4 ms·
I have a problem with the recent practice of using innocuous places like ancestry.com as a tool to find murderers through their familial relationships. Definit
by rootusrootus 8y ago
I have a problem with the recent practice of using innocuous places like ancestry.com as a tool to find murderers through their familial relationships. Definitely I think we need to see some more regulation there.
But, as a separate issue, when there is enough evidence to convince a judge to sign a warrant, I do not have an objection to exhuming a body. I have to trust the judicial system to handle this sanely.
- criddell 8y agoWhat are the downsides of using databases like ancestry.com to solve crimes?
- droithomme 8y agoForensic testing of DNA looks at 13 positions. 9 out of 13 is considered a match. When you match against a very large database using such a small number of polymorphisms, you get many matches. Detectives then take that list and look for people who lived sort of in the crime area. The matches who don't happen to have an alibi they can prove for a crime sometimes decades ago are then deemed "guilty". It's complete pseudoscience. If they did a full DNA sequence and matched that, sure. But they never do. Also there is the problem that many DNA samples contain DNA from multiple individuals, in which the match can be assembled piecemeal. This completely destroys the statistical validity. DNA forensics are absolute pseudoscience. Any court case relying on DNA should be discarded by the jury.
- dahinds 8y agoThese are not conventional forensic DNA tests.
- paxys 8y agoIt's not "pseudoscience" but literally how everything is investigated, DNA or not. There is always a process of elimination, strong vs weak evidence, probable cause, and many more factors. Audio/video surveillance, alibis, even eyewitness reports and just about everything else can be unreliable, incorrect or faked. That's why police gather all kinds of evidence and present it to a jury.
- droithomme 8y ago> That's why police gather all kinds of evidence and present it to a jury. There was no jury evaluating evidence and deciding guilt or innocence in this case. There was also no case. Only a proclamation of guilt against a man who died long ago and had no ability to defend himself, no defense attorney assigned, no arguments made before a jury whatsoever. The only "forensic" evidence made by some dodgy startup pushing this story to sell their "services". That's not justice at all. It's not even a caricature of justice. It's complete and absolute nonsense. Holding this up as an example of a done guilty man found is an atrocity and everyone doing so should be deeply ashamed.
- ljf 8y agoDid you not read that they dug him up to do a full dna analysis to compare to seen found in the victims underwear? And that there was other evidence to link him which is what led to the permission to exhume him? The only reason that this wasn't taken further is as he was dead.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jfk13 8y agoThe issue remains, though, that if he were alive all this evidence would result in a trial -- at which the prosecution would have had to prove their case beyond reasonable doubt. The accused would have the opportunity to defend himself, to have legal representation, to present evidence that might call into question or contradict aspects of the prosecution's case, etc. As it stands, it seems that due process has been bypassed. I'm troubled by the idea that in the case of a dead defendant, it's OK to bring in a guilty verdict on the basis of an entirely one-sided "trial".
- sokoloff 8y agoLegally, this is not a guilty verdict, precisely because of the due process issue you cite.
- Data_Junkie 8y agoRegulation is only to stop harm. Who does this hurt ? I don't think capturing criminals counts as harm. It's not trust that's needed, what's not to trust ?