7 ms·
https://www.nasa.gov/feature/langley/langley-aerodrome-created-to-explore-urban-air-mobility https://www.nasa.gov/feature/langley/langley-aerodrome-creat... I
by duxup 8y ago
https://www.nasa.gov/feature/langley/langley-aerodrome-created-to-explore-urban-air-mobility https://www.nasa.gov/feature/langley/langley-aerodrome-creat...
I assume this is 3D-printed from some 3D printing tech beyond what I've experienced buying some small 3D printed items that are temperature sensitive and kinda flexy?
- inflatableDodo 8y agoLaser sintering with powdered metal, at a guess. As an aside, if you get a basic jewellery casting setup, you can go from plastic printing to metal objects quite cheaply at home.
- newaccoutnas 8y agoHaving never seen a basic jewellery casting setup, would that scale to the size of components needed for UAV?
- inflatableDodo 8y agoDepends on the uav, but you could do components for a small one. I've printed legs for drones, and they were small enough that I could have done them in metal. The limiting factor without buying something hideously expensive is more about how much metal you want to have molten at once. For little parts you can use a bunsen burner and a small crucible. If you buy a pro setup, it flash melts the metal for you only at the moment it needs it. But they are expensive.
- WrtCdEvrydy 8y agoHonestly, Filamet makes this happen... Print with it and it's 30% PLA, and just kelnel fire it.
- Klathmon 8y agoThere are so many different kinds of 3d printing! While "FDM" or "FFF" 3d printing (the kind most people think of when they think 3d printing) is most common, there are tons of others. SLS can produce impossibly complex "solid" metal objects, SLA can use resins that have very unique properties (some extremely hard, others nearly perfectly transparent, etc...). Even if you don't leave the FDM style of 3d printing, there are tons of different techniques and plastics or plastic-hybrids that you can use. Often they can even be used on hobbyist level machines. Different kinds of plastics including Nylon and Polycarbonate, carbon-fiber infused filaments that have incredible tensile strength, even some metal-powder infused plastics which are designed to print, and then "bake" to harden them. It's a pretty awesome field with a lot of variation in what is possible even at the hobbyist level. Just looking at the video, it looks like they are using fairly "traditional" FDM 3d printing, but most likely with some unique filaments/plastics. If I had to take a complete shot in the dark at what they are using, i'd guess PEEK. It's a bitch and a half to print with using hobbyist devices (it needs a pretty high temperature and the ambient air needs to be kept quite hot to avoid warping), but it's extremely strong and very consistent.
- duxup 8y agoIt seems like a super interesting field. The fact that it all gets labeled under "3D printed" is confusing, granted ... also not wrong. I was at an exhibit about the space station and they had some tools they 3D printed to make completing some tasks easier. I was thinking "No way this could this go 'outside' of the space station if it is from the same material I've gotten that warns me not to expose it to high temps or high / low humidity, it probabbly would melt / crack instantly".
- Klathmon 8y agoPLA (the most common hobbyist plastic used) isn't all that good for functional stuff. It's extremely easy to print with, which is why it's used most commonly, but as you said it has a small temperature range where it's usable, it breaks down quickly under UV radiation, it gets pretty brittle, and it doesn't hold it's shape over repeated stress. I don't think it would "crack instantly" or melt in space right away, but it wouldn't work long term at all. But if you just go outside of that most basic plastic, there are tons of other options. Printing with PETG is just as simple in many cases, but it can withstand higher temperatures and is pretty easy to make watertight seals with. ABS is a great plastic that is also easy to print with once you learn the quirks. It is used a lot in automotive stuff since it's fairly resistant to a lot of temperatures and is pretty hard. Polycarbonate (PC) is also a great plastic to print with if you need it to withstand a lot of work and different temperatures. All of those can be printed on hobbyist machines, and I have all of them in the room next to me. And both PLA and ABS have been used on the space station and tools that the ISS 3d printer has printed have been used in space walks! It's pretty exciting stuff, and while what NASA is using is obviously more advanced than a $300 3d printer you can get online today, it's still using a lot of the same stuff and is pretty close to what you or I could print in our house if we wanted to.
- adamweld 8y ago> It's pretty exciting stuff, and while what NASA is using is obviously more advanced than a $300 3d printer you can get online today, it's still using a lot of the same stuff and is pretty close to what you or I could print in our house if we wanted to. Everything is correct except for this statement! From the video it looks like they are using an Ultimaker for some of these parts, which means you can get similar results even on a $200 Ender-3 (my go-to recommendation).
- zwieback 8y agoThe linked video shows them using an Ultimaker so it's pretty low-end tech they use for at least part of it. Unless those are non-functional models.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dogma1138 8y agoThe mechanical parts of the printer aren't that important pretty much all the printers can reach a good enough resolution for production. The biggest thing in 3D printing now is high end composite filaments and multi material applications. So for example if you print with PEEK (PolyEtherEtherKetone) or PEK/PEKK/PEKEKK you can print extremely strong parts which can be used for aerospace applications and even more. The problem is that those materials are very expensive PEEK can easily get to $250-300 per lb. and even higher for the better known brands and composite PEEK filaments (e.g. fibre reinforced PEEK). Beyond that you are limited by your print volume but many of the cheap printers especially the Chinese ones are pretty good in that regard. My largest 3D printer (Anycubic Chiron) has a custom print head (E3D Volcano) and custom drivers my hotend can reach 420c> so I can print with PEEK I just can't afford it, not to mention w/e NASA has used for this which I'll assume is probably even more expensive. That said I can print quadcopters and small drones with glass or carbon fibre reinforced nylon or PET easily and the 3D printed parts are usually the toughest part of those builds.
- mdorazio 8y agoBased on the size of most UAVs and the fact that it's NASA, they're almost certainly using a large format printer from Stratsys or 3D Systems in the $250K+ range.
- snazz 8y agoI would think so. One of the Stratasys engineers at their skunkworks division in Minnesota walked me through their process for printing something as large as a full-size table (upside down to minimize support material). The technology is really impressive but the uses seem few and far between.
- dogma1138 8y agoI have quite a few friends that work at Stratsys you’ll be surprised just how unimpressive their print quality actually is compared to many hobbyist printers. They are very consistent however especially at their volume and the material quality is also excellent which leads to very good production results. From the video at least they print the prop blades on an Ultimaker and an old one to boot this is something you can easily do at home. The body of the UAV looks like it is a skinned composite so it wasn’t fully 3D printed I’m guessing they printed a skeleton and then put composite sheets over it. This doesn’t look like anything you can’t print at home if you know what you are doing and have either a high end hobby printer or a custom built one.
- fsagx 8y agoMetal 3D printing technology is maturing rapidly. Many of the aerospace standard materials are available (aluminums and stainless steels, though titaniums seem to not quite be there yet). You won't find it in production much across the aerospace industry, except in trivial applications. ~Everyone~ is testing heavily, and trying to find the sweet spots where it makes sense. Probably a few more years before it flies on anything manned.
- Robotbeat 8y agoI think these are polycarbonate made on Stratasys machines. It's really a replacement for the slightly more labor-intensive methods of making stuff out of balsa and styrofoam, sanding and painting, fiberglassing, etc. You still need to sand and paint, to be sure, but... fairly precise shapes can be made directly without needing forms and guides, etc, so that saves on labor. Polycarbonate has a higher heat deflection temperature than the typical epoxies one might use in this sort of application. Stiffness is a little lower than epoxy, but not by much.
- 2muchcoffeeman 8y agoI watched the video and in one shot it clearly says Ultimaker 3. Looks like standard FDM. Maybe they can splurge and better filaments.