4 ms·
Could it have anything to do with most of them likely only wanting to hire people geographically in (or near) NYC? And hand-in-hand with that, the startups don
by mgkimsal 16y ago
Could it have anything to do with most of them likely only wanting to hire people geographically in (or near) NYC? And hand-in-hand with that, the startups don't really want to pay something adequate for someone with the necessary experience to live modestly within commuting distance?
I know more people who have offshored engineering/dev work to India and the like than send work to developers in Nebraska, Kansas, Alabama, etc. Then they complain about the less than stellar work, with timezone diffs, English proficiency, cultural differences and so on.
There's a pretty large pool of people who are willing to work remote and - gasp - even travel to your main office sometimes, but who simply aren't going to uproot and live in NYC to make $100k. For someone raising a family, they could make $75k in Omaha or Tupelo and have a much better quality of life.
http://www.indeed.com/jobs?q=c%23&l=nyc http://www.indeed.com/jobs?q=c%23&l=nyc
http://www.indeed.com/jobs?q=java&l=nyc http://www.indeed.com/jobs?q=java&l=nyc
9400 Java jobs in NYC, but only 900 are estimated at $150k or higher.
Cost of living between Omaha (at 75k) and NYC:
http://www.bestplaces.net/col/?salary=75000&city1=53137000&city2=53651000 http://www.bestplaces.net/col/?salary=75000&city1=531370...
Cost of living between Nashville (at 80k) and NYC:
http://www.bestplaces.net/col/?salary=80000&city1=54752006&city2=53651000 http://www.bestplaces.net/col/?salary=80000&city1=547520...
You need roughly $150k in NYC to have an approximate lifestyle. Yet only 10% of the jobs pay that.
The concept of 'hiring' itself may be due for a makeover, and a 'JIT' approach to company development may be in the cards for companies struggling to hire the right people (which they'll likely lay off the moment things go south again).
- mgkimsal 16y agoAdding on: We've also had a housing crisis which is keeping many people chained to their current regions due to underwater mortgages and no housing sales. 5 years ago people could move their families across country for a good job. Even if they want to now, they can't. This is just not acknowledged by most companies. I was approached a couple years ago by a company that was starting up - 'ex google founders' and all that. The product/service was pitched to me as a collaboration/communication tool to help remote teams work more effectively. Sounded great, but I was not allowed to work remote. I had to upsticks and move to SF. To work on a remote collaboration tool. WTF?
- nolite 16y agohow did their product end up turning out, out of curiosity?
- mgkimsal 16y agoI never followed up and they never gave me the full name until I'd sign an NDA (which I didn't).
- jayzee 16y agowell in all fairness their product was not developed yet!
- nostrademons 16y agoThere really is a huge difference between working in person with someone and working remotely. I've seen misunderstandings that could waste literally weeks of programmer time get corrected by a 15-minute pair-programming session. It doesn't really surprise me that ex-Googlers would insist you work in person. As a large multinational, Google feels the pain of distributed teams more than many companies, which is probably why they're founding their startup. It'd probably sink their startup if one of their key employees was not working in person with them.
- gaustin 16y ago> I've seen misunderstandings that could waste literally weeks of programmer time get corrected by a 15-minute pair-programming session. Are they things that wouldn't have similarly been resolved by remote pairing?
- nostrademons 16y agoWith what tools? In theory, if you have a shared screen, and real-time voice communication, and remote whiteboards, and ideally real-time video, it should be basically the same as being there. The technology to do this is very, very expensive at the moment, though, which is presumably the raison d'etre of this startup. You also miss out a lot on serendipity. Many of the best ideas that eventually become actual Google products happen because a bunch of folks are hanging out over beers, or they're sharing the latest cool thing they've stumbled across on the Internet, or they're shooting each other with nerf darts before going home. This sort of relaxed socialization seems to be exactly what you need to get creative ideas to bubble up to the surface. When you have to feel like you're "on a call" to get together with someone, you don't get this sort of spontaneous idea generation.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- earl 16y agoThat's fine, but not all of us are 20 anymore. Some people -- including some very experienced devs! -- want to do boring shit like not be broke, have savings, have a 401K, take vacations, etc. Even if they live in NYC.
- sleight42 16y agoAnd I'm one of them -- except that I still want my work to be fun. I got fired up enough about this topic that I wrote more on the matter here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1998515 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1998515
- mgkimsal 16y agoNo doubt, but by only paying wages that appeal to 20somethings who want to live with a roommate in a cramped apartment, you're missing out on a much larger talent pool. Supposedly the same talent pool with the experience and skills you claim you need.
- sleight42 16y agoIndeed. Which is why, for my part, I consult now instead of work directly for startups. Having been employed by 2 failed startups was enough for me.
- earl 16y agoThis. All these bloody people play armchair economists with macroecon, which is genuinely difficult, but refuse to do the same with micro: If you can't hire people at a given wage, raise the wage. Or whine online about the lack of employees.
