5 ms·
It's because "every startup" is lazy and afraid to take risks. In the programming world, for example, everyone wants to hire someone who has 150 years of exper
by jrockway 16y ago
It's because "every startup" is lazy and afraid to take risks. In the programming world, for example, everyone wants to hire someone who has 150 years of experience with each of C, C++, Java, C#, Perl, Python, Ruby, OCaml, Haskell, and node.js. Problem is, that is not possible. So the position goes unfilled.
If programming shops were willing to hire people fresh out of college with English degrees and teach them programming, they would probably do really, really well. But nobody is willing to do that, so college grads go without jobs and startups go without employees.
(Also, startups expect you to really drink that Kool-Aid. They want you to work 12 hour days, skip weekends, not take vacation, and "be loyal" to the company. Why would anyone do that when they can work 9-5 for 4x as much money at an investment bank?
Ironically, even the investment banks can't hire anyone, but that is for other reasons.)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- mgkimsal 16y agoThat's another really good point. There's not much in the way of apprenticeship in software. Companies will often pay for relo expenses for someone, providing they stay for X years (else they repay the relo money back). Companies could do something similar with education, whether it's local college classes, inhouse training, etc. If you leave within the first year, you pay the company back those expenses. Or... have retention bonuses for people for staying past 1 year, and invest in education for people at lower wages. Many companies would find some real gems out there, waiting to be discovered, and would engender far more loyalty than most currently get.
- sleight42 16y agoThere are small startups that will hire entry-level people. However, I agree, the relationships with the entry level people are not necessarily of the mentor-apprentice variety.
- robak 16y agoIt is illegal under the US law for an employee to pay money to his Employer. As this could be a backdoor for slavery and actually is regulated by anti-slavery laws in the US. I know this from my attorney when I asked if I should be worried about $5k I was supposed to pay back to my company as I quit before 12 months project ended. I quit, nothing happened. It was over 5 years ago and this company still exists and does business in Northern Virginia area and I know that they still require their prospect employees to sign this. Signature on this has no legal value whatsoever.
- mashmac2 16y agoThe university I attend, Taylor, just began a track in their Computer Science major a few years ago designed for this exactly. It lets students work in a team atmosphere, and get a few major projects under their belt before they graduate, with critiques and advice from professors. I have a few friends who chose that track and are learning how programming really works, getting a little bit of class credit, and getting an on-campus work study job out of it as well.
- bugsy 16y agoI'm not sure I am following this. If you want to attract actual talent, you have to pay full relocation. The good ones have stable jobs they enjoy. And they are going to pay their own relocation for a new job that may not work out? I don't think so. The only people that pay their own relocation are the desperate and the completely untalented. As far as having to pay back if you are laid off or the company is otherwise dissatisfied due to their own lack of having a decent vetting process, ha ha ha. Indentured servitude. That's a new one. I'm sure that will get the best of the best. Not.
- nostrademons 16y agoRelo packages are a perk that's given out to those with a certain amount of experience. I got one last time I changed jobs, but I barely squeaked in (official policy was that it's only for candidates with 5+ years of experience, I had 4 years, they said "We'll work something out"). And I would've had to pay it back if I worked at the company for less than a year. The vast majority of my friends did not get relo packages, because this is their first job out of school. Companies don't typically offer relo for fresh college grads. I thought this discussion was about junior engineers?
- waterlesscloud 16y agoIf you can't find employees, you have to get out of the mindset of "perks" that employees are lucky to get and start offering what it takes to get what you want. Or keep whining there's no employees. One of these paths is more productive than the other.
- physcab 16y agoI agree with you and generally this is a great way for a startup to save money as well because new grads are cheap. The problem that you'll then have though, is that when you encounter a tough technical challenge, you won't have the benefit of having someone on your team who has seen it before. So there must be some golden ratio. A solid emphasis on college recruiting to serve immediate needs, with a focus on building out a technical knowledge base accompanied by many years of experience.
- tkaemming 16y ago"I agree with you and generally this is a great way for a startup to save money as well because new grads are cheap." I'd argue the opposite case — if it's true that a good programmer is at least 5-10x more productive than an average programmer[1], you'd actually save money by paying the experienced programmer significantly more when compared to hiring a team of beginning or average programmers. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Mythical_Man-Month#The_surgical_team http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Mythical_Man-Month#The_surg...
