3 ms·
They do mention that all the growth being in EVs means traditional vehicles get less investment. This is somewhat understating the problem for existing manufact
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
They do mention that all the growth being in EVs means traditional vehicles get less investment. This is somewhat understating the problem for existing manufacturers. Basically what is going on is that EV manufacturers like Tesla are growing straight into what are the most profitable and lucrative segments of the market. This is why they are so disruptive.
This is creating a lot of demand in a market that is supply limited (e.g. batteries). So that means that short term they have less of a need to actually be in a hurry to scale down to cheaper models.
Margins at the high end are pretty sweet and Tesla has shown pretty convincingly people are willing to buy their products at a premium. Like Apple is not interested in selling cheap phones, Tesla may not be that interested in selling lots of cheap cars with much smaller margins.
The drama around the 35K $ Tesla has shown Tesla dragging their heels there. Technically it's a software limited version of a product they sell at much higher prices. The only way it makes sense for them to not take the extra money is if they would have a demand problem for those more expensive models. They don't. Everything they build ships and they are building and shipping as fast as they can already in a market that is outgrowing their capacity to grow.
So, I think 2038 is pretty reasonable. In the time between then and now, many existing manufacturers will disappear allowing the remaining ones to milk the market a bit longer. E.g. GM closing many of their product lines last year helps other manufacturers as it removes a competitor from the market. Meanwhile it just takes time and major investments to ramp up new production capacity. This won't happen overnight. IMHO much of that capacity may end up being created by new companies. ICE production capacity is a liability at this point. GM did the right thing of ripping off that band-aid and taking that pain early.
- josteink 8y ago> Like Apple is not interested in selling cheap phones, Tesla may not be that interested in selling lots of cheap cars with much smaller margins. Except Elon Musk stating his intention is the exact opposite. He sees ICE cars as a threat to the future of this planet and want them replaced by something less harmful as quickly as possible, and Tesla is the means to that end. Everything they’ve built so far has been done to prepare for decent mass-market EVs, like the Model 3. The high-end market is lucrative though and therefore this is where he’s starting to get competition from traditional auto-vendors, now that he has proven for them the viability of selling luxury EVs.
- HeadsUpHigh 8y agoBut they have slowed down their drive towards lower priced cars significantly. The model Y was supposed to be ~25k. Instead they chose to go after the much more expensive SUV market. Makes perfect sense, Tesla needs to improve their financials before they can ask for more money to make new factories. Battery supply is limited and the costs are still fairly high so they are focusing on a higher margin product. At the same time I think they might be holding off for better autopilot before they make the truly cheap model.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoA funny thing with the Model 3 is that people seem to select the more expensive models where most of the differentiation with the lower priced models is software. Basically what that means is they build the same car and price it a few thousand more to toggle a few software switches. Turning off those features only makes sense when you can't sell at the higher price. Basically you sacrifice margins for volume. Turns out that so far they get away with not needing to do that and they definitely need the cash. So they built the 35K model 3 and then realized they could be selling it for 45K+. As long as they can sell as fast as they can build these things, why would they lower their prices?
- thedag2805 8y agoIt isn't accurate to describe it this way at all. The low-end versions have a smaller battery pack, a smaller inverter, one motor and differential instead of two, AND software limitations that do things like disable some of the speakers. It's not a sound way of doing things at all, but it helps Teslas short-term objectives. Delivery takes a long time to Europe and China when the cars are made in California and Nevada. By limiting the hardware variation (but not eliminating it, as you seem to believe) you can make cars and ship them before they are ordered and be reasonably sure somebody will buy cars that match, perhaps with different software configuration (a different license, really). As you say yourself, it wouldn't make sense to sell the lower-priced versions unless you've run out of demand for the more expensive ones. Why you don't conclude like everyone else that they have indeed fulfilled the demand for the more expensive versions is unclear. I'm pretty sure they have. What's more, they now have the problem today their cheapest model is also the best. Model 3 is especially a much better grand tourer than the S or X, it's efficiency making it go farther and charge faster. A company improving its products so fast that they cannibalise the old ones isn't necessarily a bad thing, but it works better if you've made back the investment you made on the old product first! I really hope Tesla makes it through the storm (I own one, so it would be something of a catastrophe for me if they don't!), but it's much more important that regulators follow through and ensure EVs are adopted ASAP. They are good for the national economy as well as the environment, at least if you're not Germany.