3 ms·
> Picture in picture is a great feature, but it works inconsitently between apps, with some not at all, and why can't I arbitrarily size the video and put it in
by walterbell 8y ago
> Picture in picture is a great feature, but it works inconsitently between apps, with some not at all, and why can't I arbitrarily size the video and put it into the corners?
PiP video can be resized, up to a limit of about 1/4 of the screen.
> While per default watching a video/tv program rather small, I would like to have the ability to enlarge the picture, if something interesting comes up.
There's an icon (diagonal arrow) to exit PiP mode and return to full-screen in the original app.
> file management: this is really painful, so many limitations in that area. No ability to copy files from an attached USB stick
iXpand USB drives are supported by some apps (e.g. nPlayer, LumaFusion). There's a rumor that external storage support will arrive in iOS13, hopefully without too many restrictions.
- _ph_ 8y agoPiP video can be resized, up to a limit of about 1/4 of the screen. Right, thats the problem. It is nice for keeping track of what happens, but e.g. when watching a football game, you want the ability to magnify, as I wrote, to an arbitrary video size. Also, why can't I put the video into the corner, why does it keep a significant distance to the screen edges, so covering more of my app than necessary for the video size. There's an icon (diagonal arrow) to exit PiP mode and return to full-screen in the original app. Which can be slow, and not work at all. Also, it might be impossible to get back to the PIP (depending on the app) and also affects the app you were using with the PIP. Why can't I just enlarge the PIP to cover most of my screen, at least up to 75%?
- walterbell 8y agoWindowing will change in iOS13. Hopefully demos will appear at WWDC in a few weeks.
- _ph_ 8y agoI sincerely hope so, assuming it changes into a really useful UI. The PIP is a prominent example of some iOS restrictions which don't seem to have any technical justifications. Someone seems to have decided it looks cute as it is, without any usability in mind. The macOS version of PIP has the same restrictions - a big reason why I haven't used this feature in years. At least you are allowed to freely position the PIP when pressing the CMD key.
- thirdsun 8y agoI agree - videos should actually support all those split screen modes used by apps.
- _ph_ 8y agoThere's an icon (diagonal arrow) to exit PiP mode and return to full-screen in the original app. Just tested it with the streaming app of a major TV station (ZDF for the German readers) and while it ends PiP, you are not getting to see the program in full screen mode, they overlay it with the apps UI, covering up 1/3 of the stream.
- thirdsun 8y agoThat icon takes you back to the original source app of the video - from there you can initiate fullscreen (I'd assume). I guess it would make sense to allow going from PiP directly to fullscreen, but then you'd need another button to return to the app, or you could just use the multitasking gesture to return that app manually - however I guess that's too confusing for some users. Double tapping the PiP video to toggle fullscreen would be a nice compromise in my opinion.
- _ph_ 8y agoYes, I get back to the app and from there I can restart full-screen showing. But that is far to slow, if I only quickly want the PiP to be larger (also removes the app which was active before completely from the screen). But I fail to see why the PiP has any size and position restrictions in the first place.
- walterbell 8y agoYou can enter full screen in the original app, before switching to PiP. Then the icon to exit PiP will return to full screen (or the app's video state when PiP was initiated).
- _ph_ 8y agoNo it doesn't. That is the problem, every app is able to implement their own screwy behavior.
- jxdxbx 8y agoYou can also mount iXpands in the Files app via FileBrowser, making them accessible to any modern iOS app just like any other file provider.