5 ms·
The idea that nobody should get a goody if I can't get a goody, is the beginning of the race to the bottom.
by analog31 8y ago
The idea that nobody should get a goody if I can't get a goody, is the beginning of the race to the bottom.
- ALittleLight 8y agoMaybe - but you should also recognize that if you made sacrifices and spent a lot of money on something it would be annoying to discover that if you had made a less fiscally responsible choice it would have wound up working much better for you.
- refurb 8y agoDoes this also apply to the common complaints against the 1%? Just be happy that they have a ton of money even though you don’t?
- drusepth 8y agoI think it applies when you make the argument "They shouldn't be able to make millions if I can't also make millions."
- throw20102010 8y agoI think GP has a point that needs to be addressed if we ever want to do a debt forgiveness on a large scale without alienating a bunch of hard working people. It's not about keeping people from getting goodies, it's about rewarding responsible behavior. Imagine two students, Andy and Brady. Andy decided that it would be best to get good grades, so he took out more loans and worked less. Andy had more time to study so he got mostly A grades. Brady decided it would be best to get graduate debt free, so he worked long hours instead of taking more loans. Brady had less time to study so he got more B grades. At the typical US university, you might be able to call their outcomes balanced- Andy can maybe get a better job because he got better grades, but has to pay off more debt. Brady won't get quite as good of a job because of his B grades, but gets to start saving for retirement faster because he is debt free. But then some billionaire (call him Robert Smith, if we're trying to come up with the most generic name ever) comes and pays off Andy's debt. Now instead of a balanced outcome Andy is debt free and has a better job. Which is great for Andy, so I'm not saying the billionaire should't pay off his debt. But you have to think that Brady is probably kicking himself right now for not making a different set of choices. He's now behind in the race, and being behind sticks with you for a long time when it comes to careers. If we could find a solution that kept Brady from feeling bad, but still gave Andy his goodies, then I'm sure that most people would agree that is a good outcome. An easy one that comes to mind is instead of saying, "I'm paying off all your student loan debt," Smith could say, "I'm giving you each $100k." That way Andy and Brady both get goodies, and Andy doesn't have crippling debt any more. Brady also doesn't kick himself for working hard during college because he now has a nice sum of money to do something responsible with (invest, save for retirement, down payment on a house, etc.).
- supernova87a 8y agoAgreed, a flat $ gift to every person would be more satisfactory.