3 ms·
The biggest problem in psychiatry is that the only reliable way they have to diagnose illnesses, with any precision, is to prescribe things and see which one he
by ncmncm 8y ago
The biggest problem in psychiatry is that the only reliable way they have to diagnose illnesses, with any precision, is to prescribe things and see which one helps most, if at all.
This problem makes it near impossible to apply generic "gold standard" double-blind trials to psychoactive medications, because those depend implicitly on accurate diagnoses. If your target sample group has six different maladies all labeled "depression", you will never get a clear signal, even if the medication you are testing 100% cures the one-in-six of them that actually have the problem it fixes.
- phren0logy 8y agoI disagree with some of your premise, but agree in general. I sort of think of this as a "science vs engineering" problem. Science can be patient for the correct answer, but engineering needs a good-enough model of the problem to make something work today. Enter the DSM, which is on the engineering side of the aisle. It provides common terminology but is almost certainly lumping too many things together. So if your treatment doesn't help many different problems that look sort of similar all at the same time, it shows no effect at all. Which doesn't mean it won't do a great job with one of two of those narrower subtypes. This guy does some great work on the topic: https://eiko-fried.com/the-replication-crisis-hits-psychiatry-no-candidate-genes-for-depression/ https://eiko-fried.com/the-replication-crisis-hits-psychiatr...
- outlace 8y agoAs a new psych resident, I'd agree with this. The diagnostic system is not biologically based. It does at least offer a common language for mental health provides to speak, so that if one person calls something schizophrenia then other mental health providers will be on the same page about what that means. Personally, I'm very excited about direct neuromodulation technologies such as transcranial magnetic stimulation. These tools not only allow us to manipulate neural circuits, but to also test experimentally whether certain circuits causally contribute to a psychiatric phenotype of interest. As a treatment modality, they're incredibly safe and virtually have no side effects. Given that chemical receptors on neurons are so widely distributed, I doubt that a chemical substance can ever alter neural circuitry precisely enough to cure certain kinds of circuit dysfunctions. There's also starting to be exciting studies using brain imaging (e.g. fMRI) to tease apart the heterogeneity within conventional diagnostic categories and devise the inklings of biologically-based dimensional criteria.
- sjg007 8y agoECT has been characterized as rebooting the brain, my guess is that direct neuro-modulation will be seen as rebooting parts of the brain.
- outlace 8y agoI think rebooting is a fair metaphor for ECT since it induces a generalized seizure. But neuromodulation acts to mildly strengthen or weaken existing synapses within a brain region or circuit. The patient is awake and usually watching TV or something during the procedure. So I wouldn’t call that akin rebooting.
- billfruit 8y agoI think that is no bar for development of methods. Are methods in surgery developed after double blind trials? Does even the scientific method apply to surgery?