4 ms·
It normalized an easy-to-digest parody of nerd culture, perhaps. Nothing honked me off more than people watching BBT and thinking they understood "people like m
by falcolas 7y ago
It normalized an easy-to-digest parody of nerd culture, perhaps. Nothing honked me off more than people watching BBT and thinking they understood "people like me".
- doctorRetro 7y agoAgreed, but even then, I'd argue that particular parody of nerd culture has already long since been normalized. Maybe all BBT did was broaden it a little bit, but a parody it remained.
- Godel_unicode 7y agoIt's always amusing to me that people who pride themselves on emotional intelligence and inclusiveness will ask things like: "is your (nerd) friend we're going to dinner with more Sheldon or Leonard?". If you press them on this, you then get some flavor of "ok but you know what I mean..."
- Retra 7y ago"Why are you so socially awkward" -- person who mistakenly thinks this is a 'graceful' conversation starter.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vokep 7y agoIts a bit irritating, but empathizing with someone that might ask that...I'm not sure what the problem is? I would know exactly what they meant.
- Godel_unicode 7y agoIf you don't get it, I can't explain it to you.
- vokep 7y agoI...do get it though? Or...well I guess I don't get why this is a problem?
- Tehchops 7y agoThis. The first season at least dabbled in a more honest take. Season >=2 went with whatever was palatable and popular enough to get more viewers.
- Fishman343 7y agoYes, there's a big difference between riding the zeitgeist and actually influencing it. There is something oddly nice about an older person saying "Oh, just like Sheldon!" (or sometimes Moss from the IT Crowd) if I mention dungeons and dragons or online games. It might be a very simplified and / or exploitative version of nerd culture but at least there's an instant point of reference for us both.
- devindotcom 7y agoSurely the same could be said of nearly any network sitcom involving a subculture or demographic. That's kind of the idea of broad entertainment. The problem comes when the parody comes at the expense of the culture - that's exploitation. But by the time BBT was airing and popular, nerds were, and remain, to a certain extent a privileged class, not an oppressed one. They have high-paying jobs, ordinary successful lives, and look back at the old stereotypes of pocket protectors and social awkwardness with a sort of bemusement. Nerds are not a vulnerable class and haven't been in a long time. Nor is "nerd culture" particularly cohesive. That may not be the case when the group being parodied is genuinely being oppressed or discriminated against and is often not in a position to push back against that. Exploitation in that case can be real and harmful.
- 0815test 7y ago> Surely the same could be said of nearly any network sitcom involving a subculture or demographic. That's kind of the idea of broad entertainment. No, it isn't quite the same thing. ESR actually points out the specific problem with BBT in this excerpt from the blogpost I linked: > Bleagh. This is supposed to be a show about geniuses? It’s not. It’s a show about a dimwit’s idea of what bright people are like. The slowest person in my peer group could out-think and out-create any of these sad-sack imitations of “smart” on any day of the week. These actors are not bright, and don’t know how to fake it on screen. (emphasis added). The comparison to blackface that someone else made, however inherently contentious (for eminently understandable reasons) is indeed on point.
- com2kid 7y ago> Nerds are not a vulnerable class and haven't been in a long time. The ones who get a CS degree and get a good high paying job, sure. The ones still in middle school? Not so much. The ones who aren't programmers? Not so much. The nerds growing up in communities where free thinking and geeky passions are looked down upon, sometimes violently? Not so much. And those kids will reach adulthood dealing with some rather nasty issues. Everything from not having learned great socialization skills, to a poor self image, to a lot of stuff in-between. Stereotypes are bad, having a show that treats people as 1 dimensional disposable arch-types that exist only to be laughed at, is bad, no matter who the subject matter is.
- 2muchcoffeeman 7y agoIt normalized an easy-to-digest parody of nerd culture, perhaps. Isn’t this true of almost all subcultures that get co-opted? This sort of thing reminds me of IFLScience. No one ever loved science. Certain parts of it just became popular.