5 ms·
Exactly. Ghandi was very brave, it's true, but his success in India says as much about the British as it does about the power of nonviolence. Try the same stunt
by taneq 7y ago
Exactly. Ghandi was very brave, it's true, but his success in India says as much about the British as it does about the power of nonviolence. Try the same stunt against ISIS or North Korea and you'll only achieve being shot out of hand.
- crispinb 7y agoI have a feeling you haven't read much British colonial history. Amritsar? Boer concentration camps? Indian emancipation had nothing to do with British goodness. It had much to do with mass uprisings, clever tactics, and more than a few blown-up railway lines.
- Veen 7y agoThe grandfather comment said and implied nothing about British goodness. It was a pragmatic decision.
- crispinb 7y agoI read taneq's (admittedly sketchy) comment as suggesting that the Gandhian part of the Indian independence struggle was effective not because of its nonviolent tactics, but because of the relatively benign nature of British colonial governance.
- thrower123 7y agoMassive exhaustion, inability, and unwillingness to maintain their colonial empire after losing the best part of two generations to European wars had the most to do with it. Unfortunately, we are still dealing with the fallout of Britain's abdication of responsibility.
- taneq 7y agoI'm not saying they were great, and definitely on an organisational level they did some evil things. But on an individual level, shooting an unarmed person in the face in cold blood generally just wasn't done in the same way as it would have been in some other regimes.
- Super_Jambo 7y agoTo think Indian independence came about with no threat of violence seems like a whitewashing of history. The British state chose to deal with the non-violent. But would they have bothered without the fear of violence?
- tim333 7y agoThe Brits gave up most of their colonies so probably. Though it was after being knocked back by a lot of real violence in WW2.
- quetzthecoatl 7y agowhere do people get the idea that british were nice in India? They killed millions in WW2 famines alone (to fund the war campaign). The reprisals after 1857 mutiny is said to have killed 10 million Indians. Right there from two incidents you have 15 million deaths. British were much more save than the Nazis when it comes to genocide of "others", colonization, savagery etc. They get a free pass in the west as opposed to the Nazis simply because British killed Asians, Africans and Native Americans when Nazis killed fellow whites. This is pure racism.
- _khau 7y agoAs a Brit, I can confirm that there is a large section of our population that thinks the empire was a positive thing and pines for a return to it. Even the 'white man's burden' is viewed by many as a necessary endeavour. It's the number one criticism I have of my own country (and I have many). It's nationalist propaganda that panders to exceptionalism and it seems to have worked on half of the electorate unfortunately.
- brigandish 7y agoI would say a large section of our population want to go back to a certain style of governance that they believe (true or not) was around during the empire, that of strong economic liberalism and free trade with the rest of the world. I'd say it's one of the big philosophical differences with the EU (its protectionism is its main defining characteristic, after all) that has led to the Brexit vote. The number of people who want the empire back though, I reckon you could count those on one hand.
- Doubl 7y agoEurope has not given itself a free pass when it comes to colonialism. For example, at the moment they're hiding a bell in Cambridge University lest it turns out to have formerly been used on a slave plantation. There was no government organised genocide in British colonial history that I know of, not even in Ireland in the 17th century where arguably the worst atrocities were carried out. Saying Britain killed millions in India in WW2 is complete hyperbole.
- watwut 7y agoThere was more then Ghandi and non violence affecting politics back then. He was not the only player over there and there were violent people seeking in dependence too.
- taneq 7y agoYeah, I wasn't saying that Ghandi did it alone or that the British were squeaky clean. In other situations against other adversaries, though, his approach would have just got him instantly shot. The fact that this never happened shows the general character of the British that he faced.
- tim333 7y agoGhandi was quite shrewd as to what he could get away with. He started protesting in South Africa in 1893 when they were probably not terribly nice to non whites. Gene Sharp who pioneered studying non violent resistance wrote a book about it - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gandhi_as_a_Political_Strategist https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gandhi_as_a_Political_Strategi...