- physcab 16y agoTrue. But you're not accounting for the time it takes to hire a programmer that is 5-10x more productive.
- ZachPruckowski 16y agoThere's also costs that scale with headcount but not experience. For instance, you've got to get computers and chairs and desks for everyone whether they're a rookie or an expert. Ditto things like healthcare. Sure, the rookies may have cubicles and slightly worse plans, but those costs aren't going to be 1/5 or 1/10 as expensive. And while the good programmers probably need less oversight than average, support personnel costs (internal IT, HR, recruitment, whatever) still scale with headcount.
- earl 16y agoUm... I disagree. I worked for a large company that does just that: hire liberal arts majors with high gpas and teach them to program. It works, well, horribly. Ask any former employee about the code quality at epic systems.
- jrockway 16y agoI work for a large company that hires programmers with many years of experience at prestigious firms and it works, well, horribly. It turns out that not very many people are cut out for programming. So honestly, I don't think your approach is too bad.
- gcheong 16y ago"So honestly, I don't think your approach is too bad." You mean in the sense that both approaches work horribly?
- jrockway 16y agoYes. There is no "approach" that works, which means the problem is with expectations.
- diogenes_ 16y agoI have found an honest man!
- icefox 16y agoThe corp participates in some open source program (that they don't own). Then hire the best people that contribute to the project. I have seen this work several times over and it has always resulted in high quality developers.
- jrockway 16y agoYes. My employer employs something like 70,000 programmers. Your way gets you 10 programmers that do a really good job. Now find the other 69,990 programmers. (I like to think I get a lot of work done, but I can't get 7,000 people's work done.) (If it was my company, would I have a bunch of unrelated development departments with no common standards on 5 continents? No. But it's not my company, so I don't get to decide, I can only observe.)
- maxawaytoolong 16y agoIf programming shops were willing to hire people fresh out of college with English degrees and teach them programming Body shop consulting firms like Accenture have done this for decades.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- kujhytrtyu 16y agoThe clever bit is finding customers who will pay $5000/day for consultants who can just about do intro level MS-Access. Except for the government of course
- jamesaguilar 16y agoLaziness is an important positive quality in a business that already has too much to do. Teaching kids without the disposition or inclination to learn programming for themselves on the off chance a diamond in the rough might be found is not a good business proposition. There's a reason why no one does it. You are far better off just doing less.
- rhizome 16y agoThat would be an interesting kind of conservation-minded business: just small enough. Why have a 20 person company doing a variety of things mediocre than a 5 person company doing one or a few things very well? There are larger scale versions of this in the AAA game developer world as the studio model has taken hold.
- DevX101 16y agoRight now I'm a one man operation but hopefully I'll have the need to hire after launch. But for a startup I'd never consider taking on an English degree college major and teaching them to program. Marketing, sales, etc..sure, but not to program. If you never got the coding bug by the end of college, I'm sure not going to be spending my time to teach from the ground up. In a startup every person has to pull their weight and there really isn't time for a formal training. I'd venture to guess that in almost all cases, this new hire will decrease the value of your company as a programmer. That said, this approach could work at a large firm with stable revenues, a formal training program, and relatively straightforward IT requirements.
- jrockway 16y agoThere you go. I didn't say you should do this, I'm just saying it explains the two complaints in the article: * Nobody to hire * No jobs
- sleight42 16y agoI'll add my dissent. I've consulted with 4 different startups in the past few months. And they're not afraid to hire entry level. However, they seem to run into problems when they want to find senor people to mentor the entry level hires. Entry level developers are rarely able to lead a team much less handle the various technology decisions of the contemporary tech startup.
- rhizome 16y agoWell sure, but they shouldn't have to. That's why it's called "entry level." I've never heard of entry-level management or team leads!
- cvg 16y agoEmployees should meet companies halfway and learn a bit of programming on their own. Of course learning early on is better, but attempting a pass through something like http://learnpythonthehardway.org http://learnpythonthehardway.org should be mandatory for any unemployed person. Shows initiative. A company's apprenticeship program could take the company the rest of the way. A bonus: there are government programs that can help with the cost of this training.
