3 ms·
To me the most interesting part of the article was the means of befouling: the idea that the release of information does not need to have a direct effect, rathe
by nkurz 16y ago
To me the most interesting part of the article was the means of befouling: the idea that the release of information does not need to have a direct effect, rather that the process of leaking will cause the targeted organization to change its own behaviour from within. I had not previously considered these secondary effects.
If an organization (government, corporate, scientific) thinks that its actions will be scrutinized and that the walls have ears, and if internally it realizes that its methods are questionable and embarrassing, it will become paralyzed with fear of discovery and less able to act effectively. Like an allergic reaction, the leaks themselves are not the point --- it's the body's autoimmune response to the leaks that can be life threatening.
- panarky 16y agoRight. It's not about the cables themselves, it's about driving the government apparatus to degrade its own effectiveness by tightening security, increasing compartmentalization and reducing collaboration. The genius of this approach is its asymmetry. In response to Bin Laden's 'investment' of $100,000 and 19 lives, the US sacrificed thousands of soldiers, spent trillions of dollars and destroyed a reputation and moral authority that took generations to build. The US did most of the damage itself. Similarly, in response to Wikileaks' disclosures that mostly confirm what's already well known, the US is already overreacting. Looks the US is well on its way to multiplying Wikileaks' investment untold thousands of times.