3 ms·
I prefer the 'shadow' authority of presidential suasion. In a crisis, the President makes reasonable requests, and infrastructure operators will cooperate with
by gojomo 16y ago
I prefer the 'shadow' authority of presidential suasion. In a crisis, the President makes reasonable requests, and infrastructure operators will cooperate with authorities and collaborate with each other, out of common interest and reasonableness.
But, as the crisis passes, operators then have the freedom to adjust their cooperation, without a permanent obligation that could be abused. That's flexible and includes natural checks on abuse in the diversity of citizens' opinions and decentralization of decisionmaking.
No explicit language can achieve the same broad flexibility; when it tries through vagueness, it opens the door to both abuse and paranoia. And it encourages clumsy ass-covering overbroad orders from overreaching politicians, given in a dictatorial spirit, rather than considered requests offered in a spirit of community coordination.
In practice it may also be better for the government to exceed its proper bounds temporarily in emergencies, then be snapped back by calmer minds shortly thereafter, than to enshrine in law the maximal authority that might ever be needed. Lincoln, Wilson, FDR, and Bush-43 all overstepped their legal or constitutional authority in wartime, and then pulled back (or were pushed back) by the courts and public opinion later. Preauthorizing what they actually did would have made it harder in each situation to return to normalcy afterward.