4 ms·
And yet if he'd kept it on his own machine there's myriad other vectors from compromised wallets to typos that would separate even the veteran "investor" from t
by arcticbull 8y ago
And yet if he'd kept it on his own machine there's myriad other vectors from compromised wallets to typos that would separate even the veteran "investor" from their crypto. And we'd be blaming him again, just as you are now, because in the land of Crypto anything bad that happens is your fault, not the insanely problematic technology. This is the fundamental problem with crypto, it's irreversible and decentralized. These aren't features, they're bugs.
If this were real money or real assets, he'd be able to call his bank and be made whole by the close of business, I wager. Instead he's out a down-payment, SFYL.
I can't believe these shenanigans are allowed to play out as though we're all okay with this being the future of currency.
- gruez 8y ago>because in the land of Crypto anything bad that happens is your fault, not the insanely problematic technology Cars are designed to travel at lethal speeds. If you were reckless and killed someone or yourself, do you also declare it to be an "insanely problematic technology"? The problem here is that people are not aware of the risks associated with cryptocurrencies and so are not taking the required precautions. After all, you can be pretty reckless with your credit card numbers or bank login and still be fine, because the finance system has an undo button for everything. >This is the fundamental problem with crypto, it's irreversible and decentralized. These aren't features, they're bugs. I wouldn't call them "bugs", just design decisions or trade offs. Bug implies it's somehow fixable, but if it's not. What if you want to make an irreversible payment, or want to be able to send money to whomever you want without the government stepping in the way, all while being trustless? Is there a way to achieve that, and still being able to hit undo when you make a mistake?
- arcticbull 8y ago> Cars are designed to travel at lethal speeds. If you were reckless and killed someone or yourself, do you also declare it to be an "insanely problematic technology"? More aptly though, I would declare it problematic if I couldn't drive 10 feet without someone carjacking me in my ostensibly armored car, or if pressing the button on my radio caused the car to explode. I'd call that 'problematic' because if it were my fault, I'd be in jail, and if not, the automaker would be on the wrong end of a huge lawsuit. You know who we have to thank for their current level of safety? The DOT, NHTSA and legal system. > The problem here is that people are not aware of the risks associated with cryptocurrencies and so are not taking the required precautions. He had his coins on probably the only legitimate exchange in all of crypto. He had 2fac. He had 2fac on his gmail. If this isn't sufficient to keep your money protected, we need to stop blaming the victim. He's probably one of the most competent technical individuals owning crypto. If he can't keep it safe how on earth would your grandmother? > After all, you can be pretty reckless with your credit card numbers or bank login and still be fine, because the finance system has an undo button for everything. Isn't that awesome? We've recognized people make mistakes and created for them a path to remedy said mistakes. Pretending they don't happen and that it's the victims fault if they do isn't a replacement. > What if you want to make an irreversible payment. Wire transfer. You can opt in to irreversibility, it's not the default, and that's completely reasonable IMO. > ...or want to be able to send money to whomever you want without the government stepping in the way. AKA breaking the law. Yes, you shouldn't be able to send money to people on the OFAC list, to terrorists, or to sanctioned countries. That's fine with me, and all your fellow citizens. That's why we have those laws. Let's not mince words, "sending money to people the government doesn't want" is financing international terrorism, narcotics trafficking, human trafficking and so on. No, you shouldn't be able to do that. > ...all while being trustless? Again, why do you need this without the illegal use cases? Either way PoW cryptos aren't trustless, Beijing has over 80% of the hash power one strongly worded memo away. Decentralized and trustless are not a feature of Bitcoin or most other cryptocurrencies. They are centralized in the PRC. You would give up sovereign control of your money system to the PRC? > Is there a way to achieve that, and still being able to hit undo when you make a mistake? No, you shouldn't be able to break the law. An open challenge to all crypto advocates: Provide me one legal use case better suited to cryptocurrency than the US dollar.
- VMG 8y ago> No, you shouldn't be able to break the la Check your privilege, as some might say
- deadbunny 8y ago> Provide me one legal use case better suited to cryptocurrency than the US dollar. Sending money to people overseas without extortionate fees. Surprisingly not everyone overseas is linked with international terrorism as you imply.
- aphextim 8y agoStellar and IBM's WorldWire are hoping to tackle the remittances issue! Check it out if you haven't.
- arcticbull 8y agoNeither of those solutions need or benefit from BlockChain.
- aphextim 8y agoYour comment couldn't be more asinine. Did you even bother to google search them? Here I'll help. https://www.stellar.org/ https://www.stellar.org/ https://www.ibm.com/blockchain/solutions/world-wire https://www.ibm.com/blockchain/solutions/world-wire
- dang 8y agoPersonal attacks will get you banned here. Would you please read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and follow the rules?
- aphextim 7y agoI apologize. I did not read the rules. I have now and will refrain from any personal attacks going forward.
- hndamien 8y agoReplace by Fee, but its a pretty small window of opportunity.
- saagarjha 8y ago> Cars are designed to travel at lethal speeds. If you were reckless and killed someone or yourself, do you also declare it to be an "insanely problematic technology"? Possibly: see the numerous self-driving efforts underway.