4 ms·
What would "mediate" mean? The EU is hardly in a position to actually address any security concerns.
by duxup 8y ago
What would "mediate" mean?
The EU is hardly in a position to actually address any security concerns.
- acqq 8y ago> The EU is hardly in a position to actually address any security concerns. Why?
- sgt101 8y agoBecause all the nations of Europe have significantly under invested in defence and security for decades. 'catchup' would require 30 -60%of one years EU gdp over 5-10years + current spend... Until that happens the EU is a spectator or victim.
- klingonopera 8y agoWe wouldn't need that much defense if we play out the US and China and Russia against each other. Apart from that - I had suspected that "security" meant "defense" and I think this is far less important globally, than many would like to believe. Of course if you're a country that doesn't know how to negotiate and compromise and do politics, all you'd know is military intervention.
- duxup 8y ago>We wouldn't need that much defense if we play out the US and China and Russia against each other. How does that work? If anything European history shows how non major players become the chips the players play for / the worst consequences land on them.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoMost of the significant Euro powers hit around the 2% NATO guide figure, the smaller ones don't, nor does Canada. Germany has some special restrictions on defence. Overall I doubt that deprives us a carrier group or tank division. America badly wanted Pax Americana, got it, and just as Pax Britannica and Pax Romana did, it costs.
- sgt101 8y agoThe US has spent double the nato figure the last decade. 2% per UK, Germany, France and Holland would be five carrier groups and ten divisions. Germany and Holland are really delinquent here, Holland now has no actual navy, Germany would be unable to mount any defence of itself or Poland in a war with Russia. This will matter in the next few years.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoThey have, but I'm not even convinced that's the result of the choice to seek the post-war US hegemony and Pax Americana, that's been a significant benefit to America. The US doesn't have to spend that, she chooses to. Drop rate to the Nato agreed 2% of GDP as well and still be the world's dominant and most advanced military power. Halve spending and the US would still reach the old two power standard in terms of spending - easily. It would be nearer a 3 power standard. Right now it's more than what, the next seven or eight combined? Germany has constitutional limits placed on her defence demanded by the post-WW2 allies, even if they did spend more. There's limits on when and how they can operate outside of Germany - though I'm very unclear on the detail. Holland may not have much navy - but it certainly still exists with frigates, submarines and what have you, and plans for new vessels - just rather few of them. They recently increased budget to get nearer that 2%. They've a population of about 15m, I think a modern carrier is simply out of reach without completely unbalancing their defence budget. They're way past their projecting power era anyway. I do completely agree all signatories should stick better to that Nato agreed 2% though, or any future agreed amount.
- acqq 8y agoI have understood the discussion to be in the domain of computer security not in "who has a bigger ... own nuclear weapons" or whatever. I can imagine that the former would be technically doable, if there were enough political support (e.g. also to demand on the highest level from the U.S. companies to provide for the technical support to the project which would be managed from Europe for Europe). But yes, politically, I understand there wouldn't be much readiness, because of the long term established practice of depending on the U.S. "solutions" even in these aspects.
- demarq 8y agowhy do you think that?
- mfatica 8y agoThe EU and it's leaders are incredibly weak. The only thing they've managed to do successfully is replace their own people with swaths of migrants
- duckMuppet 8y agoWell they managed to push thru GDPR, which has become an incredibly powerful tool for the elites and government bureaucracy over their people. I think they've even weaponized it against certain archival websites, a brilliant but obvious move for control of the people. The U.S. has so far stymied attempts at government control and regulation of the internet through tools such as net neutrality, But I fear this is short lived, after all, "the children"..
- oytis 8y agoReally, German government even failed to see any security threat in Kaspersky Antivirus on computers of public servicemen, and it is literally a backdoor for the Russian secret services.
- AnonymousPlanet 8y agoHow is this different from using an OS that sends the names of the files you have accessed to a foreign country if you don't use its enterprise version or have misconfigured it? A situation that is true throughout public services and across your entire country's industry.
- oytis 8y agoNot quite sure what you're referring to. They also failed to replace MS products with open-source alternatives, because, you know, the icons are on the wrong places.