5 ms·
This is a dying art. The modern way to achieve any kind of complex mechanical motion is to attach a servo to the thing and use a computer to set a motion profi
by londons_explore 8y ago
This is a dying art.
The modern way to achieve any kind of complex mechanical motion is to attach a servo to the thing and use a computer to set a motion profile.
A bit of a shame really.
- soulofmischief 8y agoI think it will always have its place. For example, I predict the increasingly suffocating digital zeitgeist will give rise to a form of competition which would be the mechanist's version of a demo scene. People will compete to "hack" non-digital mechanics as far as they can go, from analog sensors to mobile, programmable, multi-function automatons such as Theo Jansen's Strandbeests [0]. Resources like this, even if their maintainers have long gone, will become coveted gold mines. https://www.strandbeest.com/ https://www.strandbeest.com/
- sasaf5 8y agoWe can see a bit of this celebration of old tech in horology.
- cr0sh 8y agoI kinda hope this branches out into complex automata; I tend to wonder, though, if such mechanisms from the 17th thru 19th century could ever be improved upon in purely mechanical terms, but to me it's a fascinating thought.
- soulofmischief 8y agoDo you think Leonardo Da Vinci have been a programmer and digital artist instead of a mechanist/inventor if born today? And would his contributions have the same impact?
- cr0sh 8y ago> Do you think Leonardo Da Vinci have been a programmer and digital artist instead of a mechanist/inventor if born today? Possibly. He was a "robotics engineer" of sorts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonardo%27s_robot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonardo%27s_robot https://www.leonardorobotsociety.org/the-robots.html https://www.leonardorobotsociety.org/the-robots.html https://www.amazon.com/Leonardos-Lost-Robots-Mark-Rosheim/dp/3540284400 https://www.amazon.com/Leonardos-Lost-Robots-Mark-Rosheim/dp... He quite possibly invented a mechanical calculator: https://www.educalc.net/197481.page https://www.educalc.net/197481.page So I could see him continue explorations of that nature. > And would his contributions have the same impact? Aside from his art, and possibly the various engineering commissions or consultations he was involved in - what was in his notebooks didn't see the light of day until long, long after his death. They were essentially "lost" until rediscovered much later. While he was alive, they were probably only seen by himself, and/or maybe a few students (speculating). On the art side alone, though - would his works have the same impact? That's difficult to say. If they were collected, preserved, and viewed by their owners properly. I don't know this for certain, but my guess is that most of the artwork of people like LDV of that era, their art were all private commissions, for the most part, outside of a very few pieces that were "publically viewable" - for various terms of "public". Those private commissions would have only been viewed by their owners, family, and maybe a few friends or acquaintances. Outside of those, the works would not have been public, until far later, as they were sold or otherwise "moved around" in the marketplace. Their value would increase or decrease almost at a whim, but also depending on how known the artist was, and other works by the artist. What we see today of these artists is probably mostly survivor bias. There's a good chance that there were others out there of a similar note who just didn't make it because of various reasons (along with a whole host of others who weren't as good, and their art - mediocre or whatnot as it may have been - became "trash" and didn't get passed down to us, but was thrown away over time). So - if such digital works were created - in 500 years or so, if the work was preserved (migrated from media to media, from machine to "machine", platform to platform) - it's quite possible they would have the same impact - after enough time passed (and everything else being the same). Pure speculation, of course...
- soulofmischief 8y ago
- balfirevic 8y agoWhat time frame do you give to your prediction?
- soulofmischief 8y agoPerhaps in a decade or two if I see no one else has gotten around to organizing that kind of thing.
- spitfire 8y agoAlready sort of happened in the mechanical watch space. When the quartz crisis hit in the 1970's all the traditional Swiss watchmakers had to move upmarket with fancier complications. I expect the same thing to happen to ICE automobiles. To become luxury/jewellery pieces.
- cr0sh 8y ago> Already sort of happened in the mechanical watch space. So-called "Tourbillon" escapements, for instance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tourbillon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tourbillon Fantastic (and expensive) works of mechanical movement art, but it goes well beyond this. Some "watches" (the fanciest ones aren't really wearable, but could be considered "portable") contain an amazing number of various mechanical functions and movements (called "complications"), of utter insane complexity: http://reference57260.vacheron-constantin.com/en2/the-worlds-most-complicated-watch http://reference57260.vacheron-constantin.com/en2/the-worlds... Similar such works are done in the clock space as well. I wish I had the wealth to be able to afford such a piece (then again, if I did, I'd probably have a 3rd iteration of the Difference Engine commissioned first - sigh).
- vanderZwan 8y ago> For example, I predict the increasingly suffocating digital zeitgeist will give rise to a form of competition which would be the mechanist's version of a demo scene. I think it's not just that. The internet allows niche hobbies to thrive where previously they would die out, because it makes it easier for people to find peers who are into the same thing. Hence it's easier to maintain the minimum required "population" for a subculture to "survive". The people involved are just dispersed across the planet.
- syn0byte 8y agoIt's not a dying art, it's "abstracted away". The servos are still internally utilizing these designs. You just don't have to worry about the gritty physical details, just some basic control code.
- hugs 8y agoYup, it's in the same way that working with transistors is a dying art. The use of transistors is not dying at all. Millions and billions of transistors were involved in the creation, transfer, and delivery of these words to your screen or speaker.