4 ms·
> the analogy he draws is the correct one: the sun actually works Under, as I said, very different conditions from those which Earthbound fusion reactors are a
by pdonis 8y ago
> the analogy he draws is the correct one: the sun actually works
Under, as I said, very different conditions from those which Earthbound fusion reactors are attempting. The only meaningful similarity between the two is that both are fusion reactions. You certainly cannot use numbers for the Sun to make any valid estimates about Earthbound fusion reactors, as the poster I responded to was attempting to do.
> Earthbound" controlled nuclear fusion doesn't in any meaningful way relating to energy production.
It hasn't yet, but that doesn't mean it never will. If it does, it certainly will not be by reproducing conditions similar to those that produce fusion in the Sun. And if your criticisms of fusion power turn out to be valid and it never works, then everything the poster I responded to said is irrelevant anyway, since he was assuming fusion power would work.
> If you can do controlled nuclear fusion, you have a really, really scary weapon.
No, you don't, because, as I said, only a very small amount of fuel is in the reactor at any given time--enough for a few seconds' worth of energy production. That equates to the energy equivalent of a few tons of TNT, not a few megatons. And since the entire system is designed to remove that amount of energy at that rate, concerns about even that few tons of TNT energy equivalent "exploding" are invalid--that amount of fuel undergoing complete fusion and liberating all that energy is what the reactor is designed for, not an abnormal condition. And, as I said, all you need to do to stop energy production is stop injecting fuel, and the reactor shuts down.
Again, a fusion reactor is very different from a fusion bomb.
- scottlocklin 8y agoYes, "earthbound" fusion reactors are attempting very different conditions from the sun: that's what I said. The sun is the only reason anyone thinks a sustained, controlled fusion reaction is possible: there are no other examples, and the idea that we can do arbitrary (and high) energy densities of sustainable controlled fusion is wishful thinking. All the results thus far are that we don't know how to do this. Nature may prevent it completely. If we do figure out how to do this, of course the possibility of a controlled fusion reactor can be used as an absurdly powerful weapon. You've basically invented something that can make gigawatts of energy appear in a small volume. Sure, a power-generating fusion reactor won't make as big a mess as a fission reactor if there is a fault. That's not the point. If you know how to do this, you can design a system where you can open a hole in one end and point it at things you don't like. And people most certainly will do this if they can. Making the non-proliferation aspects of such a postulated technology absurd. Imagine you could build a NIF type device that actually was sustainable, and you could fit into a truck. Just the neutron flux from the thing would be absurdly murderous, and even using NIF figures (~200MJ), being able to direct the energy of some fraction of a ton of TNT worth of energy at things you don't like, fueled by a tiny amount of hydrogen seems pretty dangerous to me.
- pdonis 8y ago> The sun is the only reason anyone thinks a sustained, controlled fusion reaction is possible No, it isn't. We think it's possible because we have extensive experimental data on fusion reactions from Earthbound experiments. From those experiments we know a wide range of possible conditions that can produce sustained, controlled fusion. The conditions inside the Sun are only a very narrow part of that range. > You've basically invented something that can make gigawatts of energy appear in a small volume. You do realize that any power plant that is making gigawatts of energy has the same amount of fuel energy content inside it as a fusion reactor, right? A coal plant that is making a gigawatt of energy has a ton or so of TNT's worth of fuel energy inside it at any given time, just like a fusion reactor. There is no difference between them in terms of weapon potential. It's true that the amount of fusion fuel needed to make a ton or so of TNT's worth of energy occupies a much smaller volume than the amount of coal or oil or natural gas needed to make that amount of energy, but so what? It's the energy content that matters, not the volume. > Imagine you could build a NIF type device that actually was sustainable, and you could fit into a truck. That means you're building a laser capable of short pulses of gigawatts of power that can fit into a truck. If you can build that, you don't need to include a pellet of fusion fuel with it to make it a weapon. Also, nobody is talking about building gigawatt fusion reactors that can fit into trucks. They're large facilities, just like other power plants. > being able to direct the energy of some fraction of a ton of TNT worth of energy at things you don't like We already have weapons that can do this, and are much cheaper than building a fusion reactor with a hole in the side of it would be. They're called missiles.
- scottlocklin 8y ago>No, it isn't. We think it's possible because we have extensive experimental data on fusion reactions from Earthbound experiments. From those experiments we know a wide range of possible conditions that can produce sustained, controlled fusion. There is zero evidence sustained, controlled, above break-even fusion works at the types of energy densities people talk about for power plants. None; keine, zero, zilch: there is arguably as much evidence for this as the existence of ghosts or leprechauns. The models don't work! I ain't saying we shouldn't try, but there are by now reasonable arguments to be made that it's a big waste of time and money better spent on something boring that we know will work, like thorium. To make another technological analogy from nature: if the earth's gravitational potential well were larger, we wouldn't have been able to achieve orbit using chemical rockets. The specific impulse of fuels which exist in the periodic table of the elements would have been insufficient to achieve this. For example: https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.04727 https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.04727 -similarly, the properties of plasmas may make it impossible to achieve controlled, above break-even nuclear fusion in a conveniently small and dense volume. There is at present no evidence that it can be achieved. They've been working on it for 65 or 70 years now depending on how you count things, you'd think there would be some positive indications by now beyond optimistic press releases. As for your wishful thinking that a controlled nuclear fusion technology couldn't be used as a weapon, well, there you go again with that wishful thinking. Controlled fusion is a non-proliferation nightmare. Should this actually come to pass and become routine enough to be a meaningful part of the power grid, it will be a hell of a lot easier to build a fusion howitzer than an ICBM with H bomb at the business end of it. I mean, you're a nuclear physicist, man!