2 ms·
But they still have IP correlatable with server logs with timestamps and everything, plus you get a new client side DB what will be perked into by every adware
by baybal2 7y ago
But they still have IP correlatable with server logs with timestamps and everything, plus you get a new client side DB what will be perked into by every adware in existence.
The stated goal of untrackability by timestamp matching is simply not achieved with just 12 to 24 temporal dithering for anything, but biggest websites on the planet.
They say it is privacy preserving, then, 5m minute into the text it comes out that it is nothing like that at all.
It is the next "do not track" header.
But to me it feels to be Apple's first "carrot and stick" step to chip away at Google walled garden.
See: few month ago they launched both a ad cookie killer, and a 3rd party cookie firewall by default. Clearly, there was a huge net loss of ad money nearly momentarily, they clearly wanted it to be a surprise, to push ad businesses into panic. Now they come with a stick: play our walled garden, and you get your ad cookie back.
In other news, people were noticing that Apple was hiring senior Ad tech people for quite some time now.
- om2 7y agoI don't see how this proposal has anything to do with an Apple walled garden? Nothing here special cases or favors Apple. We welcome issues on possible limits of the privacy protections though.
- baybal2 7y ago1. If nobody will support this scheme other than Apple, then it is destined to become another DNT. 2. Apple become a gatekeeper for an AD revenue from Apple devices, being able to "switch lights off" on anybody with a single browser autoupdate. To any business person, it looks like a very clear ultimatum
- olliej 7y agoWhat is the “switching the lights off” threat? The comparison to DNT is not reasonable: DNT was a proposal the originated in the ad industry in response to a government inquiry into their gross abuse of consumers. It was positioned to head off actual regulation, despite all browser vendors knowing it would not actually work. The Ad industry killed DNT when they announced that they would no longer recognize it (and were in fact using it for tracking) despite them positioning it as the “solution” to their own abuses. Once that occurred it became clear that the only solution is for browsers to break all tracking directly. This is merely something that would allow the ad ecosystem to still function in the absence of tracking. This is the answer to (1) - it’s not a matter of advertisers adopting it, if a browser vendor blocks tracking then advertising based on tracking is broken. So all that happens is those users are not tracked, and also don’t produce revenue.