- nostrademons 16y agoThe first startup I worked at did this. They hired kids straight out of (or in) high school, like me. They hired recent Indian immigrants who couldn't work anywhere else because of visa issues. They opened an office in Shanghai where they could get programmers for $20k/year. It worked, well, terribly. The startup folded in a year and a half mostly because of code-quality issues. I remember talking to the founders near the end of my gap year, where they said that of the 10-ish or so high schoolers they hired, only two of us really produced more than we cost (even on our piddly $20-30k/year salaries), and even then we needed a fair bit of management support. These were also not random people - one of the founders had been a teacher at my high school (he'd been an entrepreneur with a successful exit before then), and he basically skimmed the top of the class off and got them to work for him. Many of us later had successful careers at Google, Bain, or hedge funds. But there's only so much that you can do to compensate for inexperience. There's a lot that you learn in your first job or two, even if you already know how to program. And until you learn it, there's a good chance that you'll be negatively productive.
- samd 16y agoPerhaps the problem was a poor balance between experienced and novice developers. I wouldn't expect a company with hardly any experienced people to succeed.
- nostrademons 16y agoIt was, but that's ultimately the problem with hiring novices. We had a couple senior engineers. Most of their time was spent mentoring novices. Startups are cognitively demanding enough to take a highly-skilled engineers full attention. If the bulk of their time is spent managing, who's writing the code? You end up with a bunch of novices who gain a lot of experience, and a bunch of code that's crap. If you have to hire the senior engineers anyway, why not hire only the senior engineers, at least in the early stages of the company? They'll be able to get actual work done, you'll have a decent codebase, and you might actually be able to ship a product that can get you additional funding and revenue. Then, once you've taken care of the money problem and the startup is no longer fighting for its life, you can hire some junior devs to flesh out the product and exploit market opportunities that you didn't have the resources to explore in the startup phase.
- scottshapiro 16y agoGreat points about the expectations of startups. However, I've never met anyone below the MD at an investment bank who's working anywhere close to 9a-5p (unless you meant 9a to 5a which is more often the case with analysts).
- iskander 16y ago>If programming shops were willing to hire people fresh out of college with English degrees and teach them programming, they would probably do really, really well. But nobody is willing to do that, so college grads go without jobs and startups go without employees. Do you have experience hiring someone with no technical experience and turning them into a productive employee? How did you train them? How long did it take?
- j_baker 16y agoI don't know about going that far, but I think your basic point is right on. Too many startups expect to have their ideal candidate delivered to their doorstep on a silver platter. Of course, when they can't find that candidate, they blame the education system. Yet I hear very little talk about what startups could be doing to create a better-skilled workforce. It sounds an awful lot to me like they want a skilled workforce as long as someone else pays for it. Startups have two options: they can choose to be lazy and risk-averse or they can complain about not being able to find workers. They can't do both.
- yesimahuman 16y agoI was with you there for a second until you threw out the idea of teaching non programmers to program on the job. What startups should be more open to is CS types that don't have years of experience in certain languages but have the ability to learn quickly. Too much focus on minor technologies that could be picked up in a few days.
- petercooper 16y agoIf programming shops were willing to hire people fresh out of college with English degrees and teach them programming, they would probably do really, really well. English degrees? The number of English grads I've bumped into in the software industry has been small (in comparison to just how many English grads there are). Math grads would be better since most would have had to do some programming already (even if just in Mathematica). Even physics grads..
- fertel 16y ago9-5 at an investment bank - Sure it's 4x the money (or was)- but it's 100+ hours of weekly work that in my personal opinion is nowhere near as exciting as creating new technologies.
- jackfoxy 16y agoI just want to hire someone who can demonstrate a level a little beyond competence in database programming, server programming, client-side (js, jquery, css) programming, and understands how the internet works. Most of those people already are gainfully employed. Oh yeah, and they have to be willing to come into our office to work and demonstrate to me they are willing to commit to learning our non-trivial application. I have a degree in Comparative Literature (which is not an English degree, btw). I would consider someone with a serious music degree, maybe philosophy (e.g. PG). Most liberal arts majors are not cut out to be engineers.
- jrockway 16y agoI guess what I really wanted to say here, BTW, was that I'd rather work with a smart person that doesn't know the particulars for $foo language than I would with a dumb person that has 20 years of experience with $bar framework.