3 ms·
This seems worse in almost every respect than a hydrodynamic stormwater separator. With the latter, you pop open a manhole cover and suck out the goo with a vac
by amluto 8y ago
This seems worse in almost every respect than a hydrodynamic stormwater separator. With the latter, you pop open a manhole cover and suck out the goo with a vacuum truck. With a net, you have to somehow pick it up without spilling the contents. Then you hope you can empty it without destroying it or you replace it. This sounds much harder.
Oh, and hydrodynamic separators claim to catch oils, too.
- bootlooped 8y agoThe only benefit I can think of is that it is probably easier to retrofit onto existing installations.
- manigandham 8y agoHow much do those cost though?
- ricardobeat 8y agoThat only works for vertical storm drains, no? Could it be installed in outflow pipes as seen in the pictures? And what about cost?
- VSerge 8y agoLooking around, a number of widths exist for these systems, and installing what is called pre-cast units would start at about 10k$ for the smallest (4ft in diameter), and go up from there (see EPA paper below for additional details). Maintenance costs are said to be really low in what I could find (1000$ a year or so), as maintenance (emptying the trash) can be done by one vacuum truck in 30 minutes. So it may be a better choice for systems that are there to last rather than nets, but nets would still be best for temporary sites. http://www.water-research.net/Waterlibrary/Stormwater/hydrodynamic.pdf http://www.water-research.net/Waterlibrary/Stormwater/hydrod...
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoTextbook example of perfect being the enemy of good. If we can't solve the problem 100% with this (cheap, easy to retrofit) method then why even try?