 ms·
I find the working visa concept ridiculous. Why would a nationality be a topic in the hiring process? It's ridiculous to have the government involved in the hi
by mrtksn 7y ago
I find the working visa concept ridiculous. Why would a nationality be a topic in the hiring process? It's ridiculous to have the government involved in the hiring process and the first vetting step towards employment being the immigration office.
Yes, I understand the problems that limitless free movement might create but it's still unpleasant to see that people claiming to be egalitarian or people who say that want meritocracy to discuss only the implementation details of the visa system in the context of exceptions(i.e. you cannot work in this country except if you personally meet the following criteria).
Why not create a system that is fair at the core, something like "your passport countries' democracy score, worker rights, environmental protection standards and human rights need to be in the same range as the country you want to work at". The visa-free travel and visa-free working right essentially boil down to this anyway, why not remove all the exceptions and let people optimize their countries towards these metrics if they want to work in some other country?
In the current form, immigration is painful for the immigrants and doesn't do any good for the countries that send those immigrants.
- jldugger 7y ago> it's still unpleasant to see that people claiming to be egalitarian or people who say that want meritocracy What ever gave you the impression that the "America #1" crowd was either of those things?
- mrtksn 7y agoThe populists say all the time that they want meritocracy and complain that those women/minorities/immigrants are hired based on their gender/race/passport instead of their skills. They are populist probably because these opinions are popular.
- nl 7y agoI think you'll find that the "America First" crowd and the "Meritocracy" crowd are listening to different parts of the arguments from the same people, and just hearing what they want to hear. I think there is a strand in their argument that being American is a merit in itself, but this isn't usually stated explicitly except in forms like "Americans for American Jobs". I'm not arguing this makes any logical sense though - it doesn't.
- mrtksn 7y agoI see your point. However, even if being an American(or any other nationality) was merit by itself, why would you demand government involvement in the hiring process? If being an American is a merit, then companies could choose to hire based on this merit. I'm just trying to understand that way of thinking. Maybe they think it's a merit but are insecure about it and demand recognition for because their experience shows that companies do not value this merit enough?
- nl 7y agoThere really isn't a lot of point trying to understand an emotional argument as a logical argument. It isn't.
- pas 7y agoMaybe the best way to look at this is to recognize that people have concepts of how the world should look like, naturally that usually includes pleasantries for them. And when the world does not match their predictions, they want to correct for this error. Of course depending on cognitive patterns (which depend on exposure to others' cognition, eg. upbringing, peers, and all their previous experiences factor in to path dependence) one might try to look into themselves, look for their faulty base assumptions, look for causes external to their own sphere, and so on. Normally, people who are not familiar with the problems of borders, the arbitrariness of them, who grew up in a culture that never experienced a downsizing country, a war in their country, stories about how political persecution and/or absolutely bleak prospects drove hundreds of thousands (or millions) of their fellow countrymen away are not going to be very understanding of these problems. On the other hand they will understand that their life is not going as well as they would like it. And they are caught by the meme net cast by whatever lucky political group. (And "blaming the victim" fused with "the outside enemy" is a pretty proven strategy for populists.) And populists always advocate for more power to themselves to fix things. (Obviously, politics is about power, and populism is pretty much the shit tier direct marketing of politics.) Hence the thinking of "america first", "make america great first", before we deal with whatever is outside our borders. This also implies that listen to "americans first", and then listen to any external criticism. (This is again always a pretty great strategy to consolidate power - a form of divide and conquer.) And naturally, this has the effect of basically diverting the attention away from global issues. And since we're living in a global world for quite some time, without at least partially understanding global issues making sense of the local ones is a fool's errand. Because a thinking that tries to somehow understand everything locally inevitably runs into "outside powers caused this to us", and this feeds powerlessness. (It doesn't matter that the USA has and had a very significant factor in shaping that "outside world".)
- bruceb 7y agoRemittances to India stood at US$68.968 billion in 2017, nearly 12 billion from US alone.
- conanbatt 7y agoAnd what does india do with the 70billion dollars, but ultimately spend them on the U.S. as well.
- ap3 7y ago>In the current form, immigration is painful for the immigrants and doesn't do any good for the countries that send those immigrants. No country is “sending” anyone. It’s an individual choice. Some people decide to apply for H1B because it is advantageous to them, but a lot more decide to stay in their home country. H1B is voluntary
- mrtksn 7y agoI didn't use "Sending" literally, of course[0]. I think you miss the point by a yuge margin. [0] Sending is used quite often in this context, you can google it or look at its usage in this Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_by_country It's used together with "receiving" and it's used to indicate the origin of the immigrants.
- ramblerman 7y ago> Why not create a system that is fair at the core, something like "your passport countries' democracy score, worker rights, environmental protection standards and human rights need to be in the same range as the country you want to work at". So anyone who doesn't need to migrate then?
- mrtksn 7y agoNot at all, people don't immigrate only because they are desperate. The desperate ones are actually called refugees anyway. Think of it as if people from Texas moving to California, I'm sure it happens all the time. Often the right opportunity for you is not in the city, country or even continent you live in. Sometimes it's not the right culture for you and you want to a place with more liberal/conservative/christian/islamic/etc culture.
- dominotw 7y ago> desperate ones are actually called refugees there is an actual definition for a refugee and its not "be desperate" . There are more than 500 million ppl deseperate to move to usa very few of them qualify to be refugee.
- dominotw 7y ago> "your passport countries' democracy score, worker rights, environmental protection standards and human rights need to be in the same range as the country you want to work at". Wouldn't that exclude almost all of the current immigrants to USA. Chinese, Indians, mexicans, filipinos ect.
- dominotw 7y ago> ridiculous to have the government involved in the hiring process So make all kinds of discrimination a fair game?
- thorwasdfasdf 7y agoWell, I think it's meant to discourage permanent immigration and also protect jobs which are in short supply. The worse you make conditions for immigration the fewer immigrants you have. As population density increases, it's only natural that countries want to reduce population. Between telling people to not have children and preventing immigrants from entering, politically it's more palatable to stop immigration.
- jonhendry18 7y ago> Why not create a system that is fair at the core, something like "your passport countries' democracy score, worker rights, environmental protection standards and human rights need to be in the same range as the country you want to work at". How is that "fair at the core" when it penalizes individuals for factors they have no control over?