3 ms·
I don't know the real relationship between Google and Go, but Go is very much a product of its current core team, who are (AFAIK) all veterans of Bell Labs (Rob
by mcguire 7y ago
I don't know the real relationship between Google and Go, but Go is very much a product of its current core team, who are (AFAIK) all veterans of Bell Labs (Robert Griesemer?) and all have the same Bell Labs approach.
Bell Labs invented Not Invented Here syndrome. You can know this to be true because there is no way this group of people could have the syndrome so bad any other way. The other side of the coin is that they are very, very good. You can know that because they do a lot of interesting, novel work without obviously (or obviously without) having looked at any other research in that field.
Take for example, Chris's comment, "(The most clear and obvious illustration of this is what happened with Go modules, where one member of Google's Go core team discarded the entire system the outside Go community had been working on in favour of a relatively radically different model. See eg for one version of this history.)"
The second link there is to https://peter.bourgon.org/blog/2018/07/27/a-response-about-dep-and-vgo.html.[^1][^2] https://peter.bourgon.org/blog/2018/07/27/a-response-about-d... From that: "[RSC and the dep-pies] discussed dep at the GopherCon contributor summit. Matt Farina says that [Russ Cox] said [he] could do better if [he] went off on [his] own and built something. ... The clear impression was that Russ wasn’t going to engage with the committee, the research [the committee] had prepared for him, or the prototype product of that research, dep — at least, not yet. The clear impression was that Russ had his own hypothesis about what a solution would look like, and that he was interested in validating those hypotheses, by himself. ... Russ decided to implement his ideas on his own, and make a proposal without us, and without telling us that’s what he was doing until it was essentially done."
This is what I'm talking about. If your ideas suitably mesh with their philosophy, they may be adopted. If they do not, the Bell Labs team will ignore them completely. And if they think the problem is a problem (and they don't, in many, many cases), they are quite capable of doing an end-run around you and producing a solution which satisfies their perception of the problem.
Go may or may not be Google's language. Go is the Go-lang team's language and you will go where they want you to go, to adapt MS's old slogan. To an extent, it's similar to Perl; one's success as a Perl programmer depends entirely on your ability to hold your mouth right and successfully simulate Larry Wall. Perl is not a DWIM language, it's a do-what-Larry-would-mean-if-he-wrote-what-you-wrote language.
[^1] I myself do not endorse the technical ideas in that post. "[Something] does not support using multiple major versions of a program in a single build. This alone is a complete showstopper." is true. The fact that most tools don't do it---and have to live with the resulting pain---simply means that it's hard, not that it's not necessary.
[^2] A previous discussion of Go modules here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17534923 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17534923