5 ms·
That strikes me as useful as the "security expert" who shows up on TV and tells people to "only download apps you trust". Who really knows anything about ANY o
by duxup 8y ago
That strikes me as useful as the "security expert" who shows up on TV and tells people to "only download apps you trust".
Who really knows anything about ANY of the apps they download? Nobody has the required knowledge / time to make that determination with any amount of success.
Anyway the FDA situation reminds me of a libertarian blogger who a while back wrote a great blog that went something like "Guys, libertarians aren't supposed to hate the FDA / EPA!"
His point being that libertarians are supposed to get riled up when government gets involved in protecting people from decisions that they should make on their own, such as preventing people from jumping off anything because jumping off a cliff is bad (overly simple example but that's the idea). Situations like telling good medicine from bad where you need huge amounts of testing and industry knowledge, or having someone dump toxic waste next to your house that you can't tell ... you're permanently hurt by the time you figure it out is something libertarians should want a government involved in.
Life is complex, we can't figure everything out ourselves.
- throwayEngineer 8y agoConsider that the alternative, is expensive drugs that only the ultra wealthy can afford. What is better? A situation where the poor sometimes get ineffective drugs, or a situation where the poor get no drugs? If you picked G.) Other. You don't understand how the world works. It's the "cheap, fast, good", you picked 3 instead of 2. Edit, would love to hear solutions.
- orhmeh09 8y agoI’m sorry , why are you presenting these as if they are the only options? And did you just defer to a common saying to make an assertion about how the world works instead of making a genuine argument?
- throwayEngineer 8y agoThat is the genuine argument. Not Everything is cheap. Did you want a third option where old people get medicine, but young people pay higher taxes? Pick your solution, someone loses.
- evandev 8y agoPick two, cheap and good. If the FDA is correctly doing their job, it should take some time to process if the generic drugs are effective. And for non-generic drugs, the R&D involved specifies that it doesn't come fast.
- duxup 8y agoAt least in the US it appears the costs of drugs is not tied to any real market forces / competition type forces, and I don't think when drug prices were lower the FDA was doing less testing.
- linuxftw 8y agoThere's a free-market answer to the FDA problem, I don't think any real libertarian would argue otherwise (note: I'm not a libertarian). The solution is having a brand, and building that brand based on trust. Additionally, 3rd parties you subscribe to could verify the claims of brands and their integrity. This is similar to things like Fair Trade [1] certifications, or Kosher certifications. I often buy brand-name drugs OTC for QA purposes. I know that for the most part, Tylenol is going to contain 500mg of the primary ingredient when I buy it. Those portions are likely to be of good purity and uniform size. The off brand, might have more or less, of similar or dissimilar quality. I trust that US-based business for the most part actually care about their customers. It's a web of trust. Do I trust non-US business with manufacturing operations overseas? Not really when it comes to medication, no. 1: https://www.fairtradecertified.org/ https://www.fairtradecertified.org/
- bgorman 8y agoAn even better example is UL (Underwriters Laboratories), which directly tests products for safety.
- duxup 8y agoI'm not sure that works if building trust requires you to try it and .. hope for the best.
- dragontamer 8y ago> The solution is having a brand, and building that brand based on trust. You mean like Boeing's 737 MAX8 aircraft? Or Purdue pharma's Oxycotin (aka: that opioid that Purdue Pharma claimed was non-addicting, except it kick-started the entire opioid crisis because spoiler alert: its opium-based and therefore very very addicting?) 1. Big brands make mistakes. 2. Consumers don't know the brands: do you know whether or not your drugs are Purdue Pharma or not? 3. Brands are sold. The original company who made a brand may have cared very much about it. But 10 years or 20 years later, the brand may be owned by entirely new people. Either everyone has retired / moved on, so the company is simply consisting of new people... or maybe the brand was chopped-up and sold to 3 or 4 different companies. Quick: who owns Epipen right now? (That drug brand has been passed around at least 3 times in the past decade)
- testvox 8y agoMost of the libertarians I know are fine with the FDA doing research and providing information, maybe even requiring specific and true labeling for certain publicly sold goods. What they do not like is the FDA banning the sale of drugs or foods that they do not approve of, even with proper and true labeling. Because that is is just another attempt to take decisions away from people.
- duxup 8y agoYeah I think that is understandable, it's not all or nothing with the FDA, you certainly can approve of some aspects and be libertarian, and not approve of others and be libertarian and it all still makes sense philosophically.
- pochamago 8y agoI would add that its intensely slow process is the epitome of the harmful lumbering bureaucracy that libertarians react strongly against. Factory inspections are understandable, but the approval process takes so much time and effort it's no wonder generics cost far more than they should. The FDA has the power to move more quickly, but they have no incentive to do so
- CaptainZapp 8y agoLooking at the current "Kill all regulations" frenzy gripping the US I'd wager that they're brutally underfunded. Essentially the same problem that turned the FAA into Boeing's lapdog.
- theptip 8y agoSibling comments have given examples here, but the one-sentence summary would be that libertarians are in general opposed to licensure, and believe that a free market with certification (which would be provided by trusted private entities) is superior. In more detail, the argument goes something like "any time you require a license, you are necessarily reducing the choices available in the free market, and more choices are good." See e.g. Milton Friedman, "Capitalism and Freedom". I think the purist libertarian position on the FDA would be that it should be abolished and replaced with a private certification agency. But if you _must_ fund it with government money, it should be a certification body and not a licensing body.