3 ms·
>“We may also need to punish overconfident behavior more than we do,” she said. Who is "we?" Maybe overconfident behavior is adaptive in a world where risk-tak
by whatshisface 8y ago
>“We may also need to punish overconfident behavior more than we do,” she said.
Who is "we?" Maybe overconfident behavior is adaptive in a world where risk-taking works out enough of the time. Not all overconfidence takes the form of "I rationally know I can't do it but I'll try anyway," it is often closer to, "I rationally don't know whether or not I can do it, but I'll assume that I can and press on."
- dkarl 8y agoWhen faced with a task, there's a difference between believing that you can eventually learn and work it out given time and effort, and believing that you're already capable of doing it. What's frustrating is when the only people who are given the opportunity to fail over and over again and eventually get it right are the ones who never recognize that they can, do, and have failed.
- bigred100 8y agoI think it’s very often not adaptive. Eg some parents are very confident in their ability to conduct medical research in their spare time, and the result is measles outbreaks.
- whatshisface 8y agoThose parent's aren't "conducting medical research," they are believing what they are hearing from sources they trust more than medical researchers (their own friends and families). In fact, it would take more self-confidence in their ability to do research in order for them to learn the information necessary to step back from their community evaluate the risks on their own.
- naasking 8y ago> Not all overconfidence takes the form of "I rationally know I can't do it but I'll try anyway," it is often closer to, "I rationally don't know whether or not I can do it, but I'll assume that I can and press on." "The reasonable man adapts himself to the world: the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man." ~ George Bernard Shaw ~
- taneq 8y agoSurvivor bias combined with a very large initial sample size leads to it looking like risk-taking works out most of the time regardless of the actual odds. This makes it very hard to figure out whether that risk-taking is really adaptive or not.