3 ms·
That's assuming that we use the same order of magnitude of energy. If the promise of a technology is that we can use several orders of magnitude more energy pe
by epistasis 8y ago
That's assuming that we use the same order of magnitude of energy.
If the promise of a technology is that we can use several orders of magnitude more energy per person, then that .1W/m2 could become 10W/m2.
If we don't increase energy usage, sure, no big deal, but the entire point of pursuing fusion is to enable fantastically more energy usage, at least as I see it.
So we also need a second revolutionary technology, direct conversion of energy rather than thermal energy conversion.
Fusion will never be a cost winner if it's using thermal energy conversion, anyway. Solar and wind will soon undercut the steam turbine lifetime costs, so even if the fusion part were free, there's no way for heat engines to compete on cost.
- tomatotomato37 8y agoI have the feeling when we do hit the first milestone on the Kardashev scale that we'll have a lot more options available to mitigate terrestrial concerns, so let's just concentrate on getting there without killing the planet first
- mrec 8y agoI've never understood why people get excited about the Kardashev scale. It's a proposal for classifying civilizations which has no place for the one and only civilization we actually know of. Doesn't that make it kind of silly?
- roenxi 8y agoIt works great for conversation like this. It lets a person summarise 1 wiki page worth of assumptions and definitions into a single line and quickly establishes an order-of-magnitude scale to frame the discussion. Fiction, science fiction and storytelling generally are ideal for that sort of usage. They let people pre-consider a lot of the arguments and assumptions of the people they are talking to.
- 14 8y agoI agree that I would like more energy. If it was limitless you could do all sorts of things that are not really worth it today. Imagine being able to have a hot water tank at the back of your property just because it is nice to wash your hands with warm water. Or to keep your bathroom floor always heated. May as well get a hot tub can finally afford to power that year around. I could go on forever if I had cheap energy. So as you say energy consumption may go up if made possible.
- llukas 8y ago> If the promise of a technology is that we can use several orders of magnitude more energy per person, then that .1W/m2 could become 10W/m2. Depending on what type of energy you exactly have in mind. It is totally possible to increase consumption of iee. electric energy and reduce overall energy needs. We burn most of the fuels and use them very inefficiently: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primary_energy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primary_energy In short: you need to burn coal with 3x as much energy to generate 1x of electricity. So when you switch from coal to nuclear (or renewable) and increase 2x your energy usage you still come up ahead in total primary energy consumption.
- pdonis 8y agoThis comparison isn't valid for nuclear; nuclear power plants use steam turbines to convert heat to electricity, just like coal plants do, and the thermal efficiency (fraction of energy from burning the fuel that actually becomes electrical energy) is about the same.
- llukas 8y agoOK, I double checked and you're right. Nuclear is counted properly difference is only for renewables: https://energypost.eu/iea-underreports-contribution-solar-wind-factor-three-compared-fossil-fuels/ https://energypost.eu/iea-underreports-contribution-solar-wi...
- pdonis 8y ago> the entire point of pursuing fusion is to enable fantastically more energy usage No, it's to enable enough energy usage for, as MacKay says, a first world standard of living for the entire world's population, instead of just a small fraction of it. That's more than today, but not fantastically more. Also, as technology advances, the energy usage required for a first world standard of living goes down. Our entire house now has LED bulbs; that cuts our energy usage for lighting to about 10% of what used to be the standard (incandescent bulbs), or about a third of the previous "low energy" standard (fluorescent bulbs--which also have hazmat issues since they contain mercury). Computers today use only a small fraction of the energy of older computers while still delivering more computing power. HVAC systems and refrigerators are more and more efficient. Cars are more efficient--I have a small SUV with a four cylinder engine (up until a few years ago I would never have even considered a four cylinder engine for an SUV, but this one has good enough performance) that gets better gas mileage than the 4-door sedan with a V6 engine that I had before it. The list goes on.