6 ms·
>> "Twice in the last 20 years - more than any other time in US history combined - The Presidential election went to the candidate that LOST the popular vote"
by Kye 7y ago
>> "Twice in the last 20 years - more than any other time in US history combined - The Presidential election went to the candidate that LOST the popular vote"
There aren't a lot of data points--less than 100--for this, so it might not be statistically significant. Both those presidents are awful, but that could be an anomaly once seen in the context of a more significant sample.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoTrump hasn't gotten us into any trillion dollar boondoggles in the middle east (knock on wood) so I think the history books in 100yr are going to consider W "bad" and Trump "mediocre". I'd still rather have W in the white house though. Uncouth comments and geopolitical stupidity get forgotten in the long term. Iraq, the GWOT and the accompanying erosion of our freedoms will be what's in the history books. Obama will be known for the ACA (even if it is subsequently repealed it will be known as the first attempt at a nation wide healthcare solution). Trump will be a footnote. It'll be interesting to see what the next administration brings. Edit: Is this at -2 because I'm wrong or because people lose the capacity for critical thought when the orange man is involved?
- Kye 7y agoTime will tell, but you might be right. Almost everything I dislike (or fear) about Trump is stuff W was on board with, but it was the status quo then. W wasn't great for LGBTQ+ rights (for example) either, but his views and polices didn't stand out as much. Trump's SCOTUS picks will probably look worse in the 100 year view.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jnbiche 7y ago> Is this at -2 because I'm wrong or because people lose the capacity for critical thought when the orange man is involved? I didn't downvote, but I suspect it's at -2 because Trump is chiseling away at our rule of law and societal norms for a president. That's a big net loss for our democratic system of government, which for many of us is what matters most, far more than any D or R after a name.
- Fomite 7y agoThat will entirely depend on the knock-on effects of Trump. Wars are flashy, undermining the norms that keep the government running less so.
- RubberbandSoul 7y agoIt could also be that candidates are getting better and better at playing the system. Why aim for the popular vote when it's the electoral vote that counts? If the popular vote would count the candidates would change their campaign strategies.
- jakeogh 7y agoYa, visit 5 states because the rest wouldn't matter. Right back to the real Tea Party.
- pimmen 7y agoOne could reply with "Yeah, visit less than half the population because the rest wouldn't matter. Right back to the real Tea Party."
- jakeogh 7y agoFortunately the United States is not run on a tyranny of the majority. The Electoral College insures minority representation of the states. Unless I have misunderstood you, by that logic a majority of the US could move to TX and rule the rest.
- pimmen 7y agoAs your last paragraph shows, the Electoral College does not ensure minority representation of the states (or ”tyranny of the majority of states”) because if enough people moved to Texas it would decide everything. As is right now, about 22% of the population controls half the EC votes. And the senate already ensure representation of all states, so pwople in smaller states have many times more power than fellow citizens in larger states in all parts of the government except the House.
- jakeogh 7y agoI'm referring to the executive branch. Less populated state representation in one branch does not negate the need for it in the others. The founders (wisely imo) left national proportional representation to a single entity, the purse-string holders in the House. Removing the electoral college removes the incentive for a presidential candidate to campaign to most of the states.