- mgkimsal 16y agoBut if you whine loud enough, you can open more visas for cheap labor to come in next year. I'm totally not against people coming in to the country - legally. One of my first tech jobs was at a company that sponsored a number of Polish and Czech engineers. They were all effectively captive - they were paid a barely livable wage (relative to US-born people doing the same job) but couldn't easily go out and take another job due to immigration status. But that meant the company 'saved' so much, and could use it to help keep other wages in line - 'you're already paid $x more than person Y!' sort of thing.
- aristus 16y agoAh yes, the "visa discount". The legal part of our immigration regime is exploitative, humiliating, and such a great deal for employers that I don't see it changing any time soon.
- mgkimsal 16y ago"If you can't hire people at a given wage, raise the wage. Or whine online about the lack of employees." Or move your operations closer to the less expensive areas of the country (there's 48 other states besides CA and NY!). Some industries are lauded for moving entires factories overseas and making a killing on wage arbitrage. But somehow 'the money' likes to keep 'blessed' startup activity within 10 minutes drive from all VC offices, and this is seen as 'the way things have to be'.
- rbranson 16y agoFactories are nothing like software development: factories are repetitive assembly lines and software development is a creative process. When talent concentrates like it does in SF and NY, it creates a culture that becomes more valuable than the sum of it's parts. You've got people who are constantly meeting and exchanging ideas, often by coincidence or near accident. This doesn't happen when in areas without enough talent density to create a concentration. The same pattern is repeated in many forms of art and business.
- maxawaytoolong 16y agoMost startup jobs in NYC pay over $100K if you're an engineer. If you have a family and need a bigger place you can always live in New Jersey. "Money" is not really a problem in New York City. If you're smart and hustle in NYC, you can always make more money. You will probably have to do something heinous to get it, but it's sitting there, waiting for you. That said, many hackers just aren't into the sort of startup projects that get funded and pay well in NYC. That's a bigger factor in the "talent shortage." The startups there just aren't that cool. If someone in Brooklyn started a company making life-sized Gundam robots you could control with your web browser, everyone would quit working at whatever foodie-blog-ad-network they're currently stuck at and work at the robot place for half their previous salary. It's hard to do outsourced work in an early stage startup because stuff changes so frequently. The last startup I worked for in NYC actually did have a half dozen outsourced employees in places like Oregon and Hawaii and all but one of them quit because they were so frustrated about changing priorities and miscommunication.
- mgkimsal 16y agore: "Money" - a $100k job in NYC with living in NJ just isn't going to get you anywhere close the same living space (especially for a family) as that same money would in most of the rest of the US. Similarly, $150k+ would go a long way to help make up that difference. Ultimately, it's just not a lifestyle tradeoff most engineering talent seems to want to make at those price points. Upping base to $150k (with something closer to $200k for sr-level talent) for startup engineers (vs ~$100k) would attract more talent the companies are claiming they need. If that's too expensive, perhaps 'startups' should locate themselves closer to where the resources they need are actually located? Those issues of 'miscommunication' and 'changing priorities' are happening regardless of where the workers are, and I bet many people working at the main office were similarly frustrated. I've worked on site and remotely, and understand the challenges in each. Neither is perfect, and having a remote team (and being a remote developer) requires certain skills. I'm dismayed, but perhaps not surprised, that these skills aren't actively developed and nurtured at more companies. The long term rewards will be great.
- CPops 16y ago
- sleight42 16y agoExcellent question. The parochial mentality that workers must be colocated is clearly part of the problem. However, using remote workers is not the only solution. As a remote worker, I can tell you that I have to expend more effort communicating than I would if I was co-lo'd. Granted, I'm an extrovert so I don't mind terribly. For more on this, see: http://evan.tiggerpalace.com/articles/2010/12/10/rule-0-choose-the-right-people/ http://evan.tiggerpalace.com/articles/2010/12/10/rule-0-choo...
- cosmicray 16y agoInstead of importing an entire team to NYC, why don't they export a team leader to Omaha or Tupelo for the duration of the project, or at least until they feel the team is groking the gist of the project.
- natrius 16y agoSuch a scenario would imply that there's a higher number of capable programmers willing to receive a given wage within commuting distance of those places than there is in New York. I don't think that's the case.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoCost of living between Omaha and Jersey City, NJ is not nearly as bad. Just because you work in NYC doesn't mean you can't live 15 min away. (Queens and Brooklyn are similar priced, if you work on the east side.) http://www.bestplaces.net/col/?salary=50000&city1=53137000&city2=53436000 http://www.bestplaces.net/col/?salary=50000&city1=531370... Also, your data on Indeed is a significant undercount of the higher paid programming jobs. If you are looking for a good programmer, you will pay $150k and you won't bother posting it on Indeed or Monster.