3 ms·
I find it interesting how every Tesla car autopilot crash is widely reported yet all other car manufacturers' self-driving propositions are not better[0] compar
by pdimitar 7y ago
I find it interesting how every Tesla car autopilot crash is widely reported yet all other car manufacturers' self-driving propositions are not better[0] compared to Tesla's and almost nobody is talking about that -- at least not in the news outlets I've been following.
Media seems to really want to see Musk fail. That doesn't look like objective journalism to me.
(Additionally, did somebody actually investigate Waymo's and Uber's self-driving car departments inner workings and if they report the accident counts truthfully?)
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-driving_car#Incidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-driving_car#Incidents
- ilikehurdles 7y agoIf other manufacturers released a public beta, opt-in version of an incomplete self-driving solution, I’d consider them dangerously irresponsible with human life. Tesla makes it part of their sales and marketing.
- ymolodtsov 7y agoBecause no other car manufacturers sells consumer a car with something they claim to be “autopilot” creating a clear association with complete self-driving you can trust.
- notfromhere 7y agoBecause other car companies aren't pretending they have a L5 system ready for commercial deployment
- woodpanel 7y agoIn my experience the Uber incident was also intensively covered, even more than each fatal AI incident that happened with a Tesla. While not living in the US, I'm reading up on such issues as does anybody else at HN, but the Uber crash was the only such incident that made my country's evening news (as far as I can remember) [1]. Apart from that: Of all companies involved in the R&D of autonomous driving Tesla is probably the "loudest" (i.e. they make the strongest claims to the greatest audience), so being criticized the loudest is just about right IMHO. [1] Granted, maybe that was just due to the video footage the killer-car taped. EDIT: [1] And probably also due to the fact that not the car's passenger/driver was killed, but a pedestrian.
- pdimitar 7y agoYep, I admitted my filter bubble might have skewed my opinion on which events are covered how much. But HN itself demonstrates a lot of negative bias towards Tesla and Musk in particular. I get it that the marketing can be deceptive but I still fail to see what Tesla does so much worse than anybody else; many people are furious with dubious marketing claims of many other companies yet Tesla always seems to get the most flak here in HN and, to an extent, on Reddit.
- umurkontaci 7y agoFrom the same article: Uber's system killed a person. They received a huge backlash and their permission to test self-driving cars have been revoked in the state of Arizona. They also pulled out from testing California as well. Waymo had 13 non fatal crashes, of which, 12 of them were other drivers' fault. One was caused by the software where the car wanted to maneuver around some sand bags on the road and side swiped a bus. No injuries. Google took the blame and said it's a learning experience. AFAIK, Waymo cars are not available to public by default. Tesla had multiple fatal accidents as a result of "Auto Pilot" which is just a bunch of driver assistance systems taped together and marketed as a complete self-driving system. At every single accident, Tesla never admitted the blame, and just reiterated it's statistically safer to drive with AutoPilot than without. Obviously, this pisses people off. The never-take-the-blame attitude gets old and annoying. It's like a colleague who would throw everyone under the bus to avoid taking the blame. Secondly, I've seen the video of the accident with the Apple employee. It's clearly AP error and I don't care if it's statistically safer to drive with AP, if a system causes and accident that I could have avoided easily, I don't trust that system.
- pdimitar 7y agoI don't disagree. But in the end, looking at statistics, it's still safer to drive with AP indeed. Self-driving cares are done for the first time (I mean, almost fully autonomous ones). Accidents will happen still. We are very far away from a good generic AI that can adapt to different tasks so it's gonna be a bumpy road, pun intended.
- cjhopman 7y ago> But in the end, looking at statistics, it's still safer to drive with AP indeed. There's no publicly shared statistics that show that. You may have been confused by Tesla's PR.
- umurkontaci 7y agoThat's not the right conclusion I don't think. That published statistic is referring aggregates and averages. As we know there are safer and riskier drivers on the roads. If everybody was driving with AP the total number of accidents would drop. However if you are already a safe driver, there's a chance that AP is riskier. I don't want to bash AP to the ground, I think the tech is still phenomenal, and forced the car industry to catch up. However Tesla has the attitude of the classic move fast and break things mentality and not willing to take responsibility for it. When lives are at stake, you gotta do better than that. You don't get to blame the customers for getting distracted for using a system that's literally called and marketed as Autopilot. There's a reason similarly capable other cars in the market their systems as driver assistance and will force you to give input on tighter intervals.
- mannykannot 7y agoI don't know, but maybe the bias you see has something to do with the fact that, for the most part, other manufacturers' cars are not getting into fatal crashes while under autonomous control? When an Uber car did, it was reported as thoroughly as anything that has happened to Tesla. > (Additionally, did somebody actually investigate Waymo's and Uber's self-driving car departments inner workings and if they report the accident counts truthfully?) Do you have any basis for believing this is the case, or are you asking to insinuate something there is no actual evidence for?