3 ms·
> There is zero evidence sustained, controlled, above break-even fusion works at the types of energy densities people talk about for power plants. This is just
by pdonis 8y ago
> There is zero evidence sustained, controlled, above break-even fusion works at the types of energy densities people talk about for power plants.
This is just another way of saying we haven't gotten it to work yet. That's true, we haven't. The same could have been said about controlled fission in 1941.
> there are by now reasonable arguments to be made that it's a big waste of time and money better spent on something boring that we know will work, like thorium.
I agree there are reasonable arguments to be made about this. But comparing controlled fusion to ghosts and leprechauns is not one of them.
> it will be a hell of a lot easier to build a fusion howitzer
I have no idea where you're getting this from. Again, I really don't think you've grasped the implications of the fact that the energy content of the fuel inside a reactor producing, say, a gigawatt of power, is the same whether the reactor is fueled by coal, oil, natural gas, or fusion. So a "fusion howitzer" based on a fusion reactor would have no more explosive power than a chemical explosive howitzer (which is not based on a coal, oil, or natural gas plant anyway, it's a very different thing).
Nuclear fission is a unique case here because of the historical accident of fission power developing in such a way that multiple years' worth of fuel, containing orders of magnitude more stored energy than was being burned at any given time, was all inside the reactor core at once, instead of the reactor having fuel continually injected just in time to be burned, like every other kind of reactor. All of the downsides of fission--the possibility of meltdown, decay heat removal, huge spent fuel pools containing lots of long-lived radioisotopes, even an accident like Chernobyl--are due to this unique attribute. Newer designs like pebble bed reactors have shown that this is not a necessary attribute of fission power. But it won't be an attribute of fusion power at all.
- scottlocklin 8y agoPeople claim to have seen ghosts and leprechauns. Nobody's claiming to have seen break even. Only "if you give me enough money you'll see it." Which one could say about ghosts and leprechauns also. The difference between the energy content of a coal reactor and a hypothetical fusion reactor: you can store a lot more gigawatts in the back of a pickup truck for one of them, and that is the one that makes enough neutrons to sterilize a city block when you burn them up. I mean, how many pounds of fusion fuel does it take to level a city?
- pdonis 8y ago> Nobody's claiming to have seen break even. Huh? That milestone was reached some years ago. https://www.livescience.com/43318-fusion-energy-reaches-milestone.html https://www.livescience.com/43318-fusion-energy-reaches-mile... What has not yet been achieved is ignition--a self-sustaining reaction that does not require continuous energy input. > how many pounds of fusion fuel does it take to level a city? We already know how to make a fusion reaction that will level a city. Having a working controlled fusion reactor would not affect our capability to level cities. So I really don't understand why you keep harping on this.
- scottlocklin 7y agoBecause you can put the energy required to level a city in the back of a pickup truck, then level a city with it using the same technology has a hypothetical fusion reactor possible, that's why. I don't know why you can't see the destructive potential of a project Daedelus with the business end aimed at Los Angeles. The NIF result created 35000 neutrons, and you should know that press release is the functional definition of a scientific fraud -I wrote a couple of articles on it which you can go find if you care about fraud.
- pdonis 7y ago> Because you can put the energy required to level a city in the back of a pickup truck Yes, we can already do this, it's called a fusion bomb. > then level a city with it using the same technology has a hypothetical fusion reactor possible No, a bomb is not the same as a fusion reactor. A bomb burns a megaton of TNT's worth of fusion fuel all at once. A fusion reactor outputting a gigawatt of power burns the same amount of fuel in about a year. It's not at all the same thing.
- pdonis 7y ago> that press release is the functional definition of a scientific fraud -I wrote a couple of articles on it Google isn't showing me anything useful. Do you have links?
- 7y ago